Michael Korzi's Presidential Term Limits in American History traces the politics of presidential terms and tenure from the American Founding to the second term of George W. Bush. This book makes three important contributions to the study of the American presidency: it offers the first truly comprehensive, systematic understanding of the debates over term limits throughout American history; it engages with the connection between term limits and presidential power; and it considers the legacy of Founding decisions for contemporary politics. On the first two, this book delivers nicely. On the third idea—perhaps the most theoretically ambitious and controversial—it engages the reader in the question, but doesn't quite deliver a satisfying conclusion.
In the first part of the book, Korzi presents the debate over term length, re-eligibility, and method of selection (direct popular election, selection by the legislature, or the eventual winner, indirect election). These practical questions of institutional design are placed in the context of selection methods for state executives as well as competing schools of thought about the proper role of the national executive. A table on page 37 neatly illustrates how the design that came out of the Philadelphia discussion represents a midpoint between different views of power and democracy in executive politics. The absence of formal term limits in this arrangement gave rise to the “two-term tradition” in the nineteenth century. Korzi devotes a chapter to this period, between Thomas Jefferson's refusal to pursue a third term in 1808 and the discussions of term limits still swirling around in the 1920s. This incredibly informative chapter outlines the persistence of term-limit planks in national party platforms (sometimes calling for a limit of two terms, sometimes for one) as well as recurrent efforts to recruit presidents for a third term. While this short chapter contains an impressive wealth of detailed historical information, it would have been useful to inquire whether earlier questions about power and democracy carried over into later debates about term limits.
In the two chapters on Franklin Roosevelt's presidency, Korzi delves into the debate about Roosevelt's motivations for pursuing a third term and concludes that the main justification was the preservation of the New Deal (82). While acknowledging the factors that made the Roosevelt case sui generis, Korzi uses FDR's four terms to great analytical effect. He argues that the third term illustrates the advantages of re-eligibility beyond the second term, while the fourth term is indicative of some of the major pitfalls. These accounts serve to both elucidate the historical narrative and frame the normative question that underlies any term limit debate: Are term limits good or bad for democratic governance?
The book's final two chapters assess the politics surrounding the passage of the Twenty-Second Amendment and its impact on subsequent presidents. As with the first four chapters, Korzi's presentation of debates over the Twenty-Second Amendment adds a great deal to our understanding of how thinking on term limits has evolved. The final chapter, however, felt somewhat rushed and general compared to the meticulous and vivid accounts of earlier historical moments. Instead, Korzi evaluates whether the benefits of the two-term limit have outweighed the costs. This is an important question, possibly deserving a book of its own. Furthermore, its presentation in Korzi's book seems like an abrupt turn away from the theoretical framework that made the earlier chapters so compelling. As a result, this transition detracted from this otherwise illuminating and enjoyable book.
The question whether term limits are good for presidents appears tightly bound to the notion of presidential success, which—however measured—is essentially a phenomenon of the modern presidency. In this sense, it seems a different question from the others explored throughout the book. The central questions about presidential power changed considerably between the Founding debates about tenure and re-eligibility, and the post-Twenty-Second Amendment period. During the first stages of institutional design, it was possible to imagine a number of possibilities for presidential leadership. These included pitfalls ranging from excessive power to inadequate executive governance. Even accounting for FDR's third and fourth terms, by the 1950s, political actors had a much more developed sense of the nature and limits of presidential power. I would have liked to see the book deal more directly with this change over time. In other words, what were the major concerns about presidential power in the early republic, after the civil war, at the turn of the twentieth century, and so forth, and how did these concerns shape the debate about term limits? If Korzi's research has led him to believe that these debates were similar over time, then that point should be clearly stated.
By jumping into the very debate that he seeks to analyze, Korzi misses an opportunity to theoretically engage with the durable legacies of decisive moments in history. For example, what would the structure of the presidency look like if Whig executive ideas had not been part of the conversation at the Founding? If party politics had evolved differently in the nineteenth century, would the two-term “tradition” have taken hold? Would formal term limits have been imposed if factors had not converged to allow FDR to run successfully for a third, and then a fourth term? These are obviously counterfactual questions that cannot be answered definitively. However, if the ultimate goal of political science is to explain outcomes, then we can use historical evidence judiciously to offer theoretical explanations as well as interesting stories. The history of presidential term limits is ultimately a story of presidential power—how it is conceptualized, practiced, and constrained. Korzi's account doesn't quite tell us why change occurs in this area of American politics; however, this informative book gives future scholars a solid foundation on which to look for answers.
