The Politics of Turkish Democracy is an important contribution to the study of Turkey's modern political geography. Focusing on the presidency of İnönü, the book analyzes the international and domestic context that defined the dynamics of the institutionalization of the multiparty experiment. The discussion is informed by two general questions: “(1) In what ways did İnönü pursue the Kemalist agenda, and in what ways did he move away from it, or beyond it, to pursue his “İnönü-ist” program? (2) How did İnönü perceive the multi-party system he helped create in the early years of the Cold War—as the outcome of Kemalism …” (p. 5)?
VanderLippe weaves his answers into a chronological narrative of the political developments that surrounded the presidency of İnönü. The book opens with Atatürk's death in 1938 and ends with the “major defeat and great victory” of İnönü in 1950, when his Republican People's Party (RPP) lost the election to the Democrat Party (DP). In nine chapters, VanderLippe skillfully chronicles how İnönü and his cadres institutionalized the Kemalist hegemony in Turkish politics; how the regime responded to World War II, when the new republic chose to maneuver around a neutral yet at times ambiguous stance toward the Axis and the allies; how the RPP dealt with the emergence of opposition from within and outside of the party; how the very alternative to RPP emerged without an alternative ideology; and how the regime was selectively opened up in a manner to simultaneously introduce closures to ensure an institutionalized hegemony in Turkish politics.
Critiquing what he calls a “Kemalocentric” interpretation of modern history of Turkey, VanderLippe argues that to better interpret Turkish political history, one has to drag İnönü from the shadow of Atatürk in order to make visible the historical developments through which Kemalism was instituted as the hegemonic ideological commitment of the regime. This is not an easy task because one of the most frequently deployed technologies of post Atatürk Kemalism was to argue that whatever happens after Kemal was a mere following of the path he himself foresaw and drew. İnönü is no exception, for he was the pioneer of asserting agency by subcontracting his choices to the agency of Atatürk. VanderLippe does a great service to students of modern Turkish history by making visible the reincarnations of Atatürk by his political midwives who have come to define the politics of the Turkish multiparty experiment.
The book also hints at the historical roots of contemporary developments in Turkey. By analyzing the making of the hegemonic ideological geography of Turkish politics, the book shows how and why the left was pushed aside by a coalition of seemingly different political projects of the RPP and the DP, how political Islam began to be used as a counterhegemonic project that presented itself as a “real” alternative, and finally how fascist-leaning nationalism and Pan-Turkism have been lingering around the boundaries of the Kemalist political spectrum. It is the relative absence and presence of these three trends that have come to serve as the main building blocks of modern Turkish politics, for the interpretation of which VanderLippe's book serves as a generous guide.
However, it is surprising that the book does not open a critical conversation with the literature that also analyzed the same period with a similar research objective. Other scholars' work is consulted as historical data used to construct the historical narrative on which the argument was built. In instances in which the argument begs for a critical conversation with the literature, such as the author's valid critique of Kemalocentric approaches, the book is silent about who pursued such a stance and how the stance was constructed. More important than that, it is surprising to encounter neither a reference nor a discussion of Taha Parla's work that served as the first and most developed critical approach to the historical roots, the sociological universe, and the emergence and institutionalization of Kemalism. The book would contribute to our understanding of the era in a more fruitful manner if it incorporated the literature on the subject in a more engaged manner.
VanderLippe's work is an example of serious scholarship with an attendance to historical details. Moreover, bringing together the discussion of international and domestic contexts in a vivid prose, The Politics of Turkish Democracy describes the political developments between 1938 and 1950 in a comprehensive and skillful manner. The book will serve as an essential reference source for historians and political scientists of not only modern Turkey but also the Middle East and global South as a result of its accessible language, clear argumentation, and careful research. As a timely contribution to the study of modern Turkish history, The Politics of Turkish Democracy should be bought by all serious libraries, can be used in teaching, and should be consulted by scholars who are interested in theories of democratic transition, Middle Eastern politics and history.
