Todd Eisenstadt's book is the first comparative study of the two most relevant social movements in the last 30 years in Mexico: the movements initiated by the Ejército Zapatista de Liberación Nacional (Zapatista National Liberation Army, EZLN) in Chiapas and the Asamblea Popular de los Pueblos de Oaxaca (Popular Assembly of the Peoples of Oaxaca, APPO) in Oaxaca. As such, it presents not only a detailed comparative analysis of the origins and developments of these two movements, but also a comparison between the political, social and economic conditions that influenced the way in which claims for indigenous rights were presented by each movement. Eisenstadt is interested in finding out why, although both movements developed within the two Mexican states with the highest indigenous populations, and both movements had indigenous peoples among their members, the indigenous rights frame was strongly advocated by the Zapatistas in Chiapas, while the APPO did not rely on it to present its agenda. To accomplish this goal, Eisenstadt developed an original survey instrument to gather information from indigenous and non-indigenous respondents on their attitudes towards individual and collective rights. Based on this evidence, he argues that communitarian attitudes, characterised by some scholars as inherent in indigenous identities, depend mostly on the degree of political repression endured by peasant populations and the type of land tenure titles granted by the state to rural dwellers.
The author's original survey leads the way into a new understanding of the formation of indigenous identities, which appear to be related more to the socio-economic conditions, land tenure institutions and rural protest traditions of indigenous communities than to their ethnicity. In Chiapas Eisenstadt finds that the struggle for collective indigenous rights is due mostly to the decision of the state to grant land to peasants in the form of ejidos, instead of communal lands as in Oaxaca. The subtle but determinant difference between communal lands and ejidos resides in communal lands being granted to rural indigenous populations when they could ‘credibly claim “primordial title”, either by displaying a colonial era deed or by obtaining a presidential decree stating that the community had held the lands since deeds were recorded’ (p. 29), whereas ejidos are collective lands granted to landless peasants as compensation achieved by the Mexican Revolution of 1910, which led to the nationalisation and collectivisation of rural land. The former involves only the legal recognition of precolonial titles. The latter implies the usually contentious mobilisation of peasants to achieve the distribution of land titles. Although both types of title imply the collective use of the land by their stakeholders, communal lands were usually parcelled out to families and individuals, while members of the ejido were selected by a local government agent and decisions made through the collective vote of all members.
Thus, communal lands allow more individual autonomy to members than ejidos. It should not therefore be a surprise that Eisenstadt finds that comuneros in Oaxaca tend to hold more individualistic attitudes, while ejidatarios in Chiapas are more inclined towards communal values.
There are two important factors influencing peasant attitudes in favour of individual or collective values. The first is the repression endured by indigenous peasants. Compared with the brutal repression endured by ejido peasants and indigenous communities in Chiapas, comuneros in Oaxaca experienced a lighter version of it, precisely because of the greater autonomy allowed inside their lands. Claiming that indigenous peasants in Oaxaca were not repressed, however, would be wrong. Second, although the EZLN and the APPO movements are the most recent expressions of long traditions of mobilisation in those states, their respective histories have also shaped the way in which indigenous identities are portrayed and used to mobilise adherents, sympathisers and supporters.
Eisenstadt's findings are not only particular to indigenous politics and movements in southern Mexico. He compares those attitudes found among the indigenous and non-indigenous population to those of individuals in the state of Zacatecas in north-west Mexico and establishes a more general hypothesis with respect to indigenous movements in Peru and Ecuador in the last chapter. He argues that, as in Chiapas and Oaxaca, indigenous people in Ecuador have enjoyed greater rights of autonomy over their lands than their counterparts in Peru. Hence, Ecuadorean indigenous peoples have been successfully mobilised through collective identities, while in Peru the formation of indigenous identities and movements has remained incipient. However, Todd Eisenstadt's most important contribution to the study of indigenous movements is his argument that indigenous peasants behave like any other non-indigenous social movement actors who define their identity and identify with a movement's agenda based on their evaluation of the individual and collective incentives given by the political and socio-economic conditions surrounding them. Hence, depending on these conditions and their needs, indigenous peasants will decide in a pragmatic fashion to present their demands within an ethnic or a class-based frame.
Acknowledging the presence of diverse attitudes vis-à-vis individual and collective identities is crucial if we are to begin to understand the complexity within indigenous movements and the different meanings of ethnic identities. Within the subfield of indigenous politics it is common to find scholars-turned-activists who, while analysing the causes and consequences of indigenous movements, pretend to speak for indigenous peoples. Eisenstadt's book is a refreshing, objective analysis of indigenous voices using first-hand, rigorously systematised ethnographic evidence.
