This volume adds to the expanding literature on China and Africa – growing as exponentially as the trade between the two regions did from 1998 onwards. Accompanying Alden's more popular booklet China in Africa (2007), the edited book focuses on a number of crucial aspects: led by the veteran China–Africa analyst Philip Snow and the editors, the ‘return’ of China to Africa is put in historical perspective. The OECD team of Andrea Goldstein, Nicolas Pinaud, and Helmut Reisen gives a comprehensive overview of the economic China–Africa exchange, solidly anchored in international economics. They are cautiously optimistic on the impact of Chinese trade and investment in Africa, depending on the policy framework, while Deborah Bräutigam explores the strategic opportunity of the flying-geese pattern working in Africa's favour, based on her field research in Mauritius and Nigeria.
In Oliveira's well-resourced contribution, key insights on China's oil companies in Africa are mooted. When the big three of China's oil business engage in Africa, it is complementary to the international oil majors' interests rather than a competitive threat. Beyond Western good governance rhetoric, the sphere of oil extraction always was rather one of sober realpolitik, which China has now simply joined. The apparent motive is to ‘lock in’ resources by appropriation of oil fields, thus making supply independent of the vagaries of world markets. Castigating this strategy in oil, gas, and minerals as immature, as US analysts tend to do, ignores the highly political and speculative nature of world commodity markets, from which China tries to shield itself by its Africa engagement. Clearly, the political challenge to proper management of resource revenues in Africa is on the rise with China, as is also highlighted by other contributions in the volume.
The second section contains an assortment of views from Africa (Adama Gaye), China (Wenping He), the USA (Bates Gill, Stephen Morrison, and Chin-Hao Huang) and France (Roland Marchal), all critical as to the state of knowledge and popular views held by representatives of their respective countries with regard to the China–Africa topic. The rich South African debate is added later in the book by Garth Shelton – in fact the only country in Africa (apart from Mauritius) trying to counter China's industrial policy vis-à-vis Africa with its own. Among the important players, just the EU/Brussels and the British viewpoints are missing from the tableau, if we do not take the whole volume as representative of the latter.
Selected country and/or sectoral cases are presented on Tanzania, Namibia, Angola, Sudan, Cape Verde, and, as mentioned, South Africa – often based on the authors' long-standing field research. Stories on Chinese immigration figure prominently – an emerging major topic in China–Africa research. Within the historians' perspective, Jamie Monson's account of the TAZARA railway – based on her recent book (Africa's Freedom Railway, 2009) – is furthest reaching. For anything essential lacking, I will just mention an analysis of the recent mega-deal in the DR Congo and the way in which it replicates the Angola model and similar ‘resources against infrastructure’ barter deals in Gabon, Liberia, Nigeria, or Sudan (and in future possibly in Zimbabwe). Rendering the opaque details of these mega-deals transparent increasingly shapes both public debate in the countries and scientific impact analysis. Finally, contributors to this volume cannot yet fully answer the core question of how much of China in Africa is part of what the editors acknowledge as centrally planned ‘industrial policy’ (obvious in the mega-deals) and how much is the result of independent vectors of myriads of Chinese (and African) actors.
Four pieces by Stephen Chan, Chris Alden, Christopher Clapham, and Daniel Large conclude, refuting the view of Chinese imperialism replacing the Western one in Africa, insisting on a multipolar geopolitical outcome (a bit awkwardly resumed in Alden's ‘Africa without Europeans’), and urging the need for more research, in order to present an accurate picture of the multiple actors involved and the ambiguous, yet on the whole positive, fallout of the blossoming China–Africa relations. Though resulting from of a Cambridge conference in summer 2006, it contains fairly up-to-date material (albeit often summaries of studies published elsewhere), but hardly any of those accidental contributions one likes in conference reports. The book presents an excellent overview of the China–Africa work, deepens some core aspects, and sharpens conclusions on policy and research.
