Composer Jeff Scott’s Passion for Bach and Coltrane (2023) is a genre-blending and spiritually transcendent album that unites performers, musical styles and references, and poetry into a cohesive message emphasizing the humanity of twenty-first century Black music and its musicians in the United States. Winner of the 2024 Grammy Award for Best Classical Compendium, Passion features complex and moving performances from poet A.B. Spellman (a leading member of the 1960s and 1970s Black Arts Movement), Imani Winds, the Harlem Quartet, and a jazz trio with Alex Brown on piano, Edward Perez on bass, and Neal Smith on drums. The album is accompanied by notes highlighting the relationships between Scott, Spellman, Bach, and Coltrane, written by Imani Winds oboist Toyin Spellman-Diaz, A.B. Spellman’s daughter. The goals of the composition and its recording are clear and are further mirrored in the missions of each of the performing forces: (1) to build a sonic space within European classical music that incorporates a diversity of sounds, (2) to show Black and Latinx musicians as belonging in European classical musical spaces and soundscapes (despite their historic marginalization), and (3) to offer a meditation on anti-Black violence.
Passion begins with two pairs of spoken dedications to Bach and Coltrane from Spellman titled “Dear John.” This opening immediately justifies what might, to some, seem like an odd pairing between an eighteenth-century composer known for virtuosic contrapuntal flights of fancy and a twentieth-century jazz musician revered for his improvised “sheets of sound” and credited with igniting the spiritual jazz movement. Throughout, Scott borrows and transforms music from both composers, particularly Bach’s Goldberg Variations (1741) and Coltrane’s A Love Supreme (1964)—indeed, the titles of some tracks signal these moments of borrowing and transformation.
The first two pieces (“Dear John, Pt. 1: Bach” and “Aria”) imagine Spellman writing late at night, suddenly catching a bit of Bach on the radio. The next three tracks (“Dear John, Pt. 2: Coltrane,” “Psalm,” and “Resolution”) reflect a change in the station to Coltrane, an experience that, for Spellman, is remarkably similar to listening to Bach. In one poem, Spellman tells Coltrane, “If I believed in heaven, I would ask if you and Bach ever swapped infinite fours.” In addition to themes from A Love Supreme, “Psalm” notably features Spellman’s poem, “After Vallejo” (2008), and an oboe solo from Toyin Spellman-Diaz makes an uncannily impressive substitute for Coltrane’s soprano saxophone in “Resolution.” From there, Passion moves to the Passion of Christ, narrated in Spellman’s words (“Out of Nazareth, Pt. 1” and “Out of Nazareth, Pt. 2: Manual for a Crucifixion”) (I discuss part 2 further below). Tracks 8−12 (“Variation 13,” “Groovin’ Low,” “Among the Things I Must Have Known,” “Interlude,” and “A Hug for Gonzalo”) each move easily across musical styles, from a theme from the thirteenth variation of Bach’s Goldberg Variations, to a reflection on the relationship between European classical improvisation and jazz, to a tribute to Cuban pianist Gonzalo Rubalcaba that features driving rhythms. The last track, “Acknowledgment,” features the iconic four-note motive from A Love Supreme beloved by so many jazz musicians, critics, and fans alongside Spellman’s “Death Poem.” Here, clarinetist Mark Dover takes on an extended and virtuosic improvised solo much in the style of Coltrane. The recording ends with the instrumentalists singing “A Love Supreme,” just as on the Coltrane album.
Does the fusion of jazz, spoken word, and classical music in A Passion for Bach and Coltrane “work?” It does, with evocative verve and innovation. Scott calls his compositional style “urban classical music.” In a 2024 virtual interview with the Philadelphia Chamber Music Society, he describes the segregation between the music he heard growing up and the music he studied—he is both conservatory trained in “traditional European” classical music, and his music is also “informed and truly guided by [his] urban upbringing and [his] urban experience” growing up in New York City.Footnote 1 As Philip Ewell notes, although many colleges and universities now have programs in jazz, curricula in European classical music studies and jazz often remain segregated from one another.Footnote 2 Such refusal to dedicate either the time or money to the study of jazz and other Black musical traditions reflects anti-Black bias pervasive in many departments and schools of music. The binary between the two musics that emerged somewhere around the mid-twentieth century—that jazz was a perfect mixture of European classical harmony and African rhythm—alongside the patronizing, racist, and pervasive belief that jazz music had only to “grow up” (or “become a lady”) to become an art music persists. It is still written, it is still taught, and it is still believed by a surprising number of people. Through the composition’s compelling blend of musical styles and the recording’s commitment to performing forces working to create greater equity in the broader field of European classical music, Scott’s Passion ably lays to rest both lies about the distance between and status of both musics.
Passion’s broader message about anti-Blackness doesn’t rest only (or even primarily) within musical fields. Composed in 2015 and recorded in 2023, Passion demands to be heard across what might be called the #blacklivesmatter decade, beginning in 2013 following the acquittal of George Zimmerman of the murder of Trayvon Martin. By the time Passion was released, support for the Black Lives Matter movement had dropped from 55% in August 2017 to 51% in April 2023.Footnote 3 I found the emotional center of the piece in track 7, “Out of Nazareth, Pt. 2: Manual for a Crucifixion.” In this section, the resonance between anti-Black violence at the hands of police and the historically anti-Black treatment of Black music and musicians across institutions of European classical music in the United States resounds and coalesces. The track begins with Spellman matter-of-factly explaining the best practices for a crucifixion in terms that make plain the relationship between Christ’s death, the lynchings of Black people in the Jim Crow South, and the recorded and streamed deaths of Black men and women at the hands of police in the twenty-first century:
a crowd
always turns out for a lynching and they will taunt him
with insults and throw refuse. let them. it makes a good show
keeps the people happy and gives the
prisoner the full benefit
of the experience by letting him die humiliated.Footnote 4
Spellman’s seeming nonchalance in tone suggests an emotional distance from the crucifixion that appears mismatched with the physical proximity to the event. However, rather than rest in judgment of the narrator, Spellman’s poetry, accompanied by a quiet, unobtrusive, perhaps Bach-ian string trio, reminds listeners that these murders exist in and for the public sphere; that, regardless the mode or method of sharing (be it a postcard of a lynching in the 1930s or a video shot on iPhone and shared on social media), we are all potential actors in this mob that has existed across the centuries.
If this piece were assigned to undergraduate students for musicological study (which I can easily imagine), it would be easy to frame it as either a remnant of the 2015 start of the #blacklivesmatter movement (when it was composed), or a response to the growth of the equity movement in classical fields by 2023 (when it was recorded). But the work of A.B. Spellman, Jeff Scott, Imani Strings, and the Harlem Quartet to build sound worlds that accept a greater diversity of voices does not end with Passion, and the piece will continue to resonate beyond 2023. For example, I listened to this for the first time the day after the January 20, 2025 inauguration, an event that eclipsed remembrances of Martin Luther King, Jr. and that ended in the pardoning of (among others) insurrectionists who had, amidst their violence, placed a MAGA hat on a statue of King in the Capitol Rotunda.Footnote 5 What does hearing Passion right now (whenever right now is) do to and for its listeners? How do we witness this Passion? How does it speak to and across moments in history, including those in the future? Passion’s ability to create space for such conversations in the past, present, and future is a compelling reminder of why equity work in music fields matters: because anti-Blackness anywhere offers an excuse for anti-Blackness to exist everywhere.
Kelsey Klotz is an (ethno)musicologist specializing in jazz history, race and gender studies, and American cultural studies. Her book, Dave Brubeck and the Performance of Whiteness (Oxford University Press, 2023), uses jazz pianist Dave Brubeck as a frame to understand mid-century whiteness, privilege, and white supremacy more fully. She is an assistant professor in musicology/ethnomusicology at the University of Maryland, College Park.
