Why did some indigenous peasants support Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path, SL) while others fought against it? Miguel La Serna's The Corner of the Living attempts to answer this question. Like Jaymie Heilman's Before the Shining Path (Stanford University Press, 2011), this book is part of a growing literature on the insurgency produced by historians, albeit historians comfortable with multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary methodologies. Like Heilman, La Serna also focuses on two communities in Ayacucho, the department of Peru most affected by the conflict. In La Serna's case, these are highly emblematic communities. Chuschi, in the province of Cangallo, was the location of SL's first armed action, when, in 1980, its militants burned the ballot boxes during the presidential elections. Huaychao, in Huanta province, was arguably where the peasant-led counter-insurgency against the movement began in 1983, when a group of Senderistas was captured and killed by comuneros.
La Serna explores the history of these two communities since the mid-twentieth century in order to attempt to explain why they reacted so differently to the insurgency during the first few years of the conflict. Whereas in Chuschi SL found ample support among the peasant community, in Huaychao it encountered widespread resistance. La Serna draws on the work of scholars of violence such as Charles Tilly and Stathis Kalyvas in accounting for this divergence. He does not deny that both SL and the armed forces used violence against the indigenous peasantry. However, in line with the report of the Peruvian Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the work of anthropologists such as Kimberly Theidon, he rejects interpretations of the conflict that see peasant communities as being caught between ‘two fires’. Instead, he suggests that ‘indigenous peasants … took advantage of the civil war to bring about violent solutions to local matters that were often tangentially related to the macropolitics of the armed conflict itself’ (p. 11).
In the first three chapters La Serna explores the divergence between Chuschi and Huaychao by looking at the legitimacy of community authorities, the nature of intra- and inter-community relations, and the relations between the communities and local non-indigenous power holders such as landlords and regional authorities in the 30 years or so before the start of the insurgency. Whereas in Chuschi the inability to deal with delinquency, such as cattle rustling, and significant outmigration eroded the legitimacy of community authorities, in Huaychao no such erosion occurred, at least not to the same degree. Whereas relations between Chuschi and neighbouring communities, particularly Quispillaccta, were marked by acute tension, even armed conflict, in Huaychao inter-community relations were marked by collaboration. Finally, whereas peasants in Chuschi had to contend with abusive local power holders such as mayors and teachers, which led to a crisis of authority, relations in Huaychao with local hacendados, while asymmetrical, were far more consensual.
La Serna then turns to the first years of the internal armed conflict. He shows very clearly how the violence of the internal armed conflict mapped on to the local experience in each community. In Chuschi, he argues, support for SL in the first few years was voluntary. It drew on the perception that SL could right a number of wrongs – wrongs associated with intra- and inter-community relations, and with local non-indigenous power holders. Summary justice, in the form of popular trials leading to executions, was embraced, in some cases though not in all, as a way to punish those comuneros and local authorities who had routinely escaped other forms of justice. But the Senderista violence also reshaped the conflict between Chuschi and Quispillaccta, with campesinos in both communities seeing the new regime of violence as a way to settle old scores.
In Huaychao, by contrast, the community rejected SL. After killing seven Senderistas who had come to the community seeking its allegiance in 1983, Huaychao set up a peasant militia, with support from the armed forces. As is well known, a counter-insurgency strategy based on rondas campesinas like the one established in Huaychao would eventually play a key role in defeating SL. According to La Serna, Huaychao rejected SL because it represented a threat to what the comuneros perceived as their own effective administration of the community's affairs and more broadly as a threat to local ‘culture’. There was no need for Senderista ‘justice’; Huaychao's system of customary law could resolve local disputes effectively. The anti-landlord and class discourse of SL found few takers in a community where relations with the local landlord had been broadly positive. Although inter-community tensions with neighbouring villages did erupt, they did not reach the degree of violence seen in Cangallo.
In a final chapter, La Serna considers, somewhat more briefly, some of the consequences of the internal armed conflict in both communities. Despite the significant differences in the experience of war in Chuschi and Huaychao, both communities saw a probably irreversible erosion of the legitimacy and power of traditional authorities, such as the varayoqs, and a growing power of the rondas campesinas. In terms of gender relations, the communities experienced important changes. Some women took an increasingly active role in their communities in the context of the conflict, establishing Clubes de Madres, for example – although La Serna recognises that the patriarchal order in the communities was not significantly undermined. Finally, the emblematic character of both Chuschi and Huaychao meant that in the post-conflict context both communities came under significant attention from both the state and civil society. This had important consequences for the community members, who have benefited materially in ways that other, less emblematic communities, also affected by the violence in Ayacucho and elsewhere, have not.
Throughout the book La Serna very successfully combines ample archival material with interviews and ethnographic observation, and elegant prose, to produce both a very clear and very compelling account of the history of these two communities, but also a convincing explanation for why indigenous peasant communities in Ayacucho had such disparate reactions to SL. This community-level analysis sheds light not only on the particular experiences of Chuschi and Huaychao but also on the complex combination of factors that account for the rise and fall of SL and for the course that the internal armed conflict took. In this sense, The Corner of the Living represents a major and original contribution to an ongoing attempt by historians and social scientists to build upon, and in some ways go beyond, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's 2003 final report in explaining the causes and course of Peru's internal armed conflict.
