Taboo Memories, Diasporic Voices is a collection of Ella Shohat's landmark writings from the last two decades, including both new and republished essays. Taken together, this collection makes a set of indispensable arguments about the interplay between culture, empire, race, gender, and the politics of representation in dissimilar geohistorical contexts. This kind of comparativist inquiry is at the crux of Shohat's intellectual project and turns on a critical method that she refers to as “relationality,” that is, a mode of scholarly inquiry that “stress[es] the horizontal and vertical links that thread communities and histories together in a conflictual network” (p. 207). A relational approach, Shohat contends, “operates at once within, between and beyond the nation--state framework, [and] calls attention to the conflictual, hybrid interplay between communities within and across borders” (p. 207). “Relationality” should not be misread as “transnationality” in any limited sense. The term also marks Shohat's investment in “crossovers and echoes” between scholarly disciplines, theoretical vocabularies, and historical contexts (p. xiv).
The collection's thematic and theoretical range is broad. Taboo Memories includes discussion of feminist, postcolonial, and transnational debates; critical interrogations of Third World cinema and media theory; and grounded analyses of the links among race, gender, and empire. Much of this material will be extremely useful for scholars working in Middle East studies because it offers a set of theoretical paradigms and interdisciplinary linkages that remain beyond the purview of much Middle East studies writing to date. Middle East contexts and archives can be found throughout the volume. Her writing on cinema is attentive to what she calls the “Cinematic Orient,” particularly as manifest in the figure of the harem (“Gender and the Culture of Empire”). Elsewhere she queries the image of Cleopatra as it has circulated in contemporary media debates (“Disorienting Cleopatra”), an essay important for the ways it brings questions of race to bear on Orientalist discourses. Many of Shohat's landmark writings on Zionist discourse and cultural production are reprinted in this volume, the extension of a project that first came to the attention of most U.S. academics with Shohat's first monograph, Israeli Cinema: East/West and the Politics of Representation (1987). Her work in this area has been bold and trailblazing, challenging dominant Israeli political paradigms and the prevailing terms by which academics have studied the Zionist project. Shohat's insistence on reading the Israeli nation–state through a colonial lens has been met with considerable unease among Israeli publics—particularly so in the 1980s, before the Oslo process made such conversations more palatable within the Israeli academy and popular media. In the two decades since, scholars in both the Israeli and U.S. academies have increasingly used the language of colonialism to narrate the Israeli nation-making project. Yet very few scholars working on either Israeli or Palestinian cultural studies have substantially engaged in postcolonial theoretical debates or brought postcolonial analytics to bear on their scholarship—this despite the founding imprint of Edward Said on the postcolonial field. Ella Shohat's work remains groundbreaking in this regard.
Most of Shohat's writing on Israeli cultural politics has been concerned with the status of Arab-Jews (or Mizrahim) in Israel, namely, their history of dispossession by and within the Israeli state and the ways that Israeli popular culture and discourse have participated in this dispossession. Indeed, it was Shohat that brought Mizrahim to the attention of the U.S. academy with her 1988 essay “Sephardim in Israel: Zionism from the Standpoint of its Jewish Victims,” a rejoinder to Edward Said in The Question of Palestine. Many of the essays in this book continue this important project, pushing her earlier work in new directions. The territory covered is expansive, including attention to the racial logics of Israeli modernization discourse, the blind spots within Zionist historiography, and the “invention of the Mizrahim” (p. 332) by state and popular Israeli discourse, as well as critical discussion of the importation of postcolonial theory into the Israeli academy. Her work in these areas is always comparative in ways that push powerfully against the discourse of Zionist exceptionalism. In “Taboo Memories, Diasporic Visions: Columbus, Palestine, and Arab-Jews,” she urges us to consider the linkages between histories that are not traditionally viewed in tandem, arguing that “[t]he same historical process that dispossessed Palestinians of their property, lands, and national-political rights was intimately linked to the process that affected the dispossession of Arab-Jews from their property, lands, and rootedness in Arab countries” (p. 222). This linkage forcefully inscribes Mizrahim onto the cultural geography of the Arab Middle East even as it asks that our studies of the Israeli occupation also be mindful of repressive state processes within Israel's borders. Although somewhat overshadowed in this volume, Shohat is also making a bold call for a new Mizrahi studies—a relational mode of scholarly inquiry that would map Mizrahim transnationally in ways that refuse the hermeticism of both Zionist and Arab nationalist historiography.
Shohat's methodological contributions are, in and of themselves, considerable—particularly so for scholars working in the Middle East studies context. Taken together, the essays in this collection productively disorient the field of Middle East studies, introducing a set of analytics and methodologies that many scholars in the field have engaged only reluctantly at best. Shohat poses a version of this methodological provocation in her introduction: “One of the challenges facing multicultural/transnational feminism has to do with the translation of theories and actions from one context to another. In an Arab Muslim context, where feminism is often denounced as a Western import, and where Arab Muslim women articulate their version of what constitutes gender struggle, what would it mean to deploy a poststructuralist perspective that would critique the notions of experience, authenticity, and essentialism?” (p. 7). Like other questions posed in the volume's introduction, this one is meant to stimulate a rethinking of prevailing scholarly paradigms rather than to provide a facile blueprint for their remaking. Taboo Memories, Diasporic Voices is indispensable reading for those engaged in the important work of pushing Middle East studies further.
