In Argentina Betrayed, Antonius C. G. M. Robben thoughtfully analyses how Argentine society has dealt with the legacy of massive human rights violations perpetrated during Argentina's last military dictatorship (1976–83). Systematic torture, forcible disappearance, sexual violence, appropriation of children born in captivity and other state-sponsored crimes were among the methods that the military and security forces used against people deemed enemies of the nation – most specifically those who opposed the government's political, economic and cultural agenda. State terror was a strategy to destroy bonds of solidarity, squash political dissent, dismantle social movement organisations, silence voices of denunciation and physically eliminate social and political activists. These developments are now well known, but Robben revisits this history to interpret it through the lens of trust and betrayal in relation to major ‘areas of national contestation’ (p. 23).
Drawing on ethnographic observations, in-depth interviews, government documents, journalistic reports and archival information, Robben offers an expansive study of how different stakeholders have understood the regime's actions and the transitional and post-transitional justice measures that followed. Among the groups addressed in the book are members and supporters of the state armed forces, relatives of the disappeared people, survivors of clandestine detention, human rights activists, former insurgents and Catholic Church clerics. Robben's book benefits from his long-term and cumulative engagement with the topic, including fieldwork conducted in the late 80s and early 90s, and additional research trips to Argentina over the decades. Given the ideologically diverse people that Robben spoke with, including from groups situated at opposite ends of the political spectrum, it is not surprising that he heard varied and often divergent accounts.
Argentina Betrayed places the conflicting interpretations of political events at the centre of the analysis and delves into what is at stake for different groups regarding dominant frames and policies at particular historical moments. For instance, Robben explores differing characterisations of the dictatorship's violence: from the notion of a dirty war that, according to the military, required the use of unconventional methods against ‘subversives’; to the democratic transition's narrative about a confrontation between two demons (state and guerrilla forces – the former wielding the most destructive power); to the human rights movement's emphasis on state terrorism (a concept that highlights and denounces state-sponsored atrocities against its victims); to the increasing purchase of the genocide frame, which underscores the dictatorship's attempt to destroy a sector of the population and reorganise society, while also pointing to collective guilt beyond the military.
The notions of trust and betrayal are vital to the book's arguments. Robben applies these concepts to understand individual and group perspectives in relation to state and insurgent violence, transitional justice initiatives, impunity laws and presidential pardons and the politics of memory and memorialisation. Departing from individualised notions of trust, Robben ‘use[s] the term social trust for interpersonal and group relations in society, including the home, and political trust for interactions with state agents and state institutions’ (p. 17; original emphasis). He points out that trust is important to the social fabric, including social ties and relations, and ‘involves the suspension of the doubt that relations may go awry’ (pp. 17–18). During the dictatorship trust was deeply betrayed, for example, by state authorities who denied knowledge of the whereabouts of the disappeared people and by members of civil society who turned against or became indifferent to friends and relatives targeted by the regime. Yet the dynamics of trust and betrayal also applied to how different groups felt about initiatives taken during democratic times to deal with the dictatorship's actions and consequences: from the Nunca Más (Never Again) report by the National Commission on the Disappearance of Persons, to the trial of the military juntas and later ‘Truth Trials’, to government policies that ensured prolonged impunity, to the repeal of these measures, to the reopening of judicial cases for crimes against humanity. Robben explores trust and betrayal dynamics not only between ideologically opposed groups, or between groups and institutions such as Church and State, but also within ideologically aligned groups. In this way, he addresses conflict and mistrust within the armed forces sector as well as within the human rights movement and leftist political circles.
In addition to providing historical background regarding political violence and related events before, during and after the dictatorship, the chapters are each structured around concepts that allow Robben to weave in both empirical information and theoretical insight: Trauma, Memory, Testimony, Denial, Sovereignty, Accountability, Guilt and Mourning. The author teases out how these terms illuminate conflicting perspectives and contentious situations, which in turn are illustrated with the voices of political protagonists and other people affected. For instance, we hear both heart-wrenching testimonies of relatives of the disappeared as well as disturbing accounts by repressors about the atrocities committed. From a methodological and ethical standpoint, research interactions with members of opposed constituencies present difficult dilemmas that the author tries to grapple with in different parts of the book. Furthermore, while not intending to establish moral equivalence between the groups, Robben extends the notion of sociocultural trauma not only to victims but also to perpetrators. This application of the concept may be controversial, but Robben argues that ‘Argentina's predicament in the last four decades can only be understood when all pertinent protagonists, organizations, and state institutions are included in one comprehensive analysis of the complex multilevel dynamics of political violence and sociocultural trauma’ (p. 36).
Argentina Betrayed offers an in-depth and thorough examination of the traumatic effects and ramifications of state terror in Argentina. The book should be of particular interest to scholars and students of collective memory, human rights, transitional justice and Latin American politics. While the issues described take place in Argentina, they have connections with and relevance for broader contexts, especially in the region. The book digs into the past, but also reaches the present, addressing enduring questions about grief, mourning and recovery. In exploring the challenges that societies may encounter as they reckon with atrocity, this book provides valuable tools for understanding and confronting painful political histories.
