Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T12:00:54.174Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Turbulence kinetic energy transfers in direct numerical simulation of shock-wave–turbulence interaction in a compression/expansion ramp

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 February 2022

Niccolò Tonicello*
Affiliation:
CORIA - CNRS, Normandie Université, INSA de Rouen, Technopole du Madrillet, 76801 Saint-Etienne-du-Rouvray, France
Guido Lodato
Affiliation:
CORIA - CNRS, Normandie Université, INSA de Rouen, Technopole du Madrillet, 76801 Saint-Etienne-du-Rouvray, France
Luc Vervisch
Affiliation:
CORIA - CNRS, Normandie Université, INSA de Rouen, Technopole du Madrillet, 76801 Saint-Etienne-du-Rouvray, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: niccolo.tonicello@coria.fr

Abstract

A direct numerical simulation is performed for a supersonic turbulent boundary layer interacting with a compression/expansion ramp at an angle $\alpha =24^{\circ }$, matching the same operating conditions of the direct numerical simulation by Priebe & Martín (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 699, 2012, pp. 1–49). The adopted numerical method relies on the high-order spectral difference scheme coupled with a bulk-based, low-dissipative, artificial viscosity for shock-capturing purposes (Tonicello et al., Comput. Fluids, vol. 197, 2020, 104357). Filtered and averaged fields are evaluated to study total kinetic energy transfers in the presence of non-negligible compressibility effects. The compression motions are shown to promote forward transfer of kinetic energy down the energy cascade, whereas expansion regions are more likely to experience backscatter of kinetic energy. A standard decomposition of the subgrid scale tensor in deviatoric and spherical parts is proposed to study the compressible and incompressible contributions in the total kinetic energy transfers across scales. On average, the correlation between subgrid scale dissipation and large-scale dilatation is shown to be caused entirely by the spherical part of the Reynolds stresses (i.e. the turbulent kinetic energy). On the other hand, subtracting the spherical contribution, a mild correlation is still noticeable in the filtered fields. For compressible flows, it seems reasonable to assume that the eddy-viscosity approximation can be a suitable model for the deviatoric part of the subgrid scale tensor, which is exclusively causing forward kinetic energy cascade on average. Instead, more complex models are likely to be needed for the spherical part, which, even in statistical average, provides an important mechanism for backscatter.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Q-criterion contours coloured by velocity magnitude ($Q=1.0 u_{\infty }^{2}/\delta ^{2}$). In the background, numerical Schlieren is displayed to highlight the primary shock wave. Here, $\delta$ denotes incoming boundary layer thickness.

Figure 1

Table 1.Characteristic of the incoming boundary layer.

Figure 2

Table 2.Numerical discretisation details, where $N$ denotes order of approximation, $N_{x}, N_{y}, N_{z}$ denote the numbers of elements along the streamwise, wall-normal and spanwise directions, respectively, and ${\rm \Delta} x^{+}, {\rm \Delta} y^{+}, {\rm \Delta} z^{+}$ denote the wall-normalised grid spacings.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Compression/expansion ramp: computational grid. Here, $\delta$ denotes incoming boundary layer thickness.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Averaged (a) friction coefficient and (b) wall pressure, along the streamwise direction. Solid line, present simulation; dashed line, DNS by Zhu et al. (2017), dashed-dotted line, DNS by Priebe & Martín (2012). Black circle, measurements by Ringuette et al. (2009).

Figure 5

Figure 4.Tangential velocity profiles along the wall-normal direction. (a) $x=-3 \delta$. Solid line, present simulation; dashed line, DNS by Priebe & Martín (2012). (b) $x=4 \delta$. Solid line, present simulation; dashed line, DNS by Wu & Martín (2007); symbols, experimental data by Ringuette et al. (2009); the streamwise velocity is normalised by the outer velocity $u_{e}$ downstream of the main shock.

Figure 6

Figure 5.(a) Van Driest (VD) transformed streamwise velocity at $x=-8 \delta$. Solid line, present simulation; dashed line, DNS by Wu & Martín (2007); symbols, experimental data by Ringuette et al. (2009); dash-dotted line, $u_{VD}^{+} = y^{+}$ and $u_{VD}^{+} = 5.25 + \log (y^{+})/0.41$. (b) Normalised Reynolds stresses at $x=-8 \delta$. Solid line, present simulation; dashed line, DNS by Pirozzoli & Bernardini (2011b).

Figure 7

Table 3.Characteristics of the incoming boundary layer: reference versus computed.

Figure 8

Figure 6.Probe locations. In the background, instantaneous normalised velocity magnitude field.

Figure 9

Figure 7.Kinetic energy spectra. Dashed line, $x=-8\delta$; solid line, $x=4\delta$. $\mathbb {E}$ denotes the kinetic energy Fourier spectrum of the velocity signal: (a) applying Taylor's hypothesis to temporal signals; (b) along $z$ ($y=0.7\delta$), where the vertical dashed line represents the Nyquist grid wavenumber. Here, $\kappa$ represents the wavenumber, which is evaluated along the spanwise direction as $\kappa _{z} = 0.5/z$ and, using Taylor's hypothesis, as $\kappa =2 {\rm \pi}f/\langle {\|\boldsymbol {u}\|}\rangle$, with $f$ the temporal frequency of the time signal. Both spectra are normalised by the first mode.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Compensated kinetic energy spectra along $z$ ($y=0.7\delta$). Dashed line, $x=-8\delta$; solid line, $x=4\delta$. The horizontal solid line represents the classical value of Kolmogorov's constant, approximately equal to $1.5$ (Pope 2001).

Figure 11

Figure 9.Numerical Schlieren.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Instantaneous absolute value of the normalised spanwise component of the vorticity field (wall view). Vertical white lines represent compression and expansion corners. Three periods along the spanwise direction have been plotted.

Figure 13

Figure 11.PDFs of (a) pressure, (b) density, and (c) temperature, time signals at the downstream probe location. Dash-dotted line, conditional PDF with $Ma<1$; dashed line, conditional PDF with $Ma>1$; solid line, total PDF. Vertical dotted line in (a) represents the pressure mean value.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Snapshot of averaged artificial viscosity normalised by the molecular viscosity.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Averaged limiter activation.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Dissipation of the kinetic energy of the resolved scale ($K_3$ term of (4.8)).

Figure 17

Figure 15.Pressure-dilatation term ($K_1$ term of (4.8)).

Figure 18

Figure 16.Normalised turbulent kinetic energy: $2 \bar {\rho } k/(\rho _{\infty } u_{\infty }^{2})$.

Figure 19

Figure 17.Main terms of the resolved kinetic energy balance (see (4.8)) along the streamwise direction at height $y^{+}\approx 30$. Dashed line, flux term $K_{0}$; dotted line, pressure-dilatation work $K_{1}$; dash-dotted line, dissipation term of the resolved part of the kinetic energy $K_{3}$; solid line, local balance of the resolved kinetic energy $\sum _{i=0}^{5}K_{i}$ ($K_5$ from (4.13)). All the terms are normalised by $\rho _{\infty }u_{\infty }^{3}/ \delta$.

Figure 20

Figure 18.Artificial viscosity terms of the resolved kinetic energy balance. Dotted line, flux contribution $K_{5}^{f}$; dashed line, sink contribution $K_{5}^{s}$; solid line, sum of the two, $K_{5} = K_{5}^{f} + K_{5}^{s}$. Notice that the vertical axis units are scaled by $10^{-5}$.

Figure 21

Figure 19.(a) PDF of the SGS kinetic energy dissipation term ($K_{3}$). Black line, averaging; blue line, filtering with $\varDelta =2h$; red line, filtering with $\varDelta =4h$; and green line, filtering with $\varDelta =8h$. (b) Detailed view of (a).

Figure 22

Figure 20.Averaged SGS Mach number (see (4.14)).

Figure 23

Figure 21.Filtered SGS Mach number ($\varDelta = 4h$).

Figure 24

Figure 22.Filtered SGS Mach number ($\varDelta = 8h$).

Figure 25

Figure 23.JPDFs of dissipation of resolved scales ($K_3$) and resolved pressure-dilatation work ($K_1$). (a) Averaged data; (b) filtered data with $\varDelta = 4h$; (c) filtered data with $\varDelta = 8h$.

Figure 26

Figure 24.Visual comparison of dissipation (bottom, $K_3$) and pressure-dilatation work (top, $K_1$) for a given instantaneous filtered field ($\varDelta = 4h$). The two quantities are shown in a specular way to ease the comparison. White and black circles highlight regions of intense back and forward scattering, respectively.

Figure 27

Table 4.Correlation coefficients between $K_{1}$ and $K_{3}$, in the different quadrants.

Figure 28

Figure 25.JPDFs of SGS kinetic energy dissipation and $Ma_{{SGS}}$. (a) Averaged data; (b) filtered data with $\varDelta = 4h$; (c) filtered data with $\varDelta = 8h$.

Figure 29

Figure 26.Visual comparison of SGS dissipation (bottom) and SGS Mach number (top) for a given instantaneous filtered field ($\varDelta = 4h$). The two quantities are shown in a specular way to ease the comparison. Circles highlight strong energy transfer regions.

Figure 30

Figure 27.JPDFs of SGS dissipation and $\varLambda$. The solid black line denotes the line $\nu _{t}=0$. (a) Averaged data; (b) filtered data with $\varDelta = 4h$; (c) filtered data with $\varDelta = 8h$. Both $K_{3}$ and $\varLambda$ are normalised by $\rho _{\infty }u_{\infty }^{3}/ \delta$.

Figure 31

Table 5.Correlation coefficients between $\varLambda$ and $K_{3}$, in the different quadrants.

Figure 32

Figure 28.Comparison between averaged terms (a) $K_3$ and (b) $K_3+\varLambda$. Both terms are normalised by $\rho _{\infty }u_{\infty }^{3}/ \delta$.

Figure 33

Figure 29.JPDFs of deviatoric SGS dissipation and large-scale pressure-dilatation work. (a) Averaged data; (b) filtered data with $\varDelta = 4h$; (c) filtered data with $\varDelta = 8h$.

Figure 34

Table 6.Correlation coefficients between $K_{1}$ and $K_{3}+\varLambda$, in the different quadrants.

Figure 35

Figure 30.Averaged JPDFs of standard and deviatoric SGS dissipation and large-scale pressure-dilatation work. (a) $K_{3}$; (b) $K_{3}+\varLambda$.

Figure 36

Figure 31.Solution (red circles) and flux (blue squares) points of spectral difference discretisation in the reference element ($N=4$).

Figure 37

Figure 32.Distribution of solution (red circles) and flux points (blue squares) in the standard element for a third-order spatial discretisation.