In socialist Yugoslavia, the People’s Liberation War (Narodnooslobodilački rat or Narodnoosloodilačka borba, hereafter NOB), the Partisans’ antifascist struggle and the parallel socialist revolution that occurred during the Second World War were central historical references that permeated society at all levels. The war represented the birthplace and a source of legitimacy for Yugoslav state socialism and marked the cornerstone of Yugoslav revolutionary and antifascist memory culture. Dominant discourses on war were shaped by notions of brotherhood and unity, which helped to construct a cohesive narrative of an all-Yugoslav struggle against the occupation and domestic collaborators.Footnote 1
This article focuses on the commemoration of the fifteenth anniversary of the Battle of Sutjeska in 1958 to examine the logistical organisation and social production of war remembrance in socialist Yugoslavia. Also known as the Fifth Offensive or Case Black, the 1943 battle was one of the largest Axis military operations in Yugoslavia during the war and a turning point for the Partisans, who managed to break through enemy lines and suffered enormous losses. The battle was one of the most important dates in Yugoslavia’s culture of wartime remembrance and was commemorated in Tjentište in the south-east of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Dominant narratives on Sutjeska emphasised the Partisans’ victory, sacrifice and heroism and the participation of Partisans from across Yugoslavia.Footnote 2 Focusing on Sutjeska allows us to examine Yugoslavia’s culture of war remembrance and explore the unifying Yugoslav war narrative, the multifaceted mnemonic agency, the modernisation of commemorative practices, the embeddedness of war memory in leisure and everyday life and, finally, what Olga Manojlović Pintar refers to as ‘the spatialisation of socialist ideology’ through sites of memory.Footnote 3
This article investigates how and by whom the 1958 Sutjeska commemoration was organised, and what this particularly commemorative event reveals about the social production of war remembrance in socialist Yugoslavia. It analyses logistics, infrastructure, organisational labour and everyday practices that embody the social production of antifascist and revolutionary war memory. Shifting attention away from commemorative narratives and speeches, the paper centres on the practical infrastructure, labour and social practices behind war commemoration. War commemoration was organisationally complex: it required roads, tents, food, drinking water, bathrooms, lighting, security and medical services and involved registration procedures, youth camps, hikes, sporting competitions and cultural programmes. Therefore, war commemoration in Yugoslavia was intertwined with leisure, sport, tourism and entertainment, and embedded in everyday life.
The work of socio-political and social organisations, such as the Partisans’ veteran association, the Federation of Associations of Fighters of the People’s Liberation War (Savez udruženja boraca Narodnooslobodilačkog rata, hereafter SUBNOR), hostellers and mountaineers, was crucially important for these kinds of commemorative activities.Footnote 4 While the NOB was the official state-sanctioned narrative, the culture of remembrance did not follow a state-centred model. Instead, Yugoslav public memory was shaped by complex relations between different organisations, embodied in sites and rituals of commemoration, and ‘a product of a great deal of work by large numbers of people’.Footnote 5 These organisations also facilitated mobilisation and participation, embodied Yugoslav socialist democracy and walked the line between state directed and autonomous action.Footnote 6
Large commemorations of the Battle of Sutjeska, considered the greatest battle of the NOB, took place in Tjentište before 1958, but the fifteenth anniversary elevated the battle and its location to an all-Yugoslav site of memory, as well as a symbol of the war and revolution. In 1958, it became a central Yugoslav celebration. The battle’s anniversary, usually commemorated in mid-June, was merged with the celebration of Fighter’s Day on 4 July, the federal memorial day commemorating the beginning of the Partisans’ uprising in 1941.Footnote 7 In addition to the main event in Tjentište, which stretched across a few days, commemorative events across Yugoslavia throughout 1958 were dedicated to Sutjeska. At least 60,000 people were expected to attend the main event in Tjentište in 1958, and this required months of preparation involving war veterans, youth, scouts, mountaineers, hostellers, doctors, artists, musicians, food suppliers and representatives of the tourist industry. The coordinating committees brought together numerous actors and diverse sports and cultural activities involving young people, which represented an intensification of cooperation among social organisations, a shift towards youth and the diversification of social practices of memory.
The Yugoslav culture of war remembrance has attracted much scholarly attention. Some scholars have focused on the images of the past that state institutions sought to circulate, interpreting Yugoslav memory culture as imposed from above and the Partisans as ‘memory watchdogs’.Footnote 8 Others have provided valuable perspectives on actors, commemorative mobilities, local-level dynamics and agency from below.Footnote 9 Yugoslav antifascist monuments, including the Sutjeska memorial, have generated significant scholarly and public interest, particularly in art history, and have become a research field in their own right.Footnote 10 This article builds upon this scholarship but shifts focus onto the logistics, infrastructure, organisational labour and everyday practices surrounding war commemoration. Focusing on the social production of war remembrance and the aspects that are rarely examined in scholarship on memory politics, this study demonstrates not only the importance of historicising the study of memory politics, but also of focusing on the social history of memory as a distinctive area of inquiry.Footnote 11
This article draws primarily on material from the Archives of Yugoslavia in Belgrade, particularly the fonds of SUBNOR, the Mountaineering Association of Yugoslavia (Planinarski savez Jugoslavije, hereafter PSJ) and the League of Hostellers of Yugoslavia (Ferijalni savez Jugoslavije, hereafter FSJ), as well as newspaper coverage of the 1958 commemoration. These sources reflect the organisers’ perspective, largely leaving unaddressed the questions of participants’ perceptions. The correspondence and discussions concerning the registration of participants show that interest in attending the Sutjeska commemoration and joining the mountaineers’ and hostellers’ camps was immense and could not be accommodated, while the newspapers’ reports provide a glimpse into participants’ perspectives through reports, photos and quotes. However, an in-depth understanding of their motivations, experiences of the events and the extent to which they meaningfully engaged with the commemorative theme is beyond the scope of this study.
The article starts by discussing theoretical considerations and the culture of war remembrance in Yugoslavia and highlighting the agency of socio-political and social organisations. Thereafter, the article shifts focus onto the 1958 commemoration of the Battle of Sutjeska, analysing the actors involved and the logistics, organisation and infrastructure of mass participation to explore the overlap between war memory and leisure, sport and tourism.
Sutjeska as a Yugoslav Site of Memory
The 1958 commemoration of the Battle of Sutjeska took place at the battle site on 4 July and across Yugoslavia that year. The most important Second World War dates, such as Fighter’s Day and days of uprisings in individual republics, were also dedicated to the memory of Sutjeska. The goal was to evoke memories of the struggle and to include the broadest possible segments of society (especially youth) in the commemoration through diverse forms of remembrance. The main event involved traditional wreath-laying, simulated wartime formations of surviving participants in the Battle of Sutjeska, several political speeches and a mass popular gathering, as well as a diverse programme of other activities, such as sports competitions and cultural programmes. A similar format was repeated across the country. SUBNOR organised a commemorative programme, including lectures, gatherings and the laying of flowers and wreaths at graves and memorial plaques, after which other social organisations organised additional activities within their respective domains. Schools organised thematic classes, meetings with the Partisans and visits to museums of the NOB and revolution. Children and young people participated in literary and school competitions on the theme of Sutjeska. Many people organised picnics and short trips to coincide with the holiday.
According to Heike Karge, beginning in the 1950s, Sutjeska gradually developed into ‘the central and most prestigious war memorial in Yugoslavia’.Footnote 12 Following the first large-scale commemoration in 1958, the site of Sutjeska developed into a national and memorial park, funded primarily from the federal budget.Footnote 13 The development of the memorial complex symbolises the inscription of war memory into space and territory and transforms Sutjeska into one of the central sites of memory in Yugoslavia, that what Sanja Horvatinčić has described as an authentic spatial unit marked by war experience, preserved and marked to transfer war memory to future generations.Footnote 14 The grandiosity of the space, the almost mystical landscape and the monumentality of the concrete blocks that form the central monument symbolised the struggle for socialist Yugoslavia and the enormity of the Partisans’ sacrifices and victory.Footnote 15
Sutjeska as a site of memory developed from the memorial plaque and ossuary in 1949 to a vast memorial complex by 1974 with a museum, memorial house, two hotels, a youth centre, an outdoor swimming pool and a modernist monument by Miodrag Živković.Footnote 16 The memorial complex was planned as an outdoor multimedia historical classroom, intended not only for contemporaries but also for future generations of visitors.Footnote 17 Merging tourist, educational, sport and recreational, leisure and socio-political functions, Sutjeska illuminated the embeddedness of war memory in everyday life as a place of both death and joy, blurring the boundaries between a recreational park and a national cemetery.Footnote 18 The complex can also be seen as a multimedia and collective work of art, where engineers, architects, sculptors, painters, historians, landscape architects and construction engineers collaborated to shape the revolutionary ideology through modern construction technology and abstract art forms.Footnote 19
Sutjeska symbolises a unified natural-memorial complex that merges together the monument, the battle site and the surrounding natural environment. Nature protection became a prominent topic in discussions of war memory in the late 1960s and early 1970s, as the number of monuments within national parks grew. The protection of nature and the environment was deeply intertwined with the preservation of monuments and commemorative activities. The environmental characteristics of different locations determined their role during the NOB, as a site for secret meetings, hidden hospitals or storage of ammunition, and because of this, SUBNOR considered their preservation as equally important to the protection of the concrete memorial object.Footnote 20 In other cases, the natural environment served as a protective framework for the monument or its aesthetic frame, which emphasised its aesthetic value and shaped visitors’ experience. Finally, there was also a category of natural monuments, that SUBNOR defined as places or areas historically important to the community, such as caves that served as meeting points, trees where Partisans were hanged by occupation forces or sites that served as mailboxes.Footnote 21 Sutjeska was one of the larger geographical areas and landscapes that represented a memorial to the NOB because of the battle that took place there. While working on the Sutjeska monument, Miodrag Živković imagined the composition of the paths, platforms, ossuary and monument as a single memorial, aesthetically unified with the surrounding hills.Footnote 22
The Social Production of War Remembrance in Yugoslavia
All political programmes intrinsically involve some construction of the past as well as the future.Footnote 23 The politics of memory encompasses ‘the discourses and practices of using the past by various social and political actors for the purposes relevant in the present’.Footnote 24 The modern state outweighs other actors in this context because it possesses the resources, authority and the power to limit competing efforts, which explains why scholarship on memory politics has been dominated by state perspectives.Footnote 25 The nation and nation-state have also served as ‘the prime arena for the articulation of war memories and the mobilisation of commemoration, since war has been central to its identity and symbolic continuity’.Footnote 26 This is the sphere of official memory that Ashplant, Dawson and Roper define as encompassing hegemonic narratives, ‘which underpin and help to organise the remembrance and commemoration of war at the level of the nation-state’.Footnote 27
The NOB served as a powerful state-building and legitimising narrative in Yugoslavia, in which state actors and institutions invested significant effort. However, state actors were not the only mnemonic agents. Moreover, the war and revolution were also a lived experience for many Yugoslavs, and a broader memory culture was embedded in everyday life and across different spheres of society, rather than imposed from above. Focusing on the social production of memory moves beyond state agency as a framework and thinks through all the ways in which a sense of the past is constructed within a given society. It entwines public representations with lived experiences, which are also collective and shared.Footnote 28 The social production of memory and knowledge about the past also occurs in everyday life.Footnote 29
As the Popular Memory Group argues, relying on Gramsci, ‘a sense of history must be one element in a strong popular socialist culture’.Footnote 30 Through this, a social group builds knowledge of the broader context of its collective struggles and becomes capable of taking on a wider transformative role within society. This formation of a popular socialist memory culture is precisely what characterised the Yugoslav culture of remembrance. Even though local practices across Yugoslavia focused on mourning the dead and differed from the broader socialist, revolutionary and future-oriented memory culture, this was not a dichotomy or polarisation that would obscure the full complexity and significance of commemorative processes.Footnote 31 Yugoslav memory culture was not a monolithic sphere, and it encompassed a plurality of social practices and diverse forms of participation in war remembrance.Footnote 32 Moreover, the power of dominant memories depends not only on their public visibility, but also on their capacity to connect with and articulate particular popular conceptions, whilst actively silencing or marginalising others.Footnote 33
The questions of who does memory and how memory is politically utilised are central concerns for the study of memory politics, according to Maria Mälksoo.Footnote 34 We seek to understand how, by whom, by what means, with what intention and with what effects past experiences become both visible and politically relevant.Footnote 35 Actors that operate at different levels of society can be termed memory entrepreneurs, mnemonic agents or choreographers.Footnote 36 They act within and with social frames of remembrance that shape what people remember as well as communities of memory.Footnote 37 The focus on agency, which identifies actors and their mnemonic practices, reveals the political and social processes underpinning the production of representations of the past, and the focus on social practices of remembrance helps overcome ‘sticking to solely the level of representations and discourses’.Footnote 38 The analysis of social memory and social history of memory in Yugoslavia involves the exploration of distinct sets of mnemonic practices in various social sites, rather than investigating ‘collective memory as a thing’.Footnote 39
Yugoslav memory culture was a multifaceted ‘memoryscape’ in which the NOB had a central position. Memoryscape refers to a socio-spatial phenomenon that ties together material spaces with more immaterial, performative and narrative spaces to form ‘a vast array of material sites and objects, embodied practices, narratives and discourses and cultural heritage that interact with each other in creating meaning of the past’.Footnote 40 In the Yugoslav antifascist and revolutionary memoryscape, Sutjeska served as a pivotal site of memory, both as a site where the 1943 battle took place and a symbol present across society. Memorial sites do not only represent the places where a historical event occurred but, more broadly, are wherever groups of people engage in public activity through which they express a collective shared knowledge of the past.Footnote 41
Memory is constantly remediated and circulates across different platforms, networks, cultural forms and social contexts.Footnote 42 Mediation is key to remembrance, as ‘any representations of a collective past, in order to be effective, need to be communicated via the arts, politics, school, mass media, museums and the like’.Footnote 43 In the Yugoslav context, as Nataša Jagdhuhn shows, there was a network of museums of the revolution and of the NOB in each constituent republic, autonomous province and even in smaller regions.Footnote 44 There was barely a village in the former Yugoslavia that did not have a local war memorial, either in the form of a soldier with a weapon in his hand or at least a small commemorative plaque.Footnote 45 The NOB was also present in almost all spheres of social life, such as school curricula, television, press and political speeches, and it became part of everyday social imagination.Footnote 46 Schools visited monuments and sites of memory on important dates; enterprises and labour organisations went on collective trips to museums of revolution and to different places from the liberation war and revolution; and families went to monuments and memorial parks on their own initiative, turning them into places for outings, hikes and picnics. The affirmation of memorial tourism was part of a broader process of tourism development.Footnote 47 In this way, memory culture informed and shaped everyday life in Yugoslavia.
The Agency of Antifascist Memory: Partisans and Social Organisations
Yugoslav memory culture was not merely imposed from above, but it was organised as a dense infrastructure of social mobilisation and disciplining of mass participation by social and socio-political organisations. These organisations were the carriers of the Yugoslav culture of war remembrance, and SUBNOR was the leading actor that formulated the frameworks of war memory and initiated cooperation. Cooperation between multiple mass organisations in the sphere of war remembrance, which was crucial for the 1958 commemoration of the Battle of Sutjeska, was rooted in the joint involvement in the civilian mobilisation in the military sphere after 1948, but it was also necessitated by the shift towards younger generations and the modernisation and pluralisation of social memory practices from the late 1950s onwards.
Associations of scouts, hostellers, mountaineers and other groups participating in the organisation of war remembrance were formally social organisations. They gathered people together based on their generational, professional, biographical or leisurely affiliation and enjoyed a certain degree of autonomy in their specific activities, so long as they did not deviate from the official frameworks of Yugoslav state socialism.Footnote 48 According to Nikola Baković, they embodied Yugoslav socialist democracy as ‘the socialist emanation of the semiautonomous sphere of civic activism’.Footnote 49 They were autonomous in their activities and interests and based on voluntary membership, functioning as ‘a surrogate for civil society and activist groups’.Footnote 50 SUBNOR, on the other hand, was one of Yugoslavia’s socio-political organisations, a category of social organisation whose field was considered to be in the public interest.Footnote 51
With Second World War combatants as the main mnemonic agents and the most influential political actors, Yugoslavia can be seen as an outlier in state socialist Eastern Europe, where veterans did not shape the culture of war remembrance for decades after the war.Footnote 52 SUBNOR had almost one million members in the 1960s and did not only work on veterans’ affairs and welfare.Footnote 53 Besides organising commemorations, SUBNOR’s official tasks included: maintaining the graves of Partisans and victims of fascism, planning, erecting and protecting monuments, marking historical sites, opening museums, collecting and processing historical documents and testimonies, publishing studies and memoirs about the NOB and organising various Partisans’ gatherings and events.Footnote 54 To fulfil these tasks, SUBNOR had to cooperate with relevant institutions and organisations, such as the party, the Military History Institute, museums, institutes for the protection of cultural monuments and publishers.
The commemorative practices during the first decade after the war remained within the traditional field of the culture of remembrance. They involved the building of thousands of monuments and memorial plaques, marking graves, commemorating important dates, awarding medals, publishing memoirs and collecting and producing knowledge about the war. As Bergholz shows, the commemorations usually followed a set protocol, beginning with a procession of the families of the dead, particularly mothers or children, followed by a series of political speeches, poetry reading or songs performed by pioneers and, finally, the laying of flowers and wreaths on monuments or graves.Footnote 55 These activities were intended to honour the fallen and veteran Partisans. As SUBNOR reviewed their memory work in the late 1950s, they realised that a shift from honouring the war dead and focusing on the wartime generation to transmitting memory to younger generations was necessary.Footnote 56 Transmitting revolutionary traditions to youth had always been an important task, as Josip Broz Tito proclaimed about SUBNOR in 1947: ‘this organisation will have a goal of spreading and instilling into hearts of younger generations the heroism, enthusiasm, excitement, commitment and readiness for sacrifice’.Footnote 57 From the late 1950s, however, the focus on youth in the sphere of war memory shifted from the discursive level to a more practical one.
In its focus on the youth, Yugoslavia reflects the broader European context. After 1945, a new conceptualisation of youth emerged across Eastern and Western Europe, where young people became a special social category and ‘a potential force of renewal in the world’.Footnote 58 In socialist societies, young people had to be organised and mobilised, and they ‘harboured the promise of new men and women – better in soul, body, and mind – and thus holding the key to a brighter future’.Footnote 59 In the immediate postwar period, the focus on the young generation presented a symbolic opportunity to project the Yugoslav regime into the future while also mobilising a much-needed workforce.Footnote 60 Youth were to play a particularly important role in the construction of socialist society, mobilised for youth labour actions and as factory workers after the Second World War.Footnote 61 The 1948 split with the Soviet Union marked the disappearance of the main role model for building socialism in Yugoslavia, but it also led the Yugoslav party to differentiate itself from the Soviet model and find its own methods of building socialism and ‘a Yugoslav socialist man’ who was more open and free than in the postwar period, but still susceptible to political judgment from above.Footnote 62
Youth were considered to be one of the most important pillars of Yugoslav state socialism. The state invested symbolic and economic capital in young people, hoping that ‘the sense of “Yugoslav socialist patriotism” would supersede and replace narrower circles of belonging or ethnic and class divisions’.Footnote 63 The state employed social mobilisation and collective opprobrium as tools of social control while presenting youth discursively as activist citizens, and this indirectly led to the growth of youth agency.Footnote 64 Social organisations were key to the socialist mobilisation of young people. Children were envisioned as those who would build socialism and continue where the previous generations stopped, embodied in the Association of Pioneers of Yugoslavia (Savez pionira Jugoslavije), where all primary school pupils were members.Footnote 65 Later, they joined the Association of Youth of Yugoslavia (Savez omladine Jugoslavije) and could also be active in various organisations, such as scouting, hostelling, music, cultural, educational and sports associations. According to the Party programme, these organisations were tasked with promoting social responsibility, creative power, cultural education and the formation of a socialist outlook among young people.Footnote 66 Initiatives such as labour actions served the purpose of developing socialist patriotism, but in later decades, they increasingly emphasised entertainment and fun to attract youth, rather than shaping them solely in ideological terms.Footnote 67
The Partisans’ shift towards the younger generations had the goal of connecting two completely different generations in the project of ‘creation of an intergenerational culture of remembrance’.Footnote 68 It sparked an expansion of the culture of war remembrance into various spheres of education, media and popular culture, a shift from traditional to more modern practices of war commemoration and, finally, led to cooperation with more diverse socio-political actors. SUBNOR began to think about the place of the NOB in school curricula and extracurricular activities, exhibitions, museums, literature, radio and television, theatre and film, as well as about how to combine revolutionary traditions with entertainment, recreation and commercial content. Monuments followed the shift, transforming from memorials to fallen fighters to large-scale memorial parks that were both commemorative and recreational.Footnote 69
The cooperation frameworks between social and socio-political organisations that accompanied the shift in war remembrance stemmed from civilian military training (vanarmijsko vojno vaspitanje), which was established to strengthen the country’s defensive power following the Yugoslav-Soviet split in 1948. Coordinating committees from the county to the federal level gathered representatives of all social organisations to work together on basic military training for civilians and on various physical fitness activities, including mountaineering, skiing, cycling, horse riding, swimming and rowing.Footnote 70 As the threat of an attack by the Eastern Bloc passed, the institutional focus shifted to the pre-military training of youth, with social organisations also involved.Footnote 71
From the mid-1950s onwards, the abandonment of non-military army training coincided with SUBNOR’s realisation that cooperation among social organisations was necessary to transmit NOB traditions to new generations.Footnote 72 As there was no need for the organisations to continue working on military training, the coordinating committees of civilian military training became coordinating bodies of social organisations for developing the militant traditions of the NOB, based on the idea that preserving the culture of remembrance was in everyone’s interest.Footnote 73 Under the leadership of SUBNOR, greater numbers of social organisations became involved, connecting their activities with military traditions for ‘development of socialist patriotism and strengthening of defence capabilities and independence of the country’.Footnote 74
Cooperation between SUBNOR and organisations that represented children and youth, such as scouts and hostellers, strengthened in the late 1950s. The spread of war remembrance into spheres like sport, tourism, recreation and nature increased the number of actors involved. SUBNOR’s committee responsible for war remembrance saw the mass participation of youth in commemorations as manifesting ‘the revolutionary continuity of the struggle for socialism’.Footnote 75 For example, many scouts’ activities were mobilities organised around the NOB. From 1959, Sutjeska was the theme of their annual federal jamborees held at Tjentište, under the title ‘Sutjeska Burbles Eternally’, symbolically referring to both the river and the battle of Sutjeska.Footnote 76 They also took part in Partisan pilgrimages, combining the marches with their touristic agenda of getting to know the country.Footnote 77 Individual Partisans usually joined youth camps and marches at the sites of wartime events to share their memories. In addition to children and youth, other organisations took part in commemorative mobilities honouring the Partisans, including alpinist societies, trade unions, the army, firefighters, shooting clubs, the Red Cross, student clubs and others.Footnote 78 The organisation that played a particularly important role in war remembrance was the PSJ, which marked hiking trails around battle sites and commemorated important anniversaries. They were also a key partner at the annual Sutjeska commemorations. Besides managing specific activities within their domains, these organisations were responsible for social mobilisation, ensuring and disciplining mass participation and strengthening the links and embedding ideology and war memory in leisure and everyday life.
The 1958 Commemoration of the Battle of Sutjeska
This is going to last for a few days. We need water, bread and meat; those are the three things we must provide.Footnote 79
The central commemorative event took place in Tjentište on 4 July. It began at 7:30am with the battle participants, who had been woken in their camps by fanfares at 5am and were then organised into 16 brigades for the ceremonial troop inspection by Tito.Footnote 80 The official programme involved laying wreaths on the ossuary by representatives of the party, organisations and foreign guests, followed by speeches by Tito, SUBNOR president Aleksandar Ranković and Đuro Pucar, the president of the Assembly of the People’s Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Gamal Abdel Nasser, who was visiting Yugoslavia with his family, also gave a speech.Footnote 81 The event was an occasion for awarding medals and decorations. The Sutjeska Memorial Medal was officially established, and Tito decorated all 16 brigades with the People’s Hero medal, after which he was given a Charter of Appreciation of the People of Yugoslavia in return.Footnote 82
The media reported that between 70,000 and 100,000 people attended the commemoration.Footnote 83 This number includes veterans who fought at Sutjeska, their families, state officials, foreign guests, social organisations and over 40,000 attendees from across the country.Footnote 84 Due to the limited roads to Tjentište, not all could arrive on the morning of 4 July, but organised arrivals began already on 1 July. Foča, a small town, was bustling with thousands of people who arrived by train and were taken to Tjentište by buses.Footnote 85 A city of tents sprang up along the Sutjeska river, with the main street that newspapers referred to as ‘Tjentište Boulevard’, with temporary constructions housing restaurants, dining halls, shops, public institutions, a hospital and emergency rooms, the post office and, as media reported, ‘everything that every big city has’.Footnote 86 The four post offices sold special envelopes and stamps dedicated to Sutjeska. In shops, one could buy special packets of cigarettes called ‘Sutjeska’, which were made for the occasion, and an anniversary newspaper with the same name, also available in the whole country.Footnote 87 In the evening, the whole valley was festive with thousands of lights and campfires and the sounds of Partisan songs.Footnote 88 In addition to the main camp and infrastructure in Tjentište, several social organisations had their own camps at different locations, including mountaineers, scouts, hostellers and Physical Education Association ‘Partizan’.
The commemoration promoted the official narrative about the NOB and the spirit of Sutjeska that should inspire younger generations: it was state-sponsored, involved speeches by the highest state officials and reflected official memory politics. However, it was not organised by state institutions but was a joint effort of SUBNOR and other organisations, which reflected the strengthening of cooperation in organising war remembrance. The commemoration did not involve only the official programme on 4 July, but also a variety of sports, cultural and entertainment activities organised and managed by social organisations in their camps and surrounding areas, which lasted for a few days. It exemplifies the diversification of social practices of memory, going beyond official, state-centred and ceremonial routines and the shift towards the youth, who became the main participants and audience in the Sutjeska commemoration.
The Agency and Logistics of Commemoration
Social and socio-political organisations were responsible for all the logistics concerning the central commemoration and were coordinated by SUBNOR and supported by the Yugoslav People’s Army. The 1958 commemoration links war remembrance to broader questions of socialist mobilisation, governance through social organisations and the management of mass participation.Footnote 89 It not only demonstrates that Yugoslav memory culture was not simply imposed from above but also illuminates the dense infrastructure of social mobilisation and the role of mass organisations in controlling mass participation.
The location and nature of the commemoration complicated the organisers’ responsibilities. In 1958, Tjentište, which would later become a memorial complex, lacked the infrastructure to accommodate more than 60,000 expected attendees. This meant that planning was not only focused on the event programme, but also required the organisation of drinking water, food stalls, bathrooms, camping areas and lighting, as well as security and medical services. The organisers considered entertainment equally important and wanted an intense programme to prevent boredom, which they feared could lead to a lack of discipline and ruin the whole event.Footnote 90 All organisations were instructed to tell all their members not to bring arms, and were worried about how to control and prevent attendees from drinking and shooting into the air in celebration.Footnote 91
Two main federal organs organised the central commemoration, alongside coordinating committees that operated at the county and municipal levels. The Organisational Board, which was comprised of prominent Partisans from all republics with Tito as president, oversaw the Tjentište event and commemorations across the country.Footnote 92 The Coordinating Committee gathered representatives of SUBNOR and all social organisations and was responsible for the official programme in Tjentište, as well as all tasks and logistics. The Committee began meeting in December 1957, eight months before the event. It brought together the widest possible range of associations, such as the Tourist Association of Yugoslavia (Turistički savez Jugoslavije) and other associations representing performers, visual and applied artists, literary authors, musicians, teachers and professors, dentists, doctors, firefighters, Esperantists and librarians, in addition to the already mentioned scouts, hostellers and mountaineers. These organisations either supported the central commemoration through activities or through providing services from their domains. They also organised their own initiatives and mobilised their respective memberships. Ensuring and organising mass participation was particularly important for youth-focused organisations, such as the PSJ and FSJ.
The organisations in the Coordinating Committee discussed plans for Sutjeska alongside other planned commemorations across the country and thought carefully about how each organisation could contribute. Many meetings were long brainstorming sessions in which representatives from dozens of organisations proposed activities related to the battle anniversary. The Tourist Association, for example, wanted to direct Yugoslav and foreign tourists heading to the Adriatic Sea to pass by Sutjeska.Footnote 93 The Association of Drama Artists (Savez dramskih umetnika) proposed that all theatres could organise appropriate plays, in addition to the plays that were already planned for the Sutjeska commemoration. Visual artists made the official poster and memorial pin for the anniversary, while literary authors organised events dedicated to Sutjeska across the country and campfire readings during the commemoration. The Committee also planned to release a vinyl record with Partisan songs. The Aeronautical Association (Vazduhoplovni savez) promoted the anniversary with aerial banners and filmed the event from above. The Esperantists promoted the event in their magazines and radio shows, whereas the Chess Association (Šahovski savez) organised a series of competitions that culminated with the all-Yugoslav youth tournament at Sutjeska.
The PSJ was a particularly important logistical partner for the 1958 commemoration because they had experience organising large-scale outdoor gatherings to commemorate important war anniversaries, including a camping event in Sutjeska in 1955. They were familiar with the area because they had already managed a large camp in Sutjeska and installed lights and telephone lines, so whenever the Committee could not handle an organisational issue, the mountaineers quickly provided a solution. Moreover, they helped relieve traffic pressure by hiking to Sutjeska from different directions while simultaneously marking the routes of the Partisan brigades during the 1943 battle.
Despite the long-term preparations, the organisational process involved last-minute changes that persisted until July. Even though the organisational bodies began meeting in 1957 and knew how demanding their work would be, numerous unresolved issues remained as the commemoration approached. For example, planning for the memorial park focused on the ossuary and the steps leading to it, which was supposed to be finished before July. However, in April 1958, the Organisational Board could still not agree on what exactly ought to be inscribed on the plaque; they had not hired the construction company and a stonemason to build it, the terrain still needed to be inspected for potential landslides and the excavation and gathering of skeletal remains across the large battle area was still ongoing.Footnote 94 The Board also only realised in April that they could not provide water, electricity and food themselves and would have to commission companies for these services. Worse still, they also needed someone legally eligible to sign contracts with them, as the Board or SUBNOR were not authorised to do so. Finally, the Army had to take over many logistical tasks and formed a technical committee to manage these practicalities of the commemoration.
Organisation and Infrastructure of Mass Participation
Sutjeska commemorations had attracted large crowds before 1958, usually around 15,000 people. As noted earlier, in 1958 the organisers expected around 60,000 people, including veterans who fought at Sutjeska, official guests, social organisations members and unorganised participants from across the country, who represented the majority. Most participants affiliated with different organisations not only attended the official programme on 4 July, but also stayed in Tjentište for at least a few days, arriving on 1 July due to traffic management.Footnote 95 For many, the whole event was weeks-long because they marched and hiked to Sutjeska, and many continued their journey to holidays at the seaside afterwards. The number of people, the location and the prolonged stay required appropriate infrastructure, as well as the organisation and disciplining of participation by social and socio-political organisations. Therefore, memory politics represents both an organisational and material practice.
SUBNOR and social organisations at the municipal and county levels registered participants from within their respective memberships and compiled lists that were crucial for the organisation of arrivals, traffic and accommodation. There were several camps across Sutjeska. The battle combatants whose procession opened the official programme stayed in two main camps near the commemoration site, and SUBNOR managed their attendance, arrival and stay. The FSJ, PSJ and Partizan had their own large camps with separate infrastructure.
The camps for battle participants were organised according to their wartime formations, brigades, units and divisions. From 1 July, the camps were sites of veterans recognising, greeting and hugging each other, searching for their comrades, evoking war memories and telling anyone who would listen about the sites where they had been wounded during the battle.Footnote 96 SUBNOR considered everyone who participated in the battles in Sandžak, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Montenegro between 15 May and 15 June 1943 as participants in the Battle of Sutjeska, but not all were invited to the commemoration. According to the minutes of SUBNOR internal meetings, those who were considered to be pro-Soviet after the 1948 split (so-called ibeovci) could only come if they ‘realised their mistakes and became active in social organisations’, and local veteran organisations marked each person not to be invited with comments such as ‘ibeovac’, ‘criminal’ or ‘deserter’.Footnote 97 For battle participants, the Organising Board covered travel and food costs, with every veteran making a donation in return to support the education of the children of fallen fighters at an amount that corresponded to their means. They were instructed to travel by train to Foča and Bileća, where army vehicles picked them up and transported them to the camps. They had to be organised into groups with leaders, and the Coordinating Committee had to know the train schedules and which group was on which train. Each of them received a hay mattress, a blanket, a plate and a spoon, and camps organised lunches in four shifts in the dining halls that could accommodate 500–600 people.Footnote 98 The battle participants did not have any planned activities before 4 July, and they could stay in the area and visit the battle sites on 5 and 6 July. Due to the terrain, the camps were not accessible to veterans with disabilities.
Other camps belonged to social organisations, which were strictly divided and organised. The commemoration centred on younger generations. The most prominent organisations that brought large numbers of people without direct war experience to Sutjeska were mountaineering and hostelling associations, the PSJ and FSJ. When selecting who should join the commemoration and their camps at Sutjeska, organisations focused on younger people from the whole of Yugoslavia in order to demonstrate the Yugoslav character of the event, rather than it being only a matter for the Socialist Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, on whose territory the battle had taken place. Sutjeska was imagined to have a more positive political impact than school classes and lectures because it allegedly permitted youth to more directly experience the revolution.Footnote 99 These gatherings were not only about commemorating the war but also about connecting young people from different parts of Yugoslavia and providing them with the opportunity to see different parts of the country.
Around 4,000 hostellers came together for a 4-day FSJ camp in the village of Suha, the site where Tito and the Supreme Headquarters broke through enemy lines. This was the third federal-level gathering of the FSJ, following previous ones in Zagreb and Belgrade. The PSJ brought around 2,000 people from across Yugoslavia, who set out for Sutjeska a few weeks ahead of 4 July and travelled along the routes of different Partisan brigades who hailed from their republics.Footnote 100 The entire routes taken by mountaineering brigades were dedicated to commemorating the war, including the departure ceremonies, the reading of war memoirs and listening to the Partisans’ memories on the way and, finally, the commemoration and cultural programme that they engaged in upon arrival at the camp at Sutjeska. They took trains and hiked along precisely predetermined routes. Travelling to Sutjeska took between four and eight days for most of the groups, some of whom walked the entire way for hundreds of kilometres.
Large-scale initiatives like Sutjeska were very costly for all participating organisations, and they covered some of these costs through the nominal fees paid by participants to take part in hikes, as well as to camp and to obtain hay or food.Footnote 101 For the PSJ, as for SUBNOR, discipline was a top priority because of the number of participants, expensive transportation schedule, camp preparation and maintenance. They directed the local and regional organisations to select their best mountaineers to represent their organisations. The PSJ camp organisation highlights the complexity of the logistical side of war commemoration: each regional or local PSJ league had to provide tents for its members or borrow them from neighbouring organisations if they did not have enough. All equipment had to be delivered by 18 June so that camps could be finalised by 25 June, but the regional meetings were already held on 8 June, during which tents were collected for shipment to Sutjeska. Each group had to write their name and location on a piece of fabric and stitch it to the tent so it would not get lost.Footnote 102 Those hiking to Sutjeska slept in schools and other public buildings along the way, which was organised by local SUBNOR branches. Even though the organisation planned everything carefully months in advance, many issues arose: tents were not always marked and got mixed up, and people did not always follow the rules upon arrival and instead occupied random tents.
Like the PSJ, the FSJ members marched along the routes of the Partisan units from across the country. Around 1,500 young people marched 2,300 kilometres altogether, and on the way, they organised various programmes for themselves and local audiences, such as reenactments, film screenings in villages, the laying of wreaths on the graves of the fallen partisans, tending to Partisans’ cemeteries and organising campfires and sport competitions against locals.Footnote 103 Those who got tired on the way were carried by horses. Some brigades organised parades through cities like Sarajevo before reaching Sutjeska. In preparation for Sutjeska, they organised over 40 gatherings and 30 marches with 15,000 participants.Footnote 104
No one could approach the commemoration site and participate unless they had registered with an organisation in advance. For individuals attending the commemoration, whether from the surrounding area or other parts of Yugoslavia, no accommodation was available. The same went for the families of fallen fighters, who were discouraged from coming on the basis that they could visit to ossuary after the commemoration.Footnote 105 There was an area reserved for individual tents, but this meant that anyone not staying in a camp for battle participants or social organisations would have to bring their own tent and all other necessities. The interest across the country was enormous, and organisations could not accept everyone who wanted to go to Sutjeska, which often led people to try their luck with multiple organisations.
How was everyday life organised in the camps? All aspects of camps, including necessities like food, water and sanitation, as well as entertainment, cultural activities and sports, were organised by the Coordinating Committee and social organisations that either had camps or whose work was related to specific activities, such as literature or music. While water was provided and stalls sold food and other necessities around the commemoration site, the transportation of additional materials and equipment to Sutjeska beyond what was absolutely necessary was complicated and expensive, so social organisations and their members had to bring as much as they could with them. The Army, as a key logistical partner, provided many missing supplies, including tents and generators. The Coordinating Committee primarily worried about order and discipline and banned the sale and use of alcohol in camps, though it considered beer a non-alcoholic drink. Here too, the preparations had numerous gaps. In April 1958, the Committee still considered it impossible to organise electrical lighting in the camps and instead recommended using fire, candles and oil lamps. Eventually, just in time for the commemoration and with the Army’s help, the whole Sutjeska valley was illuminated with thousands of light bulbs.Footnote 106
The food sold at the commemorative event was supposed to be of higher quality than the average diet of the majority of the population, but the menu consisted of sandwiches, meat and bread rather than cooked meals because it was easier to prepare. The organisers requested that the hospitality representatives keep their prices as low as those in nearby towns, such as Foča, meaning that food suppliers would have to pay the difference given the costs of transport and logistics. Negotiation on this was possible, as the commemoration organisers needed the food stalls more than the hospitality enterprises needed the Sutjeska commemoration, so they had to agree to a slightly higher price with the condition that no one could use the commemoration for profit.Footnote 107
War Remembrance as Social Practice
War commemoration in Yugoslavia was intertwined with leisure, sport, tourism and entertainment. The Sutjeska commemoration embodies war remembrance as social practice that stems from the shift in memory politics towards young people. The shift made social organisations that gathered youth and children and were responsible for the leisure and sport domains, like the FSJ, PSJ or Partizan, key actors in the social production of war memory, thereby leading to the diversification of commemorative practices. Without this shift, the 1958 commemoration of the Battle of Sutjeska would not have been so focused on facilitating mass participation through social organisations, camps or a rich programme of cultural, sport, recreation and entertainment activities. The cultural, sport and other activities were important not only for keeping the spirit of Sutjeska alive but also for security reasons, to keep people entertained and prevent uncontrolled behaviour. Most of these activities were also not spontaneous; each organisation gathered information months earlier about the potential participation of its members.
The cultural programme at the central commemorative event featured a military band and a choir, but literary readings, musical performances and film screenings took place in the camps’ central areas. There were literary readings dedicated to Sutjeska, multiple choirs singing Partisan songs, live music, film screenings and opportunities for Battle of Sutjeska participants to share their war memories around Partisan campfires (partizanske vatre). The so-called fighters-storytellers (borci pripovedači) were combatants during the Battle of Sutjeska and often prominent authors, like Branko Ćopić, who either shared their war stories or read their work to those gathered around the fire in the evenings. On 3 July, for example, Tito and Nasser, together with Nasser’s entourage and the highest Yugoslav state officials, sat around one of the dozens of Partisan campfires, where scouts, mountaineers and veterans sang Partisan songs until late in the night.Footnote 108 Numerous sports competitions and activities also took place between 1 and 5 July, including a large land navigation competition, quizzes, a chess tournament, kayaking, boxing matches, wrestling and athletics. The Association of Amateur Photographers (Savez foto-amatera) organised an exhibition on themes of the NOB.
The future-oriented, revolutionary and antifascist memory culture served as the symbolic framework for a popular socialist culture within which people from across Yugoslavia connected. For both the PSJ and FSJ, travelling to Sutjeska and back involved marches, hikes, tourist visits, parades, movie screenings, socialising with local youth and various other activities that were often intertwined with visits to sites of memory and commemorative practices. In their camps, young people danced and sang, competed in various sports, made friends and engaged in various leisure and recreation activities, regarding the event as a camping holiday with Sutjeska as the theme. A few hundred hostellers, for example, continued their journey to the seaside after the Sutjeska event, while those from Serbia went rafting down the river Drina on their way home.
During the camp from 2 to 6 July, the PSJ organised numerous tours and hikes around Sutjeska for their members, which varied in length and difficulty. In the FSJ camp, young people competed in sports like running and athletics, in making travel plans and programmes and in various quizzes and literary contests, while many also played volleyball and other sports for fun. In the evenings, as in other camps, there was a rich cultural programme, as young people were entertained by live bands and folklore ensembles who sang and danced for their peers. The Partisans who fought in the Battle of Sutjeska visited the camp regularly to share their war memories.
The visits of prominent guests were also celebratory occasions. On 2 July, Aleksandar Ranković visited the FSJ camp as the patron of their Sutjeska gathering. He gave a speech, talked to various brigades and ended up dancing kolo with some of them. More excitement followed on the same day when Tito passed through Suha in a car with Nasser, prompting standing ovations across the camp. On the following day, Tito visited the camp and spent two hours talking about the Fifth Offensive, showing the participants locations he remembered and describing what they looked like during the war.Footnote 109 He brought his camera and took numerous photographs and filmed the area around the camp. During these visits, people broke into song and dance, usually Kozaračko kolo, a circular traditional dance associated with the Partisans from Bosnia and Herzegovina that spread across Yugoslavia during the war.
Conclusion
The 1958 commemoration of the Battle of Sutjeska was not the first or only large-scale commemoration of the war or the battle in socialist Yugoslavia. However, it marked a turning point when the battle anniversary became an all-Yugoslav symbol of the war and revolution, especially when it was amalgamated with Fighter’s Day as a commemoration both on the site of the battle and across Yugoslavia. Organising this commemorative event required tasks that are rarely examined in studies of memory politics, but which are central to the production of war remembrance. The location of the central event – amidst nature and surrounded by forests and hills – determined the tasks and the format, as well as the more than 60,000 people who were expected at Sutjeska. It was not enough to think only about the narrative the event would convey and the official protocol for the commemoration. The whole area had to be prepared and surveyed; the event required complex infrastructure and the planned camps that were to house thousands of people also necessitated the organisation of entertainment and discipline. Everyone had to eat and drink, have a place to sleep, have access to bathrooms and be occupied enough so that the gathering did not descend into chaos.
The memory of the NOB was the fundamental official and state-building narrative in socialist Yugoslavia and key to state-sponsored memory politics, but it was also the bedrock of a broader societal memory culture. Understanding memory as a social practice illuminates how war remembrance is organised, materially sustained and socially enacted, as well as the embeddedness of memory and ideology in leisure and everyday life. It also points to multifaceted agency beyond war commemoration and the intertwining of official memory politics and social frames of remembrance.
Shifting attention from official narratives and representations to the logistical organisation and practical infrastructure of war remembrance, by identifying actors and specifying practices, connects memory with broader questions of socialist mobilisation, governance through organisations and the management of mass participation in Yugoslav state socialism. Organising the commemoration brought together numerous social actors and integrated diverse sports, recreational and cultural activities involving youth. Therefore, the 1958 anniversary illuminates the intensification of cooperation among social organisations, the shift towards youth and the diversification of social practices of war memory in Yugoslavia. State and political actors in Yugoslavia considered mass youth participation in political rituals (which often revolved around war memory) to be crucial for the perpetuity of the revolution and the struggle for socialism. As the case of the 1958 Sutjeska commemoration demonstrates, it was social organisations that ensured and managed the wide mobilisation and participation in war remembrance and served as key agents in the broader context of socialist mobilisation in Yugoslavia.
Beyond the contexts of Yugoslavia and state socialism, the social production of war remembrance and its logistical planning are key aspects of the still underexplored social history of memory. The shift away from narratives and representations to agency, logistics and infrastructures shows how memory politics works in practice and mobilises people. It also highlights that remembrance is not only a political, but also a social practice that is embedded in everyday life and intertwined with leisure, entertainment, sport, tourism and, very often, fun.
Funding statement
The research for this article was supported by APART-GSK funding from the Austrian Academy of Sciences.
