A careful observer might reasonably nominate the first decade of the twentieth century as the nadir of the political empowerment, civil equality, and physical security of African Americans in the United States from the end of the Civil War to the beginning of the civil rights era. The Supreme Court’s 1896 ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson invited states to implement legal segregation, leading conservative whites to lay the constitutional foundations for supremacist states in the South. The Justices followed up with Hodges v. United States in 1906, further limiting possibilities for federal intervention into the appalling labor conditions in the South. Lynchings were frequent occurrences, at times ignored and at other times abetted by law enforcement officials. The Supreme Court’s only expression of outrage about the tide of deadly violence came when a sheriff allowed a black man to be lynched after the Justices had issued a stay of execution to consider his appeal (See: United States v. Shipp, 1909).
The same careful observer would, however, avoid a simple conclusion that things didn’t get much better until Brown v. Board of Education and instead would note that by the late 1920s, the Court had begun to look like a potential policy space for reform. The Justices had struck down Oklahoma’s grandfather clause, which limited the right to vote to whites, (Guinn v. United States, 1915); prevented states and localities from imposing residential segregation (Buchanan v. Warley, 1917); and in 1923 overturned the convictions and death sentences of several blacks issued through mob-supervised trials in Arkansas (Moore v. Dempsey). Megan Ming Francis’s fine study looks to explain how the federal courts became the stage upon which Jim Crow was ultimately dismantled. In the course of explaining this development, Francis reconceptualizes the process of development to incorporate a more careful consideration of non-state actors and their capacity to change cultural conversations. Such actors’ engagements can influence both how public conversations about issues unfold and how receptive national institutions are to initiatives, thereby priming the political sphere for concrete institutional change wrought by formal political actors. She seeks to change the conversation both about the timing of civil rights reform, identifying it as starting earlier than conventional narratives, and about how American political development conceptualizes both development and change, illustrating that cultural and rhetorical shifts engineered by reform-minded groups can prime the ground for the kinds of policy shifts that conventional scholarship more readily recognizes as substantial effects. The book does an excellent job with both of these agendas, though its contributions can be enhanced by placing it into dialogue with other recent works that share these interests. Taken as a body, Francis’s book along with other projects noted in this review make a compelling case for rethinking the story of race and political development in the early twentieth century and for embracing a broader understanding of how development happens and what it is.
Francis focuses on the early years of the NAACP, taking its campaign against lynching rather than its later fight to desegregate schools as its first politically effective moment. The conventional wisdom about lynching is that, while prominent African Americans agitated against it and actively pursued federal intervention to address a rising epidemic of violence and death in the early twentieth century, their efforts were in vain, foundering against the implacable resistance of powerful southern Democrats in the Senate, who blocked the enactment of national anti-lynching legislation. Francis argues that the NAACP’s campaign against lynching was not fruitless, despite its failure to achieve concrete policy change. Its major yet under-recognized accomplishments included successfully pressuring the executive branch to acknowledge lynching publicly and rhetorically oppose it, to convince many legislators in the House that racial violence was a national problem in need of a national solution, and to identify the federal courts as the institutional location where Jim Crow could be rendered vulnerable. This last accomplishment set the stage for the march toward Brown, both by locating a national institution that might be convinced to act on behalf of blacks and by demonstrating to its supporters that the NAACP could achieve victories for its constituents, encouraging increased emotional and financial investment in the organization. Francis’s study vividly illustrates what political science misses when it designates campaigns without concrete policy outcomes as failures and omits them from developmental analysis.
Francis relies on the NAACP’s records and other primary sources as well as secondary analysis to construct her account of the campaign against lynching and its significance. She argues that the anti-lynching campaign pursued between 1909 and the mid 1920s, not the organization’s decision to invest in educational desegregation in the late 1920s and early 1930s, was the critical factor in establishing the NAACP’s efficacy and the dominance of litigation as a strategy afterwards. She argues further that this campaign produced results that primed the legal system for acceptance of the NAACP’s standpoints. Her focus on the NAACP emphasizes an emerging theme in the study of American political development— that an exclusive focus on state institutions and institutional actors overlooks both important catalysts for change and change itself, including a reconsideration of what kinds of indicators we should be seeking in order to understand to understand how and why change happens.
In Francis’s book, the NAACP is an independent and motive force in development, and its strategic choices shape how development unfolds. Other scholars have studied the organization, primarily from the standpoint of social movement theory, but much of the focus in political science and among legal historians has been on the years between the 1930s and the 1960s, and has addressed the NAACP’s efforts to desegregate schools and to assail formal legal discrimination in federal and state policy. Francis focuses on the earlier years and counters the commonly held perception that the NAACP achieved nothing substantial in its efforts with the executive branch and Congress. In an argument reminiscent of Michael McCann’s study of equal pay litigation in the 1990s (Rights at Work: Pay Equity Reform and Politics of Legal Mobilization, 1994), Francis argues that the campaign against lynching changed elite conversations about the phenomenon by bringing attention to it and situating it as a moral horror and crime against democracy. While these shifts did not produce immediate policy reform and thus would not be recognized in conventional studies of American political development as changes, they primed national political culture and created an environment in which the federal courts could, and did, engineer policy shifts.
Francis’s work raises important questions about how to conceptualize change and what kinds of agents scholars interested in understanding development should study. Even if one sticks with a narrow understanding of change, recognizing that institutions do not act in a vacuum is significant, and tracing the impact of organizations on public institutions is important. Francis also suggests that shifting ideas and rhetorical frameworks can be as consequential as concrete policy changes and indeed can pave the way for them. The NAACP’s early work, even though it did not produce policy change, changed the ways that elites talked about race and generated an accessible narrative about lynching as a moral wrong perpetrated by white mobs against blacks.
Francis’s work relates well to other efforts to enrich conventional narratives of race and development in the early 20th century, dispelling the impression that not much of great consequence happened between 1896 and the dawn of the civil rights movement. Her study tells the national and NAACP-centered part of the story, bolstering other analyses of this era that address how other non-state actors tried to work within the state structure in the South to build reform. The power of her argument can be enhanced, however, by engaging with scholars who make two related arguments: first, how advocates for blacks in the South sought to soften the impact of Jim Crow in the difficult years prior to World War II; and second, precisely how not just activism, but changing ideas, influenced the political landscape in these years. The first observation enhances our historical understanding of how the road to Brown and the demise of Jim Crow was paved, and the second further reinforces a broadened understanding of how ideas, expressed in discursive frameworks within bounded interpretive communities, can achieve change—and where these boundaries place limits on the scope of change.
Kimberley Johnson’s work on Jim Crow reform explores how local reformers engaged with Jim Crow regimes between 1910 and 1954 (Reforming Jim Crow: Southern Politics and State in the Age before Brown, 2010). These reformers sought at first to soften the edges of the supremacist state structure and later to establish a system that was, while still separate, more equal. In her analysis, the pressure to institute national legislation against lynching strengthened the hand of southern reformers by enabling them to argue that if the states did not act, the federal government would. Yet their desire to stem the tide of violence was not merely a wish to preserve local control over race relations. They pressed the idea that “lynching and lawlessness were two facets of a disease that threatened to weaken the legitimacy and authority of the Jim Crow order” and worked to transform the cultural narrative around lynching from one of protection of vulnerable white women to one of bad government and social disorder (Johnson 2010, 45). She argues that major outbreaks of racialized violence during and after World War I catalyzed the emergence of a reform movement based in the South, spearheaded by the Commission on Interracial Cooperation and its related organization, the Association of Southern Women for the Prevention of Lynching (Johnson 2010, 48–49). Lynching rates did drop after 1920, even without federal legislative intervention, and the southern-based campaign produced weak anti-lynching laws in South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia (Id. at 53). While these efforts primarily targeted extralegal “mob” violence and did not address completely illegitimate or procedurally bankrupt legal proceedings resulting in death sentences, they augmented the NAACP’s efforts to change the national conversation around lynching.
How, though, does changing a conversation make a difference? Pamela Brandwein’s work shows that the embedding of an interpretation can have significant concrete effects on how state power operates, and that interpretive communities are not limited to state actors (Rethinking the Judicial Settlement of Reconstruction, 2011). She reconsiders the Civil Rights Cases, the notorious Supreme Court decision of 1883 commonly understood to have prevented federal remediation under the fourteenth amendment of private discriminatory action. She shows that the strangled understanding of the fourteenth amendment’s reach dates not from the Waite Court that produced the 1883 ruling, but rather from the successor Fuller Court, abetted by a school of historians sympathetic to the South and hostile to Reconstruction-era efforts to raise blacks to fuller citizenship. Brandwein’s work augments Francis’s project by providing a model for how to trace the shift of an interpretive framework and its adoption by policymakers. Brandwein’s turn to the sociological theory of frame analysis clarifies the mechanisms through which ideational change can produce change in policy outcomes.
Marek Steedman’s research on the complex and codependent relationship between southern liberalism and racial hierarchy also enhances thinking about how ideas matter, adding in the importance of ideational development among non-state actors (Jim Crow Citizenship: Liberalism and the Southern Defense of Racial Hierarchy, 2012). Like Johnson, he considers progressives and reformers in the South, but his goal is to explain how white southern progressives reconciled their simultaneous commitments to liberalism and to maintaining racial hierarchy. He argues that, “the ideological work performed by white southern Progressives was instrumental to the establishment of white supremacist institutions in the heart of a putatively liberal democracy” (Steedman 2012, 1). This work did more than simply justifying the legitimacy of supremacy. It shaped supremacy’s very fabric by embedding it in laws written and enforced through putatively liberal procedural practices. This concrete imposition of ideas developed and promoted by non-state actors had a profound effect on securing the perceived legitimacy of Jim Crow for many generations.
Other work highlights, as Francis does, how organizations of committed activists can change frameworks for problems, thereby increasing pressure on state institutions to act. One aspect of the NAACP’s work that could be further explored in this period is how their research into lynching augmented state capacity by enabling the state to perceive the scope of a problem. This dynamic parallels the efforts of the Humane Society in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, as their private inspectors cataloged instances of animal abuse and pressed for state action to address it (Susan Pearson and Kimberley Smith, “Developing the Animal Welfare State,” in Statebuilding from the Margins: Between Reconstruction and the New Deal, 2014). It also calls to mind the involvement of the Better Homes of America in setting standards for appropriate housing that later formed the model for government standards (James Greer, “The Better Homes Movement and the Origins of Redlining in the United States,” in Statebuilding from the Margins: Between Reconstruction and the New Deal, 2014). These analyses, like that of Steedman and Brandwein, explain well how organizational engagement with the state enabled activists to mobilize the state or to encourage state actors to implement desired policies through the borrowing of the organizations’ resources. To what extent did federal investigations of lynching rely on the NAACP’s research efforts? How did NAACP investigations ground policymakers’ factual observations about the practice of lynching and its impact? In what circumstances could the NAACP persuade policymakers to accept their empirical findings, thereby bolstering state investigative capacity? These questions, which Francis’s work suggests are highly important, ground a better understanding of how the federal courts and the NAACP would ultimately come to work together as close partners in the judicial management of school desegregation.
Francis’s fine book enriches our understanding of a little studied piece of a critical period in the development of the United States, resisting the narrative that development shifted largely from race to labor and good governance in the early twentieth century. It provides further confirmation that understanding development requires attending to the work of non-state actors. Finally, it shifts us toward a more encompassing understanding both of what change is, and how change is made.
