Helen Chinoy's The Group Theatre: Passion, Politics, and Performance in the Depression Era delivers an exhaustive history of the Group Theatre written by the field's premiere authority on the subject—and it almost never made it to publication. The late author's children found their mother's unpublished manuscript on her computer and contacted Don B. Wilmeth and Milly S. Barranger, longtime friends of Chinoy, to ask if they would edit the work. Wilmeth and Barranger agreed, despite the “large challenges” (xii) the project posed. Chinoy had written a formidable history based on a lifetime of archival research and interviews with former Group members, but it did not include notes for any of her sources. Chinoy had wanted to forgo traditional academic citation for notes that provided a running commentary alongside the main text, but she had not left an example of how to do this. By retracing some of Chinoy's research, the editors were able to include citations for many of the book's sources. They admit that the citation format is a “compromise of Chinoy's wishes” (263) in that the notes are not the lengthy narratives she envisioned, but for the most part they do not interfere with the flow of the narrative.
The editors kept deletions to the manuscript to a minimum, and Chinoy's original organization scheme remains largely intact. In her introduction she writes that the Group made artistic and administrative decisions from two perspectives, “performance and politics” (4), and that these same themes structure her book. With insight characteristic of a scholar who devoted a lifetime to her subject, Chinoy covers in the book's first section the ways in which the Group's three directors—Harold Clurman, Lee Strasberg, and Cheryl Crawford—recruited Group members (“the Chosen Ones” [13]), experimented with staging, and molded Group actors into expert players capable of the kind of psychologically driven performances for which they became famous. In later years, a few Group members would cover some of this same ground in their memoirs—such as Clurman's The Fervent Years—but Chinoy's work is singular. She writes from the perspective of an objective outsider who knew the history of the Group's performances and internal relationships. Chinoy's personal interviews with Group members imbue her presentations of the company's most famous personalities with motivations rooted in real human experience.
Perhaps her most fascinating insights pertain to Strasberg and his fraught relationship with actress Stella Adler. Often painted as controlling and paternalistic, Strasberg is one of the Group's most legendary if controversial figures. His famous duel with Adler over the proper use of Stanislavsky's method is described in dramatic detail, culminating with Strasberg's death in 1982. Adler, in the middle of teaching an acting class, heard the news and asked her students for a moment of silence. Chinoy says that Adler then, “so the gossip goes,” told her students it would take decades for the American theatre “to recover from the damage” (95) that Strasberg caused. Chinoy describes how Strasberg pushed Group actors (especially women) to their emotional breaking points, shrugged off their complaints, and wished for the cast of Waiting for Lefty to “fall and break their necks” (179). However, in Chinoy's version of history, Strasberg's ironfistedness stemmed from extreme introversion and grief over the death of his first wife, Nora. Her history thus lends Strasberg a modicum of pity, even sympathy, that feels new to scholarship on the director.
In the last third of the book, Chinoy shifts to themes of politics, most notably recuperating the Group's symbiotic relationship with New York's militantly anticapitalist workers' theatres. She writes that “In his later years . . . Clurman was always distressed when people dismissed the Group as a theater of the left” (167), but that his distress arose from fear that the Group's radicalism would supersede its dedication to making superior art. To be sure, says Chinoy, not everyone in the Group aligned themselves with radical politics. Those who did formed a “Communist Unit” (186) inside the company. Chinoy explains that it was mostly the actions of this unit that inspired Clifford Odets to write and stage Waiting for Lefty. Prefacing this section is Chinoy's admission that uncovering the Group's radicalism “is no easy task” (186), because so little material on the subject has been published. Clurman, for example, deleted from the published version of The Fervent Years any reference to radical activity; he likely edited his original manuscript as well. Elia Kazan testified in front of the House Committee on Un-American Activities (HUAC) that the “Communist Unit” devised a fourfold plan to advance their agenda: to learn the tenets of Marxism, to help the Party infiltrate the Actors' Equity Association, to muster support for Party-sanctioned organizations, and finally, to “‘capture the Group Theatre and make it a Communist mouthpiece’” (191). It is because of Chinoy's extensive archival and secondary-source research that we now have, with her final book, historical evidence for the unit's “four main tasks” (188): Incidentally, it was the unit's fourth assignment, Chinoy argues, that contributed to the Group's semidissolution in 1937.
Chinoy's exploration of the Group's politics dovetails with a chapter that explains how the sexism of 1930s class consciousness reinforced the Group's injurious treatment of women. Here Chinoy reminds us how women in the 1930s were discouraged from participating in the commercial theatre, lest they be called “harlots” (204). On the one hand, the Group Theatre, with its “noncommercial, artistic, social” (204) sensibility, provided for most of its women members their first professional opportunities. However, rampant sexism among the male members left many Group women feeling inadequate as artists, sexually objectified, and in the words of actress Margaret Barker, emotionally “clobbered” (206).
In all, Chinoy's impressive history coheres to illustrate how the company strived to live up to the “Group Idea” (3), the admirable but vague notion that theatre should lyrically speak to the range of cultural and political experiences of American life—an obsession that Chinoy calls a “cautionary tale” (9). We must consider the Group's delusions as well as their ambitions, Chinoy writes, to “examine our own” (9). After all, it took a spectrum of experiences and values to build “the most important experiment in American theater” (9).
