Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T15:36:30.253Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Fluid density effects in supersonic jet-induced cratering in a granular bed on a planetary body having an atmosphere in the continuum regime

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 March 2021

Kaushik Balakrishnan
Affiliation:
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91109, USA
Josette Bellan*
Affiliation:
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91109, USACalifornia Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: josette.bellan@jpl.nasa.gov

Abstract

To investigate the effect of atmospheric density and jet-fluid density during supersonic jet-induced cratering on a granular particle bed, large eddy simulation (LES) for the fluid phase coupled with a granular flow model based on kinetic theory is used. Coupling accounts for momentum and energy interaction between particles and fluid. Several simulations are conducted that enable discriminating between the crater characteristics which depend on the atmospheric (or jet) density, and those which depend on the ratio between jet-fluid density and atmospheric density. The crater cross-sectional shapes are controlled by the density ratio between jet fluid and atmosphere. For large such ratios, the craters have a parabolic cross-section shape, are relatively shallow, have large diameters and have subdued ejecta. In contrast, for ratios close to unity, the craters have a conical cross-section, are relatively deep, have relatively small diameters and have substantial ejecta; these craters also display ripples on their walls. The physics leading to these differences is explained. Considerations of particle momentum flux indicate that at same fraction of the crater depth and same radial distance from the jet axis, the radial and vertical components have larger magnitudes for conical craters than for parabolic craters. The spatial distribution of the ratio between the drag force and the force due to the particles resistance to compaction are compared and it is found to be dependent on the jet-to-atmospheric fluid density ratio. A few features of the crater, in particular its depth, only depend on the atmospheric (or jet) fluid density.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of (a) the supersonic jet interacting with the granular particle bed; (b) the crater formed in the granular bed.

Figure 1

Table 1.Values of properties and coefficients used in this study.

Figure 2

Table 2.List of simulations. In all cases the jet temperature is 300 K, and the ambient temperature is 94 K, corresponding to the conditions on Titan. The jet exit plane Mach number is 1.5. The jet composition is $Y_{{\textrm {N}_2}} = 0.33$, $Y_{{\textrm {H}_2}\textrm {O}} = 0.34$, $Y_{{\textrm {CO}_2}} = 0.33$ and the ambient composition is $Y_{{\textrm {N}_2}} = 0.99$ and $Y_{{\textrm {CH}_4}} = 0.01$, corresponding to that of Titan.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of $\boldsymbol {\nabla }( \overline {\rho _{f}} /\overline {\alpha _{f}})$ (a,b,c,d) and $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ (e,f,g,h) for grids G1 (a,e), G2 (b,f), G3 (c,g) and G4 (d,h) at $t^{\ast } = 69$. The black contour line represents the locus $\overline {\alpha _{s}} =0.1$.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of $\boldsymbol {\nabla }( \overline {\rho _{f}} /\overline {\alpha _{f}})$ (a,b,c,d) and $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ (e,f,g,h) for grids G1 (a,e), G2 (b,f), G3 (c,g) and G4 (d,h) at $t^{\ast } = 119$. The black contour line represents the locus $\overline {\alpha _{s} }=0.1$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.The $(X,Y,0)$ plane view of $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ for grids (a) G1, (b) G2, (c) G3 and (d) G4 at $t^{\ast } = 119$.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Variation of crater-shape length scales with $t^{\ast }$. (a) $D_{c}/D_{j};$ (b) $D_{l}/D_{j};$ (c) $D_{u}/D_{j}$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Value of ${\overline {\rho _{f}}}/{\overline {\alpha _{f}}}$ for cases C1 (a–c), C2 (d–f) and C3-G3 (g–i) at $t^{\ast } = 50$ (a,d,g), 74 (b,e,h) and 124 (c,f,i).

Figure 8

Figure 7.Value of $\tilde {u}_{f,z}/a_{o}$ (a–c) and $\hat {p}_{f}$ in bar units (d–f) for cases C1 (a,d), C2 (b,e) and C3 (c,f) at $t^{\ast } = 124$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Value of $-\tilde {u}_{f,z}/a_{o}$ at $t^{\ast } = 36$ for cases C1–C5.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Value of $\langle \tilde {u}_{f,r}\rangle /a_{o}$ at $t^{\ast } = 36$ at different vertical distances from the jet exhaust plane: (a) $D_{j}$; (b) 2$D_{j}$; (c) 5$D_{j}$; (d) 10$D_{j}$; (e) 15$D_{j}$; (f) 20$D_{j}$.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Value of $-\langle \tilde {u}_{f,z}\rangle /a_{o}$ at $t^{\ast } = 36$ at different vertical distances from the jet exhaust plane: (a) $D_{j}$; (b) 2$D_{j}$; (c) 5$D_{j}$; (d) 10$D_{j}$; (e) 15$D_{j}$; (f) 20$D_{j}$.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Mass fractions $Y_{H_{2}O}$ (a–c) and $Y_{N_{2}}$ (d–f) for cases C1 (a,d), C2 (b,e) and C3 (c,f) at $t^{\ast } = 124$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of $\boldsymbol {\nabla }( \overline {\rho _{f}} /\overline {\alpha _{f}})$ (top row) and $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ (bottom row) for cases C1 (a,d), C4 (b,e) and C5 (c,f) at $t^{\ast } = 50$. The black contour line represents the locus $\overline {\alpha _{s}}=0.1$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of $\boldsymbol {\nabla }( \overline {\rho _{f}} /\overline {\alpha _{f}})$ (top row) and $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ (bottom row) for cases C1 (a,d), C4 (b,e) and C5 (c,f) at $t^{\ast } = 74$. The black contour line represents the locus $\overline {\alpha _{s}}=0.1$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of $\boldsymbol {\nabla }( \overline {\rho _{f}} /\overline {\alpha _{f}})$ (top row) and $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ (bottom row) for cases C1 (a,d), C4 (b,e) and C5 (c,f) at $t^{\ast } = 124$. The black contour line represents the locus $\overline {\alpha _{s}}=0.1$.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Plots of $(X,Y,0)$ plane views of $\overline {\alpha _{s}}$ for cases C1 (a,d,g), C4 (b,e,h) and C5 (c,f,i) at $t^{\ast } = 50$ (a–c), 74 (d–f) and 124 (g–i).

Figure 17

Figure 16.Crater length scales: (a) $D_{c}/D_{j}$; (b) $D_{u}/D_{j}$; (c) $D_{l}/D_{j}$ for cases C1–C5.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of the non-dimensional vorticity in the $r$ (a,d), $\theta$ (b,e) and $z$ (c,f) directions at $t^{\ast } = 124$ for cases: C1 (a–c) and C5 (d–f).

Figure 19

Figure 18.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of the non-dimensional baroclinic torque magnitude $B$ (a,c) and helicity $H$ (b,d) at $t^{\ast } = 124$ for cases: C1 (a,b) and C5 (c,d).

Figure 20

Figure 19.Non-dimensional, azimuthally averaged solid particle momentum flux components for cases C1 (a,c) and C3 (b,d) at $t^{\ast }=124$ versus $r/D_{j}$ at several crater fractional depths: $-z=0D_{u}, 0.25D_{u}, 0.50D_{u}, 0.75D_{u}$ and $0.95D_{u}$. Showing (a,b) $\langle \overline {\alpha _{s}} \bar {u}_{s,r}\rangle /a_{o}$; (c,d) $-\langle \overline {\alpha _{s}} \bar {u}_{s,z}\rangle /a_{o}$.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Variation of azimuthally averaged $\langle \boldsymbol {f}_{drag}\rangle$ in (kg m$^{-2}$ s$^{-2}$) in the $r$ (a,b) and $z$ (c,d) directions for cases C1 (a,c) and C3 (b,d) at $t^{\ast } = 124$. The legend denotes the $Z$ location where the values are computed.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Variation of azimuthally averaged $\langle \boldsymbol {\nabla } p_{fric}\rangle$ in (kg m$^{-2}$ s$^{-2}$) in the $r$ (a,b) and $z$ (c,d) directions for cases C1 (a,c) and C3 (b,d) at $t^{\ast } = 124$. The legend denotes the $Z$ location where the values are computed.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Cases C1 (a–c) and C3 (d–f) at $t^{\ast } = 124$. Shown are $\ln (BB_{r})$ in (a,d); $\ln (BB_{\theta })$ in (b,e); $\ln (BB_{\theta })$ in (c,f). The black contour line represents the locus $\overline {\alpha _{s}}=0.1$.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Cases C1 (a,c,e) and C3 (b,d,f) at $t^{\ast }=124$. PDF of $\ln (BB_{r})$ in (a,b); $\ln (BB_{\theta })$ in (c,d); $\ln (BB_{z})$ in (e,f).

Figure 25

Figure 24.Plots of $(X,0,Z)$ plane views of regions where the system is not hyperbolic (yellow coloured) for case C3 at $t^{\ast }=74$ (a,b,c) and $t^{\ast }=124$ (d,e,f). The analysis is performed for waves independently travelling in the $X$-direction (a,d), $Y$-direction (b,e) and $Z$-direction (c,f).