While the past two decades or so have witnessed an efflorescence of art-historical scholarship highlighting the interconnections between the Islamic and Christian Mediterranean, much of it has focused on the medieval and early modern periods, leaving later years—and especially the nineteenth century—still largely within the more rigid East–West framework associated with the age of colonialism. This disparity is the starting point for Paolo Girardelli and Ezio Godoli in their excellent introduction to the volume under review, which, as its subtitle suggests, aims to offer a more fluid picture of the modern period. As the two editors explain, the phenomenon of Italian architectural activity in the late Ottoman and Turkish contexts lends itself particularly well to such a project, being neither “framed in the usual mechanism of colonial power” nor “understandable as a form of cultural imperialism” (viii). The long history of Italian-Ottoman interaction—encapsulated by the centuries-old presence of Italo-Levantine communities within the Ottoman Empire itself—further contributes to the topic's relevance and potential. Although certain figures in this history, perhaps most prominently the Art Nouveau architect Raimondo D'Aronco (d. 1932), are already well known, precious little has been published on the subject in English. The present volume, which brings together seventeen essays by a diverse group of international scholars, thus constitutes a significant addition to the anglophone literature, all the more so because it concentrates on lesser-known case studies and newly revealed archival materials.
Derived from papers presented at a 2013 conference, the essays are clustered into four thematic sections that each follow a roughly chronological internal order. This hybrid arrangement provides the book with a conceptual armature while also elucidating important diachronic developments. Part one, “Landmarks, Spaces and Politics,” begins with essays by Girardelli and Rudolf Agstner on Istanbul's ambassadorial buildings, through which, starting in the later eighteenth century, Italian and other European designers first introduced an explicitly Western architectural language into the Ottoman capital. As Göksün Akyürek discusses, one of these architects, the Swiss-Italian Gaspare Fossati (d. 1883), went on to serve the Ottoman state in a number of projects that visualized the modernizing agenda of the reformist Tanzimat era (1839–76), including the famous restoration he undertook of the Hagia Sophia with his brother Giuseppe (d. 1891). Looking beyond individual monuments, Emiliano Bugatti discusses the role of the Italian engineer Luigi Storari (d. 1894) in establishing a new and distinctly Levantine mode of urban planning that adapted Western models to the needs of mid-nineteenth-century Istanbul and Izmir. Raluca Tomi moves further outside the capital in her essay on the Romanian principalities, alerting us to how widespread the Italian presence was in the Ottoman world broadly construed.
Entitled “Individual Experiences in Context,” the book's second section sheds light on a number of obscure actors and provides new perspectives on already familiar ones. Fabio Mangone traces the Ottoman sojourn of the Apulian architect Nicola Carelli (d. 1884), who during the 1830s was engaged as a teacher by members of Istanbul's ascendant community of Armenian master builders. Dealing with better-known figures, the essays by Giuliana Ricci and Giovanna D'Amia explore the complex ties of the Fossati brothers and the Istanbul-born architect Giulio Mongeri (d. 1953) to the cultural institutions of Milan. Cenk Berkant and Vassilis Colonas return us to Ottoman territories, presenting new findings on Italian architects in Izmir and Thessaloniki respectively.
Part three, “Institutions and Investments,” shifts the volume's focus to organizational and financial factors, particularly after restrictions on foreign property ownership were relaxed in 1867. Seda Kula Say looks at the work carried out by the architect Alexandre Vallauri (d. 1921)—a Levantine of mixed heritage—for Istanbul's Italo-Levantine philanthropic society, the Società Operaia, while Zeynep Cebeci offers enlightening new data on the property investments of two prominent Italo-Levantine families, again in Istanbul. In a jointly authored essay, Franceso Krecic and Diego Caltana discuss the construction in 1909 of an Istanbul office building for the Trieste insurance company Assicurazioni Generali. Vilma Fasoli completes this section with an intriguing (though temporally confusing) piece on an Italian-backed Ottoman construction company founded in 1911 and spearheaded by Mongeri.
The volume's final part, “Late Empire to Republic,” addresses the transition from the culturally and ethnically diverse milieu of the late Ottoman period to the more homogenous—albeit still internationally connected—setting of the Republic of Turkey, established in 1923. With a vibrant career spanning this shift, the largely forgotten architect Edoardo De Nari (d. 1954) is the subject of a fascinating essay by Büke Uras, who chanced upon his personal archive in an antique store. Milva Giacomelli takes us definitively into the republican period with her discussion of the varied (and ultimately unsuccessful) Italian projects submitted to the competition for Mustafa Kemal Atatürk's (d. 1938) mausoleum in the Turkish capital, Ankara. Concluding the volume, Paola Ricco considers the numerous Turkish sports facilities—most of them unrealized—designed by the Swiss-Italian architect Paolo Vietti Violi (d. 1965) during the 1930s, a topic that aptly sums up the modern and competitive image that the young Kemalist state wished to project.
As this rapid summary indicates, the volume succeeds in exploring its theme from multiple productive angles without losing focus, and the freshness of its content—some of it recent doctoral work—adds to its interest. A number of the essays, however, too readily betray their conference origins, reading as overly brief proceedings that, while rich in informational value, lack the background and contextualization required for less specialized audiences. This means that the broader implications of the individual case studies are not as clear as they might be, despite the admirable attentiveness of each paper to the sources it examines. The more successful contributions—among them the essays by Akyürek, Girardelli, Krecic and Caltana, and Uras—temper the volume's characteristic granularity with a more conceptually engaged approach that demonstrates the material's larger significance.
A less excusable shortcoming—and one that must be blamed on the publisher—is the rather sloppy manner in which the book has been copyedited and designed. Besides multiple errors and inconsistencies in spelling and typesetting, the illustrations, which are well chosen and plentiful, are sometimes so small as to lose their usefulness. These issues do not, however, take away from the overall importance of the volume, whose far-reaching subject matter and wealth of documentary evidence will make it a noteworthy source for those interested in how the longstanding ties linking the artistic cultures of the Mediterranean endured and developed in the modern period.
