This book was designed to celebrate the display of the three Herculaneum Women at the Getty in 2007, where they holidayed while their own home, the Albertinum at Dresden, was being renovated. The beautifully illustrated volume takes the opportunity of this sojourn, and their spruce up by the conservators, to bring together their histories both as artefacts and types, from their context in the theatre at Herculaneum, excavation and subsequent display, restoration and conservation to the Greek origin of the types and their proliferation across the Roman Empire. The Herculaneum Women are a promising subject for such an approach: they enjoy a rather awkward stardom, plucked rather by chance as surviving fragments of Prince D’Elboeuf's chaotic excavations at Herculaneum, yoked together as a pair (the third conveniently side lined), praised by Winckelmann, instantly recognizable but also somehow falling short of premier league status.
The book takes a narrative approach: ch. 4 on the role of the Herculaneum Women type's across the Roman Empire is basically a summary of the recent findings of Trimble and Alexandridis, both of whom have published excellent discussions on this topic in the recent past. Most relevant of their findings is that the real value of these sculptures was in their very ordinariness: offering a prototype for the well-to-do women of empire and shunned by empresses, who depend on making more of a splash.
It is here that there are many games to be had with the Herculaneum Women and the obvious tensions between their past and present histories, the most striking of which is their post-antique pursuit of fame, dependent on their ‘originality’, and their ancient value dependent on their repetition and ‘blending in’ properties. This tension is ever present, if only fully acknowledged in the last page of the text. The story of the types and their ancient uses and distribution seems constantly at odds with the need to reaffirm their status as ‘originals’ and their rooted location in both Herculaeum and Dresden. This leaves some interesting avenues unexplored: in particular, their immediate post-War history. Having survived the bombing of Dresden, they were whisked away to Russia, returning only in 1959. The narrative reduces the adventure to a digression, a blip that need not detract from the ‘Dresdenness’ of these pieces.
Ch. 6 asks why the Women, having been viewed and praised by Winckelmann, and as ‘originals’ with credentials, never got to be more famous. The explanation that these works of art were lost, drowned out by their reproduction in cast form and by the casts displayed around them, does not seem completely convincing given that many favourite sculptures have a similar back story. Most importantly, this explanation reveals the contradiction at the heart of the book: a desire for these starlets to be elevated and valued as originals rubs up against the story of their sometimes undignified display (posing amongst pot plants and primates) and unassuming subject. Does the same wish drive the quest to find the types’ ultimate origin in one (or rather two) late fourth-century (handily ‘classical’) celebrity masterpieces? The insistence seems rather to undermine the concept not only of how the types worked in Roman times but also the evidence for their use in the Hellenistic period.
The book finishes by giving (what was at the time of writing) a preview of the Women's updated residence: a smaller gallery, in which they are the main focus, will induce appropriate reverence. The indignities of the past will be removed: the plaster casts that once crowded them are off to form a study collection and the plaster head of the third woman, that made her a duplicate of the Small Herculaneum Woman, has been whipped off. The display seems somewhat at odds with the approach taken in the book. It would seem that the Women's temporary uprootedness has allowed the exploration of these multiple histories before they return to their day job, of ‘real’ museum pieces. As such, this book should be read as a well-written and informed souvenir of their holiday.
