The great movement of revival and reform which swept through the Islamic world from the eighteenth century is its most important development since the early Islamic era. The impact has been felt down to the present: in the decline of forms of ‘magic’ in Sufi practice; in the emergence of scriptural religion; in a new emphasis on action on earth to achieve salvation; in the emergence of self-interpretation in piety; in a new emphasis on jihad; and even the fashioning of new states. Moin Nizami is concerned to examine just one aspect of this great story; the transformation of the Chishti-Sabri Sufi order in northern India in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries from a religiously inclusive order, flourishing in the pluralistic environment of eighteenth-century Awadh, to a dynamic Sufi order in the Doab region close to Delhi, which had accommodated most of the main strands of reforming belief and practice.
Nizami begins by introducing us to the Chishti-Sabri world from the fifteenth to the seventeenth century and the important roles played by Ahmad Abdul Haq of Rudauli, Abdul Quddus Gangohi and Shah Muhibbullah Ilahabadi. Rightly he emphasises the importance of Ibn Arabi's wujudi doctrines for these men and their pluralistic traditions which might enable them to embrace “Vaishnavite theories, Bhakti ideas and Vedantic philosophy along with yogic exercises”. He then focuses his attention on Delhi in the eighteenth century which saw a resurgence of Sufi activity particularly among the Chishti-Nizamis and the Naqshbandi-Mujaddidis. He notes several significant developments taking place under the general aegis of Shah Waliullah and his family: there was the mixing of Sufi and ʽalim tradition represented by the growth of joint khanqah-madrasahs; there was a new emphasis on the study of Hadith; Sufis began to affiliate to several orders; shariʽat became more central to Sufi practice, called by some ‘neo-Sufism’; there was a consequent adjustment of Sufi practices such as sama listening to music in assembly, so it became a more sober occasion; and the imposition of tauhid, the oneness of God, on understandings of wahdat al-wujud. In this context the Sufi shaikh became less a person who might mediate between man and God by means of his karamat - his miracles, and more a teacher who might show his disciples how to come closer to God.
In the second half of the eighteenth century the focus of the Chrishtri-Sabri order moved from Awadh to the small towns, or qasbahs, in the Doab east of Delhi. In this context these Sufis began to interact with the Sufis of Delhi, in particular the Naqshbandis, and to absorb some of their new thinking. Nizami shows how they began to emphasise strict adherence to the shariʽat. He pays particular attention to Amroha which he describes as “in many ways the ideal qasbah in the region”. Nizami then demonstrates how during the first half of the nineteenth century this trajectory came to be reinforced by the impact of Saiyid Ahmad of Rai Bareli's Tariqa-i Muhammadia which carried an activist reformism through much of northern India. So far did this process go that by the mid-nineteenth century “the Chishti-Sabri leadership had, in sum, merged with the ‘ulama’”, by the same token the role of the shaikh as teacher had eclipsed all others. In his final chapter Nizami focuses on Haji Imdadullah, Chishti-Sabri and most influential shaikh of mid-nineteenth century India. All the developments he has been discussing were fully-realised in the Haji. In the context of what is now a fully-dominant British Raj he taught his followers how to transform themselves from within in the light of the shariʽat while working in the world to create an Islamic society.
This is a first-class piece of research which is deeply rooted in primary sources. With this new evidence it analyses a central process of religious change. In doing so it shows that the Dar ul-Ulum Deoband, which has been at the heart of Islamic reform in South Asia and in the wider Islamic world, had its roots not just in the circle of the Waliullahi ulama but in changes that had been taking place in the Chishti-Sabri Sufi order over the previous 150 years.
I do have some reservations. Nizami's great scholarship is not always entirely secure. For instance, Saiyid Shah Abdul Razzaq of Bansa was not a forefather of Farangi Mahall (p. 61) but a Qadri Sufi whose rise in Awadh coincided with the establishment of the Farangi Mahall family in Lucknow and who the Farangi Mahallis treated with much respect. It is not right to suggest that modern scholarship “ignores or minimises” the contribution of Sufi shaikhs. Barbara Metcalf's important work on Deoband shows how the Sufi engagements of its ulama were central to their lives and teaching. . .My own work on Farangi Mahall has demonstrated that for most of its ulama shariʽat and tariqat were inextricably entwined. Nizami is justly proud of the developments he has revealed amongst the Chishti-Sabris but a fairer representation of the scholarship that has gone before would be more just. This said, he has written a most important book which will be a benchmark in the field for years to come.
