This book furnishes a thorough economic and social history of the Straits of Melaka during the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. The waterway was at that time, as it had been for hundreds of years, a vital section of the trade route between China and India. The integration of the resource-rich Malay archipelago into this network enhanced the Straits' strategic importance. Melaka and Penang slotted into the prevailing commercial pattern; both settlements served a similar economic function, albeit in competition with each other, as distributing centres exporting archipelagic agricultural and forest products in exchange for manufactured goods and luxury items brought in from the two giant Asian nations. The long-distance trade tended to be controlled by outsiders, mainly by Europeans, whereas the short-distance traffic was largely handled by indigenous people.
The key commodity was Chinese tea. In order to reduce the flow of bullion from Europe to pay for the beverage, intermediate goods such as South-East Asian tin, opium, and pepper were used in exchange instead. The need for a port to break the journey to Canton became paramount to the East India Company; hence the acquisition in 1786 of Penang Island, which also acted as a refitting station and shelter from the strong monsoon winds. By 1830 the India-Straits-China trade had come to be completely dominated by the British at the expense of their Dutch and Danish competitors.
Nordin Hussin, based at Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, has conducted extensive research in the archives at Bangi, Kuala Lumpur, London, and The Hague. The work must have been arduous at times, given the lack of comparability in the data for Melaka and Penang (pp 18, 19–20, 115–16). His book has three main themes: (1) the development of trade over time and shifts in the trading patterns of the two ports; (2) their urban administration and morphology; and (3) the character of their society. The upshot is a profound and wide-ranging portrait of these outposts during an epoch of armed metropolitan conflict (the Anglo-Dutch hostilities of 1780–4 followed by the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars of 1792–1815) which was, in turn, a time of transition in the Nanyang between the ‘age of commerce’ and the subsequent era of ‘high imperialism’. The author provides information about the number, type, size and even age of ships arriving and departing, and about ship-owners and ports of origin. Asian agency is given full rein.
Significant contrasts existed between Melaka and Penang. Once the headquarters of a Malay kingdom, Melaka had a long and proud history dating back even as far as the fourteenth century (p. 335); Penang lacked such historical longevity. Melaka was under Dutch control from 1641 until 1825 (with a gap) and was ruled by the British during the said interlude between 1795 and 1818 and again from 1825 until 1957. Penang was opened more or less from scratch by Francis Light in 1786 (there were only 158 Malays living on the island at the time, p. 184) and remained under British administration until Malaya achieved independence half a century ago. Melaka operated under a monopoly system during the period under study; Penang was a free port. Melaka had a better strategic location, Penang being somewhat isolated at the northern extremity of the Straits (pp 99–100, 105, 111, 121).
The Dutch often emerge better than the British from Nordin Hussin's analysis. Their historical source materials are superior (pp. 18, 19–20, 71, 75, 78, 113, 162–3, 165–6, 168, 171, 241, 315, 339); their quality of life in Melaka was more cultured and refined than that in Penang, ‘a port-town of migrants’, which had a less stable environment and more social tensions; their urban administration was more competent (the British had no equivalent of the Dutch Weeskamer or Orphans' Chamber (pp. 206–210), whose functions were far wider than the name might suggest); Penang was plagued by corruption and inefficiency (pp. 243, 246, 310, 312); Melaka had none of the health problems of its rival and dealt with the fire hazard much more proficiently. The Dutch administrative system was retained after the British took over Melaka in 1825; and the British implemented in Penang some aspects of the Dutch set-up, such as appointing captains from the various ethnic groups and letting revenue farms (pp. 227–228). They also struggled to persuade people to abandon Melaka in favour of Penang. It was the British who resorted to wanton destruction, the razing of Melaka Fort (p. 139), not the Dutch. Despite all this, Penang was the rising power, Melaka, for long the pre-eminent emporium in Nusantara, the declining one. But both would be outclassed after 1819 by Singapore.
The author proceeds to use his empirical findings to engage with the long-running debate (1969-) about the ‘colonial port-town’ concept (especially pp. xvii-xx, 123–9, and 334–42), which has already attracted contributions from scholars such as R.J. Horvath, A.H. Kidwai, A.D. King, and L. Nagtegaal. There is a ‘knowledge gap’ between theory and historical evidence on this issue; hence the need for sound case studies (pp. xix–xx), as provided by the book under review.
The background to the colonial port-town concept is as follows. In 1960 one author advanced the idea that pre-industrial cities everywhere displayed similar social and ecological structures. Nine years later another writer observed that this theory did not match the pattern of industrialisation in developing countries, and came up instead with the colonial port-town concept. It was then objected that there was no fundamental difference between a colonial port-town and any indigenous port-city in Asia. Another view was that, whilst the paradigm should not be jettisoned altogether, some of its dominant features had been over-stated. This, in turn, produced a reaction in which it was claimed that many characteristics of the colonial port-city were not found in an indigenous setting.
Taking as an example the foundation of Pontianak by an Arab adventurer in 1772, it has also been proposed that the idea of an ‘externally-induced settlement’ might capture the phenomenon: this category would be less narrow than ‘colonial port-towns’ because not all ‘externally-induced’ towns were colonial. Nordin Hussin argues that this contrast is itself problematic because when traders and locals get together to form a settlement it is difficult to prove whether the site was externally induced or locally nurtured (pp. 335–336).
To return to the main issue, Dr Nordin Hussin agrees that at a superficial level Melaka and Penang might be regarded as ‘colonial port-towns’. Many of the defining features of the category were present, such as European-imposed urban precepts, the fort or castle as the central focus of the town, separate European and indigenous spheres, a large migrant population, the relative absence of females, a slave population, and an urban centre that was poorly integrated with the hinterland (p. 334). He concludes, nonetheless, that “it is hard to accept the validity of a separate colonial urban typology” (p. 336).
Why? He submits, first, that an emphasis on location and function might be “more relevant and meaningful than the nature of the political control or the power structure”. He notes, secondly, that “contrasts in the form, structure, content and direction of the development of Melaka and Penang indicate that port-towns did not necessarily share identical or similar characteristics and that other circumstances and historical developments were equally important in defining their respective identities”. His third point is that some features said to define the colonial port-town category in fact pre-dated the colonial period. Furthermore, most indigenous port-towns also had a large migrant element and ethnic segregation was practised in pre-colonial Melaka. He says, fourthly, that viewing “the Dutch in Melaka as the imposing colonial power denies the level of adaptation to local norms that was seen on the part of the foreign ruling group”. Both Melaka and Penang, he adds, “grew more of an Asian character rather than being dominated by any European characteristics” (pp. 336–338).
Trade and Society in the Straits of Melaka, a reworking for publication of a doctoral thesis submitted to the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam in 2002, is an impressive piece of research and a formidable work of reference. Nordin Hussin uses his empirical findings to contribute to the debate about the ‘colonial port-town’ concept.
