Struggles over land tenure have long dominated Mexico's historiography. Until recently, our understanding of broader ecological change has been more limited. Christopher Boyer has helped promote new approaches to Mexico's environmental history, and now provides a sweeping history of forestry since the 1880s, focusing on the relations between peasants, logging corporations and forestry officials. The core argument is that state forestry agencies struggled and largely failed to protect forest ecosystems or provide social justice for communities that live in them. More broadly, Boyer shows how a blend of social and environmental history can powerfully illuminate broader processes of capitalist development and nation building.
The two sections of the book correspond to major cycles of capitalist expansion. In the first, three chronological chapters show how Porfirian order and progress made fortunes for well-connected logging interests, triggered social conflict in the countryside, and fostered worries about deforestation and desertification among Mexico's emerging scientific elite. These forces culminated in the 1930s experiment with ‘revolutionary forestry’: expert-supervised, ejido-based logging cooperatives. Like the Cardenista project as a whole, the initiative became rooted in a few places, but obstacles abounded. Cooperatives confronted business opposition, bureaucratic incapacity and the dismissive attitude of scientific experts towards peasant culture, exemplified by Mexico's leading conservationist, the remarkable but profoundly elitist Miguel Ángel de Quevedo. Boyer traces experts’ cultural biases in part to the forestry service's location in Mexico City, and their unfamiliarity with large-scale, corporate logging. In the second half of the book, three more chapters explore forestry during the drive for industrialisation from the 1940s to the 1980s. As demand spiked during the Second World War, pro-business administrations gutted forestry regulations, withdrew official support for cooperatives, and handed out juicy logging ‘neoconcessions’ to well-connected investors. A partial pushback occurred in the 1950s and 1960s as grandiose regional development projects aimed at (and occasionally even achieved) regulated logging with local input. The 1970s saw a final outburst of state forestry as the government created still more grandiose ‘parastate’ agencies to manage rural development, at the cost of rapid deforestation of tropical areas and still greater bureaucratisation and corruption.
Boyer notes that environmental history has now ‘shucked off much of the activist veneer’ and avoids Manichean tales of capitalist despoliation and indigenous resistance (p. xiv). Boyer's research in national and regional archives, wide reading in the historical and ethnographic literatures, and well-chosen case studies allow him to tell the story with nuance and depth. Each chapter combines a national overview with case studies of temperate forests in Michoacán and Chihuahua, focusing on the experience of the indigenous Purépecha and Rarámuri respectively. Some indigenous peasants embraced aspects of state-led conservationism; others cut pragmatic deals with business interests or mestizo interlopers; overall they ‘rarely articulated a desire to return the land to some former pristine state’ (p. 246). For their part, some forestry officials clung to progressive hopes of mobilising peasants for sustainable forestry, but most others eventually gave up, turned a blind eye to abuses or took company bribes. The case studies allow Boyer to propose some plausible explanations for different responses. Michoacán's relative ethnic integration, and its connection to Cardenismo, ensured that ‘revolutionary forestry’ fared better than in Chihuahua. The late arrival of ejido-based forestry in Chihuahua in the 1950s had less to do with structural factors than the actions of a particularly pugnacious official anthropologist. Of the main actors in the drama, large logging interests receive the least detailed treatment. For example, it remains unclear how profitable the ‘neoconcessions’ of the 1940s and 1950s were. This is likely a symptom of the difficulty in accessing business archives from which all historians of contemporary Mexico suffer to some degree.
A slight misstep comes with Boyer's overarching concept of ‘political landscapes’: ‘spaces where conflicts over the use of forests both provoke and are provoked by state intervention that historical actors regard as illegitimate’ (p. 254). This captures a good deal of what is going on, but raises some problems. It conflates a range of sources of illegitimacy (incapacity, corruption, elitism) whose significance would be more interesting to disaggregate and weigh. It also relies on an unconventionally narrow definition of the political (based on conflict and intrusive, illegitimate states) which sometimes produces some awkward phrasing. Thus, Boyer describes the state's withdrawal from forest regulation in the neoliberal 1990s as depoliticisation, rather than a shift in the dynamics of environmental politics. Boyer argues that ‘the politicisation of forest landscapes represents one of the gravest threats to their ecological integrity’ but also shows that efforts at sustainable ‘revolutionary forestry’ were both a product of politicisation and a precursor for more recent community forestry (p. 11).
Caveats aside, this remains an impressive and important contribution to a number of fields. It will be necessary reading for scholars of Latin American environmental history, and deserves an audience among broad-minded policy-makers concerned with contemporary ecological problems. It will also be of great interest to historians of rural transformations and state formation in modern Mexico. The book's clear prose and able blend of national trends with compelling local detail will benefit students in upper-level undergraduate courses and above.
