No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Morocco from Empire to Independence is part of a series of “short histories” published by Oneworld. Like the others in the series, this book is written by a respected scholar who specializes in the country and region—in this case, C. R. Pennell of the University of Melbourne. Pennell has published widely on Moroccan history in the modern period, including a recent 442-page volume on Morocco since 1830. In this book he condenses that period into a mere 74 pages and spends the remaining 114 pages of text covering the time from Morocco's first suspected inhabitants (the “pebble people” between 125,000 and 75,000 B.C.) to the early 19th century. The volume concludes with an excellent 15-page section of recommended further reading. For students and the educated general reader, this is the most valuable part of the book.
As one might suspect from the foregoing, this is not a scholarly work per se. It is a work intended for a general audience but solidly rooted in scholarship—both the author's and the scholarship of others. As George Joffé of the Royal Institute of International Affairs notes in an endorsement on the back cover, this book “has the great advantage of being accessible to the non-specialist reader.” That is its audience. However, because the format compelled the author to cram so much into the roughly 200 pages (one suspects that was a page limit imposed by the publisher), it is sometimes a bit difficult to follow.
Particularly in the early chapters the years whiz by so quickly that it is difficult to keep track of who is who and what the relationships are among the various actors in the dramas of the Almoravids, Almohads, and Merinids. What also gets lost in the process is a clear understanding of the ideological, theological, and dynastic ambitions and conflicts among the various contending groups. A chronology, a dynastic tree or two, and maps that are easier to relate to the text would have been helpful in these sections (and, indeed, throughout the book).
Because of the brevity of the work it is not surprising that, to cover all the ground and provide the reader with some understanding of the forces at work in Moroccan history, many parts of the social and economic context, while not entirely ignored, do not receive the in-depth treatment they need to focus on events. Thus, the tribal base of Moroccan society is briefly treated but not related back to events as clearly as it might have been throughout the narrative. Indeed, the book would have benefited from a chapter on the geographic, social, religious, and economic bases of Morocco early on that the reader could refer to as the story of Morocco's unique history unfolded in the succeeding pages.
Again, one wonders if this was a constraint imposed by the publisher, and there is a hint that it was in the Preface, where the author states, “So it has not been possible to write even a short history of Morocco in terms of the last two hundred years” (p. xiii). He goes on to add later in the Preface that the book “is a very broad canvas, and its aim is to explain in the most general terms the way in which Arab and Islam, Berber and European cultures are mixed, and how a dynastic system has survived in a postcolonial state. Obviously a great deal has had to be omitted, partly because of space” (p. xiv).
Nevertheless, all of the major themes in the grand sweep of Moroccan history are included. Some get lost in the rather stodgy style of the text, but all are there. The one Pennell hits the hardest is the importance of religion in Moroccan political life, particularly the importance of sharifian descent and the sultan's (later king's) dual role as a secular and a religious figure from the 16th century to the present day.
Does this book make a contribution to scholarship? No. That was not its intent. Does it make a contribution to the literature? Definitely. For all its flaws—flaws of omission primarily driven by brevity—this book is very useful in two contexts. It is an excellent introduction to Moroccan history for the educated traveler who wants to understand Morocco before going there, and it is a useful tool for students in introductory courses on the Middle East and Africa that rarely give sufficient attention to the Maghrib in general or Morocco in particular. In the latter context, the superb and detailed section on further reading is an extremely valuable tool. In it Pennell has demonstrated an ability to home in on valuable and accessible works that can be used to pursue particular interests piqued by his text while at the same time making annotative comments of great value to scholars of the Middle East who are not Moroccanists but are interested in deepening their knowledge of the kingdom.