The 1970s, Frederic Jameson once claimed, was a decade “whose specificity seemed most of the time to consist in having no specificity.”Footnote 1 Stanley Corkin's terrific new study of American cinema in the 1970s demonstrates how this ill-defined era constitutes a critical period of economic and social transition, as well as a distinctive moment in the history of Hollywood. By analysing images of New York's on-screen development – ranging from the rubble and demolition prevalent at the start of the decade to the complacent gentrification celebrated in Woody Allen's work – Corkin builds an expansive argument concerning “the shift from a regional and then national division of labor, to a global means of organization” (31).
This, then, is a book about the relationship between capitalism and urbanism, refracted through cinema. Film, Corkin emphasizes, provides us with “a dense fabric of spatial relations” (12) and powerful visual evidence of historical processes in action. To map such intriguing terrain, the structure he adopts has both thematic and chronological dimensions, assessing how a range of directors treated urban issues such as crime, housing and transportation, but with an eye on broader national and international trends. This enables Corkin to show how earlier images of urban decline, sexual deviance and brutal violence all helped to valorize the later transformation of New York into “a place that exists for the pleasure of its cognoscenti” (184).
Thus the scenes of prostitution seen in films such as Midnight Cowboy (John Schlesinger, 1969) and Klute (Alan J. Pakula, 1971) are positioned as a complement to conservative assumptions of the time when “structural problems of the national economy” were actually “moral problems of urban behavior” (47). The breakdown in local authority dramatized by The French Connection (William Friedkin, 1971) and Dog Day Afternoon (Sidney Lumet, 1975) is said to have “softened the way” for an acceptance of global systems of governance (119). Similarly, Martin Scorsese's Taxi Driver (1976) exemplifies “the neoconservative argument for maintaining order in urban spaces” (135). In Corkin's convincing evaluation, such films reveal that exorcizing the criminal and malfunctioning elements of New York life, even via vigilante methods, became in the 1970s an essential stepping-stone toward the city becoming predominantly “a center for the affluent” (152). However, there is also little romanticism here about a period when the city's crime rate rocketed and African American communities were especially afflicted by unemployment.
What is especially compelling is the manner in which changes in film production, urban planning, municipal politics, intellectual history and global economic patterns are all combined in Corkin's ambitious analysis, without strain or simplification. Specific sites, such as Times Square and Central Park, receive detailed attention, while race, ethnicity and class are discussed in an intelligent fashion. Corkin refuses to let the reputation of celebrated films such as The Godfather overshadow their embrace of “ethnic nostalgia” (51). Indeed, Francis Ford Coppola's first two instalments of the Mafia saga, released in 1972 and 1974, are expertly critiqued for the manner in which they long for imagined neighbourhoods of the past based around local businesses and “white” inhabitants. There is a wry humour, too, in the book's reflections on New York's varying political priorities – Corkin suggesting, for instance, that the unconventional police tactics seen in The French Connection “would have found a home in the Giuliani regime of the 1990s” (125).
With innovative readings of over twenty films within a broad spatial framework, Starring New York represents an almost exemplary piece of interdisciplinary film studies. Despite the frustrating typographical errors and occasional bouts of repetition, Corkin's book remains an absorbing and clear-sighted examination of a decade often seen in hazy terms. In many ways, it is the perfect partner for Edward Dimendberg's much-praised Film Noir and the Spaces of Modernity (2004), which tackles an earlier period in American movie history in the context of the centrifugal forces that devastated postwar urban America. Certainly, both studies confirm that cinematic images are a productive archive of urban insight. Moreover, given the recently renewed interest in the performance art created in downtown New York in the 1970s and the success of Colum McCann's novel Let the Great World Spin (2009), which centres on Harlem in the same period, it is tempting to suggest that this previously disparaged era in the city's history is becoming increasingly renowned for its creative vibrancy and diverse practices – just as Manhattan and Brooklyn, in particular, become ever more dominated by financial services and property speculation.
