With the Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique now in its fiftieth year, as the founding English coeditor, I'm pleased to be able to reminisce about its first days.
This journal grew naturally out of the Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science (CJEPS), which had been published since the 1930s. CJEPS was a highly recognized journal; it was very successful internationally. But by the 1960s, there was a very conscious effort on the part of Canadian political scientists to see that their own discipline was recognized not just as kind of an offspring of economics but as a field of its own. In a sense, political science was just developing as a discipline, so we wanted to have a journal, and that's what we did. While we had been very happy to tag along with economists, eventually we thought we should have a journal of our own.
I was one of a group of people who wanted to see a political science journal in Canada but I hadn't planned to be the editor. I was approached by the Canadian Political Science Association to serve as the first English coeditor and, as a good citizen, I could hardly refuse. I was not given any instructions or direction from CPSA as to what the journal would look like; that was left that up to me and to the French coeditor.
In some respects it was an easy task. The journal was a continuation—an offspring—of CJEPS and we just continued in the traditions it had set. We became independent as political scientists but we benefited from the previous efforts and experience at CJEPS. Starting the journal was far less difficult than was the case with the other journal I founded, the International Political Science Review, the journal of the International Political Science Association. There, we had to start from scratch; there was nothing in place but much to be done, for example, negotiating with publishers.
Still, we had a sense at the journal that we were pioneering. It's always fun to be doing something pioneering. But as pioneers, we had to be good or things would go off the rails. I think we succeeded.
It helped a great deal that I had a wonderful assistant editor, Ed Black, who had recently come to Queen's from UBC. Ed had been a journalist in Vancouver and, in addition to his academic abilities, knew a lot about publishing.
From the outset we had two important goals. First, we wanted to maintain the same high quality level that CJEPS had attained. One of the ways I did that—and I think I succeeded—was to go out of my way at the beginning to solicit manuscripts from highly esteemed scholars, like C.B. Macpherson. We wanted to achieve a balance between publishing articles with a strong Canadian orientation and avoiding a narrowly Canadian outlook. I would sometimes prod people to submit their work to the journal. If I got wind of someone doing something interesting, I might drop them a note or phone and say, “Did you want to submit a paper to the journal?” And some did. For example, the lineup of authors in the very first issue was a very impressive one: Léon Dion, Al Johnson, Paul-Andre Comeau, Alan Cairns, Vincent Lemieux and C.B. Macpherson. How did I get them to submit papers? I just asked them, and as very co-operative people they agreed.
It's not that I had to be constantly beating the bushes to get good submissions. As a successor to CJEPS, we were well regarded as a quality journal, and of course having papers published in the journal was an important way for people to advance their careers. We didn't have a problem maintaining high quality in the articles we published.
As well, we insisted that papers submitted to the journal were adjudicated by good people to make sure that the quality was high. I know that it can be difficult for journal editors today to find peer reviewers but that was not a problem we had. Very seldom did people say no when asked to adjudicate a paper. At that time people had a strong commitment to what was really a new discipline and of course the political science community was much smaller then with stronger personal debts in relationships. I used the phone a lot to line up reviewers and found that most people I asked were willing to help.
In terms of fulfilling our mandate as an omnibus journal, we found we had to go out of our way to solicit papers from authors and on subjects that would otherwise be neglected. I recall that, even though C.B. Macpherson had been editor of CJEPS, political philosophy was area where we had to ensure that we had good submissions and good articles.
In our “Editorial Note” in the first issue of the journal we emphasized that we would not favour or discount any methodological or conceptual approach but would judge submissions on the basis of their contribution to political science.
Our second goal came out of our strong belief that the journal should be bilingual. Gérard Bergeron was the first French coeditor but he didn't stay very long. Léon Dion—father of Stéphane—became coeditor and he and I worked closely together for quite some time. We made a real effort to provide an opening for Francophone scholars to publish their work in the journal. We had a practice whereby I would read and comment on the French submissions and Léon would do the same with the papers in English.
We created structures and policies to be equally hospitable to scholars from both language communities. Because of their disparate sizes, and the greater interest of anglophones than francophones in the pan-Canadian CPSA and the journal, the English editorial team bore a disproportionately heavy load in creating a respectable organ for Canadian political science. I like to think that because of our efforts in the journal's early days, CJPS/RCSP still flourishes as a joint project of French- and English-speaking political scientists, coexisting happily in the pan-Canadian association.
Of course, many things have changed since the first days of the journal. For example, we didn't see gender as an issue in terms of who published in the journal. By contrast, to some extent we did pay attention to balance in the journal in terms of regions and the size of universities. We were conscious of the fact that there were some colleges and universities that weren't really involved in the national political science community so we consciously went after them to involve them in the journal.
Another way in which the journal in those days differed from the journal today is that the idea of graduate students submitting papers was not something that we considered. There might be the occasion exception; one who comes to mind was John Crosbie—yes, that John Crosbie. John wrote a very good undergraduate paper for me on local government in Newfoundland, a topic on which virtually nothing had been written. He revised his paper and it was published in CJEPS.
I very much enjoyed editing the journal; for me it was fun. I liked having to read things that I otherwise would not have read. Doing that kept me more open to the broad fields across the discipline and helped me to avoid becoming too specialized in my own bailiwick. Editing the journal was also a great way to stay in contact with colleagues, especially for a gregarious person like me. I had to give up editing the journal when I became chair of the CRTC, but I think we set it on a solid path. Long may it prosper.
