This eclectic volume offers fascinating, erudite musings on the purposes and practices of business history. The authors, with decades of experience as practitioners and editors, are less concerned with assessing what the field is or has been than with suggesting what it might become. Inspired as much by theory as by example, they point toward “traps” and “opportunities” facing business historians and discuss “concepts and frameworks” that may prove useful in conducting future inquiries. Only a quarter of the collection identifies promising themes being pursued in contemporary scholarship. The approach is consciously discursive rather than rigidly prescriptive. The authors encourage readers to dip into the book randomly over the course of an extended period of time rather than reading straight through. They try to maintain a conversational tone, in order to retain the spirit in which the essays initially took form.
The net effect serves to reinforce the book's implicit underlying message that a reimagined business history will above all be one that steadfastly resists grand narratives of structural change across time. Reimagining requires not just rejecting the particular narrative of Alfred Chandler, but also forgoing the ideals of comprehensiveness and certainty such a treatment embodies. Thus the list of traps includes “misplaced concreteness, [forced] periodization, retrospective rationalization, searching for a new dominant paradigm, scientism [i.e., ‘prescribing a rigorous set of canons … which constitute the only route to valid knowledge’], taking discourse at face value and numbers for granted, taking the United States (or the West) as normal or normative, and the rush to the recent [which skews inquiry toward the concerns of contemporary business practitioners rather than taking them on their own terms].” Add in tendencies to neglect the state (which is “always ‘in’”) while privileging the firm, and you get a pretty thorough indictment of the Chandlerian synthesis, as well as a stern warning to those who would try to assemble an alternative.
Rather, Scranton and Fridenson suggest business historians revel in the richness and variety of the many particular experiences that constitute business activity. Above all, they look for scholarship, which will elucidate and embrace the inherent slipperiness and indeterminancy of it all. Their list of opportunities calls attention to “artifacts, creation and creativity, complexity, improvisation, reflexivity, ritual and symbolic practices, the centrality of failure, and varieties of uncertainty.” They suggest we explore such matters by focusing upon “non-profits, microbusiness, the military, and public-private boundaries.” In identifying specific themes of promise, they emphasize phenomena such as “property, standards, professional services, fraud, transnational exchange, and trust, cooperation and networks,” and they direct our attention toward “projects, emergent nations, gender, and the subaltern.” Business history thus transcends the profit-seeking firm evolving in time, and instead assembles an inventory of recurrent behaviors and cultural practices operating across a broad range of institutions without direction or overarching coherence.
This is a broad, encompassing vision of the field—if not a fully historicized one—and the authors end the book with an insightful guide to concepts and approaches they believe might prove useful in bringing such history to light. Most of these derive from cultural and social theorists (notably Anthony Giddens, who looms especially large) who have considered such fundamentals as time, space, risk, memory, flows, actor networks, communities of practice, and the intriguing notion of liquid modernity. In condensing an impressive array of social and cultural theory and rendering it accessible and useable to business historians, Scranton and Fridenson have performed perhaps their greatest service. These concluding essays will certainly reward business historians aspiring to connect with the broader community of professional historians.
Connections to economic history may prove more difficult. With their disdain for numbers, suspicion of universal concepts, and critique of scientism, Scranton and Fridenson often seem aggressively resistant to economic history as currently practiced. This is unfortunate, for much of the best work in economic history addresses precisely the sorts of themes that concern Scranton and Fridenson and aspires to similar ends, only from a different theoretical perspective and with an alternative methodology. There is much to be gained from opening a fruitful discourse between the two fields. In addition to offering additional insights into concepts such as trust and property, such an exchange might also encourage business historians to engage broader, synthetic questions involving change over time.
