This is a book for those interested in imperialism, international relations, the end of colonialism, and the unintended consequences of policy decisions. Students of Canada and the Caribbean will find it especially intriguing. The history that Steven High recounts shaped the end of colonialism in the Americas. The ‘destroyers-for-bases’ deal of September 1940 had the United States transfer 50 old destroyers to the British navy in exchange for bases leased for 99 years in Newfoundland, Bermuda, Trinidad, British Guiana, Jamaica, Antigua, St. Lucia and the Bahamas. The agreement not only tied the United States and the United Kingdom in the crucial alliance against the Axis powers, but also marked the beginning of the end of the British Empire in the western hemisphere. President Roosevelt stated that the agreement was the most important US defence measure since the Louisiana Purchase. High, a professor of history at Concordia University in Montreal, has conducted extensive archival research and relates a readable, interesting and important tale. How different the post-war history of the islands would have been if the Americans had not arrived to occupy those places!
The ‘base colonies’ of the title is the term British and US diplomats and military officers used to refer to the leased bases. Steven High sees a deeper meaning in the phrase, however – these were not only ‘colonies with bases’ but also ‘U.S. bases in British colonies’ (p. 2). High observes that ‘their existence made British control seem conditional, even partial’. There was also a deeper meaning for the colonised populations of the Caribbean. Eric Williams, Trinidad's first minister, saw the bases as the start of the West Indies' connection with the modern world economy. The base sites became ‘a contact zone between colonised peoples and these two friendly rivals’ who expounded their formal and informal models of empire (p. 3). The US ‘invaders’ or ‘occupiers’ were none too impressed with Britain's ‘slum Empire’, and their stinging criticism was a source of friction within the alliance.
High's work offers readers a useful comparative perspective that broadens our understanding of effects of the base colonies. Recent studies such as Harvey Neptune's Caliban and the Yankees (2007) have shown how Trinidad's elite feared the example that US troops provided for Creole men and women. Their presence ‘destabilised the colonial order’ (p. 4). Neptune saw the Americans more as liberators than occupiers; in High's view the situation was more complicated than that, because there were real areas of contestation that involved ‘removal of inhabitants, base location, criminal jurisdiction, and Jim Crow racism’. High seeks ‘to find middle ground between the political and diplomatic scholarship of the 1980s and more recent works of cultural history’ (p. 4). Through the inclusion of white Newfoundland he describes how race was not the factor there that it was elsewhere, though there were ‘striking similarities’ in the ways the Americans treated local labourers. They considered local workers as lazy natives regardless of their skin colour. It is particularly noteworthy that all of the US military personnel, save one artillery unit sent to Trinidad briefly in 1942, were white, so the leased areas were racially exclusionary and reflected race relations in the United States. Even so, the British colonial officials were ‘especially apprehensive lest the balance of colonial authority be disturbed by the arrival of well-paid and well-clothed American Negro troops’ (p. 38).
The base colonies were invasions of US-style modernity complete with ‘indoor plumbing, cafeterias, cinemas, golf courses, and other recreational facilities, social clubs, hospitals, and even radio stations’ (p. 10). Visiting civilians were awed by the ‘power and wealth’ that the bases evidenced. The contrast with the surrounding British colony was notable. An official of British Guiana commented that normal economic restraints were absent, and that there were ‘no neglected houses or roads and every person within the borders is employed, well-clad and well-fed’ (p. 10). US civilian and military personnel were paid more than their British counterparts, and class and racial differences were strongly seen in the crowds of soldiers and sailors on leave off the base. The gates that separated these unequal environments frequently became flashpoints for racial conflict and violence.
The base colonies had real military value. Beginning, as they did, before the United States entered the war, they were a sign that the Americans were committed to protecting Britain. Time magazine saw the bases as the equivalent to ‘five new battleships’. Hanson Baldwin of the New York Times said that the bases extended the US frontier ‘to the Amazon and the Great Banks off Newfoundland’ and ‘made possible an “aggressive defense” of the Western Hemisphere’ (p. 26). And, of course, with the addition of the bases in Brazil, the defence and supply line were extended far down the South American coast.
High sets all this sensibly in an opening chapter on hemispheric defence and follows with chapters on the delicate and painful question of base location in tiny Bermuda and the problems related to building bases in the rather undeveloped environment of Newfoundland. He skilfully shows what was planned and how it all changed during construction and operation. His chapter on the ‘Racial Politics of Criminal Jurisdiction’ highlights the intense problems involved in maintaining foreign bases. The US occupation caused a ‘great deal of friction’ with the inhabitants. In British Guiana, slack discipline resulted in disturbing incidents that included US planes firing on fishing vessels and a navy gunboat shooting up a village. The question of how such wrongdoing would be handled, and by whom, caused headaches for the two allied governments and their local officials. Race was a constant flashpoint. On St. Lucia, US ‘officers refused to cooperate with black police constables of any rank’ (p. 167). Among the British colonies, only ‘Newfoundland regularly tried and convicted U.S. soldiers and sailors for serious crimes’ (p. 168).
If the bases had been given up after the war the way the Brazilian bases were, it might be possible today to look at them dispassionately – but they were not, and in the post-war era they contributed to the end of British colonialism. High correctly concludes that it was ‘significant that the coming of the Americans was everywhere described as an “invasion”, friendly or otherwise’ (p. 204). Don't miss this book – it will broaden your perspectives on the effects of the Second World War.
