Andrew Purves' Reconstructing Pastoral Theology: A Christological Foundation sets out to rethink the discipline from the ground up. Pastoral theology, he argues, properly describes God's care for the world in Jesus Christ. Only secondarily does it include the church's pastoral work. In order truly to be theology, God must be its subject. Only as we participate in Christ's person and work can we also speak of our ministerial vocation. The argument hinges on two classical christological doctrines – first, the dual nature of Christ's ministry both from and to the Father and second, our union with Christ as the gift of the Holy Spirit.
The early chapters describe this twofold character of Christ's ministry: not only is Christ the apostle of God, who ‘in his own person [is] the mission of God to and for the world’ (p. 22). He is also ‘the high priest, who responds . . . to God on behalf of the people’ (p. 47). This central affirmation, that Jesus Christ not only represents God to humanity but also humanity to God, is inseparable from the doctrine of our union with Christ. Through the work of the Holy Spirit, Christ is no longer outside us, but becomes the subjective meaning of our life as well. ‘Our life is hid with Christ in God’ (Col 3:3). Word and sacrament are the gracious means by which this participation takes place. The chapters (2–6) in which Purves develops this thesis are strongly argued, drawing on a range of patristic and Reformation figures.
Part two of the book shifts from Christ's ministry to ours, whereby the people of God become ‘parables of Jesus Christ to the people [they] meet’ (p. 152). Here Purves reflects on the nature and authority of preaching; the place of forgiveness in pastoral care (including a thoughtful appropriation of Thurneysen); the internally related concepts of suffering, comfort and empowerment for ministry through the presence of God; and the ground, liveliness and transformations of hope in social and political action. As engaging as this section was, it might have benefited from including more theological reflection on concrete acts of ministry. The one remarkable exception involved how others ministered to the author while he underwent medical treatment for colon cancer. Not only were his comments about this personal ordeal affecting, they also testified to the role of prayer for persevering in hope.
Critical of Seward Hiltner's controlling metaphor for pastoral ministry – shepherding – Purves rejects his functionalist approach. The metaphor suggests an unwarranted gap between clergy (shepherds) and laity (sheep), institutionalising their separation through professionalisation. More seriously, it fails to capture the significance of Christ's saving work. When Jesus is depicted only as the Good Shepherd, pastoral theology may be in danger of losing the full scope of his saving work. Pastoral theology needs to develop a more ‘vigorous Christology, soteriology and eschatology’ (p. xxviii). Moreover, when Hiltner adopts the assumptions of psychotherapeutic practices and norms, he loses what is distinctively Christian about pastoral work in the church. The overall effect is reductionistic; creation and redemption are not adequately distinguished; contextual awareness is largely lacking; and the anthropology depends almost exclusively on categories of developmental psychology.
A native of Edinburgh and a student of both James and T. F. Torrance, Andrew Purves was originally trained as a dogmatic theologian. He is more concerned with the question whether pastoral care is theological than whether it is practical. He asks about its theological basis, centre and telos, not about its pragmatic aspect. He does not ask the typical pastor's question: ‘What should I do in this situation and how should I do it?’ – but rather, ‘How should I think about what God is doing here?’
Pastoral theology, as Purves defines it, ‘is principally concerned with the practice of God’ and secondarily as reflection on ‘the participative practice of the church within that theological perspective through our union with Christ’ (p. xxii). By contrast, the theology of pastoral care ‘is principally concerned with theological reflection on actual churchly practice’ (p. xxii). After splitting pastoral theology into two subdisciplines, Purves risks collapsing pastoral into systematic theology. He asserts that systematic and pastoral theology have the same essential content and are distinguishable only ‘for the sake of convenience and task’ (p. xxiii), yet it is difficult to see how they are finally distinguishable at all.
Pastoral theology arguably includes the kind of normative (dogmatic) reflection that Purves develops with such clarity and care. But it also includes everything that Purves relegates to a theology of pastoral care (including interdisciplinary reflection). The essential content of pastoral theological reflection differs from systematic theology when it includes reflection on concrete situations, case studies or churchly practices.
Purves is right that ministry disconnected from doctrine can become exclusively skill-driven – a recipe for burnout and a form of ‘ministerial Pelagianism’ (p. 159). But there is an opposite danger as well, for doctrine disconnected from ministry is in danger of ‘ministerial Docetism’, or a disconnection of theology from concrete practices. As Purves knows, but does not always make clear, how to avoid both these pitfalls is the challenge of pastoral theology. A number of years ago, Rodney Hunter addressed the Society for Pastoral Theology with these words: ‘In the long run, the work of constructive theology, it seems to me, is the most important place we can contribute intellectually, as an academic profession. And it is the ground on which, in my opinion, the future of our field as a theological discipline will finally be determined’ (Rodney Hunter, ‘Five Questions and Polemical Suggestions for the Future of Pastoral Theology’, Journal of Pastoral Theology 5 (1995), p. 10). If this is indeed the case, Andrew Purves has made a substantive contribution to the field. This book deserves to be widely read and discussed.
