Perhaps no aspect of the progressive movement has proven more consequential than its program for the transformation of education. Lawrence Cremin observed that by the mid-twentieth century, progressive educational precepts had become “the conventional wisdom of American education.”Footnote 1 Nowadays it is hard to find an elementary classroom that does not exhibit at least some of the techniques outlined in Dewey's The School and Society (1899), his first of many manifestos for educational transformation.Footnote 2
But why has higher education seemingly been unaffected by the progressive pedagogical revolution? Why do most professors—historians especially—adhere to the predominant pedagogical modes of the late nineteenth century—lectures and seminar discussions?Footnote 3
The answer is twofold. First, Dewey's conception of educational play for children was never all that successful: the counterrevolution against progressive techniques is partly predicated on the fact that the results have been disappointing.Footnote 4 Second, Dewey insisted that education progressed according to a rigid developmental sequence. Dewey himself, and most of his critics, have focused on the education of young children; but Dewey's developmental trajectory had profound implications for the education of teenagers and college students. And these ideas have done much to impoverish higher education.
DEWEY'S GREAT IDEA: EDUCATION FOR A PROGRESSIVE SOCIETY
Dewey's “New Education” grew out of philosophical first principles. He insisted that the mind does not passively receive experiences; rather, it actively manipulates and interprets sensory inputs. Teachers who attempt to pour knowledge into students fail because the mind is relentlessly active—and ceaselessly attuned to immediate problems. Rather than attempt to discipline this restless mental predisposition, teachers should exploit it.
A corollary was that the child is naturally inclined to play. The best pedagogy, for children especially, was founded on play. Thus, children in Dewey's schools not only engaged in what we now call “active learning,” but they did so in the guise of play. They learned about habitations by building teepees with sticks and paper and they learned about agriculture, industrial processes, and chemistry by growing wheat, grinding it into flour, and baking bread from scratch. Of course, educational theorists had been advancing such techniques for centuries. A half century before Dewey, Friedrich Froebel had attracted a large following by advocating a pedagogy of play.Footnote 5
Dewey's revolution enlisted familiar pedagogical techniques in a larger cause: the construction of a progressive society. Dewey took inspiration from Plato, whose utopian scheme in The Republic began with educational transformation. (Dewey went so far as to endorse a “Back to Plato” movement amongst educators.) But Dewey especially looked to Rousseau, whose Emile (1762) promised to transform society by transforming education. Indeed, Dewey began nearly every chapter of The Schools of To-Morrow (1915) with references to Rousseau. Dewey's goal was explicit: a revolution in American education would produce young adults who would build a society that was “worthy, lovely, and harmonious.”Footnote 6
Such language resonated with Dewey's emphasis on the cooperative ethos of the progressive movement. And here he parted company with Rousseau, who contended that society corrupted the young. Parents, teachers, priests, and books left so deep an imprint that the young could never find their own true selves. Rousseau's solution was to isolate Emile, his student-exemplar, from other people and ideas. The sole exception was the boy's tutor, tasked with preserving the boy's isolation while stimulating his curiosity to enable Emile to discover things by himself.
Dewey would have none of this. He understood that Rousseau's Emile would grow up to be a social misfit—an “exemplary prig”—wholly at odds with the society in which he was to live.Footnote 7 By contrast, Dewey's pedagogical apparatus was not only social in character—Dewey's school was itself to be the focal point of the local community—but its pedagogical techniques were cooperative and group-focused.
This social education would serve as an antidote to the individualism and competiveness of modern industrial and capitalist society. The school, “an embryonic community,” would promote “a growing interchange of thought and growing unity of sympathetic feeling.”Footnote 8 This community, writ large, would become a nation imbued with progressive values.
But Dewey's opposition to the capitalist ethos prompted him to bar real competition from the play of students. Dutch historian Johan Huizinga long ago chronicled the centrality of competition to play in most civilizations.Footnote 9 Dewey thus embraced a pedagogy of play while excising one of the most compelling elements.
Dewey's notion of play suffered from another flaw, especially as it related to young adults. Because Dewey's goals were explicitly instrumental, he insisted that education be connected “to the business of living.”Footnote 10 He repeatedly called on educators to “fit” young people into the real world they would inhabit as adults. Biographer Alan Ryan observed that for Dewey, children were “always being propelled toward adult competence.”Footnote 11
But by focusing on the young adult's passage to a modern world dominated by scientific rationalism, Dewey eschewed activities rooted in fantasy. “In order, then, that playfulness may not terminate in arbitrary fancifulness and in building up an imaginary world alongside the world of actual things,” Dewey wrote,” it is necessary that the play attitude should gradually pass into a work attitude.”Footnote 12 By the time they got to college, young people should be ready to work in the real world. College students, especially, should engage in what Ryan has termed “protowork,” a “rehearsal for serious engagement with the world.”Footnote 13
Ryan observed that Dewey's notion of play as “protowork” seems “not to be right.”Footnote 14 Not only did Dewey's play lack the excitement of real competition but it missed the enchantment of whimsy and fantasy. Such nonsense, Dewey insisted, was incompatible with college-aged students, who were eager to get down to business of becoming productive adult members of society.
Dewey's assumption that teenagers and young adults outgrow such enthusiasms was dead wrong, as has been proven by the broad popularity of online gaming. Protected by the anonymity of the Internet, college students (and mature adults!) spend countless hours pretending to be car thieves, warriors, and even members of the opposite sex. Most people enjoy imagining what it is like to be someone else.
In short, Dewey devised a system of education built on play modes that emphasized social cooperation, discouraged competition, and facilitated the transition from childish fantasy to the real world of adult work. His scheme made sense, and that was part of the problem. A central element of “fun” is its subversion of conventional beliefs and understandings. Dewey's play, lacking competition, fantasy elements, and the thrill of subversion, just was not much fun.
But how can such elements of play be brought into higher education?
THE REVOLUTION COMES TO INDIANOLA, IOWA
As she left her dorm at Simpson College, Ellie was carrying dozens of posters. She had spent several evenings at the library researching Margaret Sanger's writings. She especially scrutinized Sanger's detailed drawings of women's sexual organs that showed how contraceptive devices prevented pregnancy and disease. Ellie had copied several of Sanger's drawings onto posters. Now she resolved to attach these posters to buildings, light poles, and other structures throughout the campus.
Ellie had been assigned the role of Margaret Sanger in a Reacting to the Past game set in Greenwich Village in early 1913.Footnote 15 Ellie's grade was based on papers and oral presentations whose purpose was to advance Sanger's beliefs. Publicly distributing the posters would improve her ability to influence the outcome of the game.
Ellie soon discovered that it took longer to affix the posters than she had imagined. As she was taping a poster to a stately Victorian building, a boy approached and stared at the poster. When he looked at her, Ellie hurried out the building, worried that he would confront her for distributing such “gross posters.” Instantly she was troubled by her impulse to flee. Why had she been so fearful? Sanger had stood up to real danger every day. Probably she would have shoved the poster into the boy's hands and told him to “educate himself before he ruined some poor woman's life.”
Then “a strange thing happened.” Ellie's nervousness evaporated: “I felt connected to Sanger in some small way.” It was one thing to read about Sanger, Ellie realized, but another “to feel like you're standing on the front lines at the dawn of the movement and are an integral part of the changes that are going to happen.” She put up the rest of the posters with a new resolve. In class, she spoke with new confidence and force.Footnote 16
Kristina, another student in the class, was assigned the role of Elizabeth “Gurley” Flynn, leader of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), a major faction in the game. In the spring of 1913 the Wobblies’ goal was to publicize their strike in Paterson, New Jersey. New York newspapers, in deference to the factory owners, had refused to report on the strike. “Big Bill” Haywood, Flynn, and other Wobblies conceived of a pageant at Madison Square Garden to dramatize the strike. They hoped to enlist the literary figures, artists, and actors of Greenwich Village to help write, publicize, and produce the pageant.
But in articulating the views of Gurley Flynn, Kristina would be arguing against classmates who were playing roles as leaders of the woman suffrage movement, which early in 1913 was organizing a Woman Suffrage Parade to protest the inauguration of Woodrow Wilson. The suffragists wanted the Villagers to use their talents to support the Woman Suffrage Parade in Washington. Kristina, a passionate advocate of women's rights, was obliged to argue that gaining women the vote was less important than winning the Paterson strike. This gave her pause.
Kristina was also nervous about making speeches: “I've always been terrified of getting up in front of people,” she recalled. However, she made it through her first speech—which she gave with a fake Irish accent. She thought it had gone well but had been surprised by the enthusiastic response of her peers. “I started to think I could be successful in the game in general,” she thought. In subsequent speeches and papers, she hammered away at the woman suffrage faction. “Adjusting the broken system of capitalism will not bring about permanent change,” she wrote. Capitalism had to be overturned completely.Footnote 17 The advocates of woman suffrage landed some punches of their own. They denounced the Wobblies as terrorists; peaceful change through the ballot box was preferable to bloody revolution. With each class session, the competition became more heated.
As the game neared its sixth and final session, the issues in dispute had become clear: would the leaders of Greenwich Village—Max Eastman, John Sloan, Mabel Dodge, Emma Goldman, Crystal Eastman, Randolph Bourne, and others—support the Wobblies’ pageant at Madison Square Garden or the Woman Suffrage parade against Wilson? Or would the Villagers refuse to endorse either political movement and instead tend their own bohemian gardens?
When their instructor, Nick Proctor, arrived at the classroom that last day, he sensed a strange undercurrent, but assumed it related to growing tension. He took his usual seat at the back of the room and explained procedures for the final vote. The students exchanged looks. Then they stood and walked out of the room, all twenty-one of them. As she was leaving, Kristina dropped a note in Proctor's lap: “We reject this false dichotomy. We will not cast votes that harm causes that we support. Meet us in the lobby.”Footnote 18
Baffled but curious, Proctor gathered his papers and headed for the lobby. The students were clumped in the two-story atrium. Some looked at him searchingly, terrified at having defied their instructor. (Proctor was also chair of the history department.) Several, having hidden guitars in the atrium, began strumming a few chords. One voice rang out and others joined in: “Bread and Roses,” a protest anthem of the early twentieth century. Then it dawned on Proctor. Somehow, during secret meetings, the entire class had decided to stand together, whatever the consequences, against what they perceived to be injustice. Proctor was nearly moved to tears.
While he had always regarded his students as clever and hardworking, Proctor had often despaired over their apolitical attitudes and deference to authority. Before Reacting, he doubted that his students would understand the various social movements of the early twentieth century. “Reacting changed that,” he said. “It turned them into a bunch of revolutionaries. It gave them a taste of what it is to be at the forefront of radical social change.”
“REACTING TO THE PAST” AND THE FUTURE
But did Proctor's students learn history? The gamebook, Greenwich Village, 1913: Suffrage, Labor, and the New Woman, consists of 100,000 words of historical context, rules, and advisories. The game also includes individual roles and teacher instructors (another 100,000 words of material). This intellectual superstructure provided students with considerable guidance about the historical context and the main ideas of the various figures. Like Ellie, many students strengthened their arguments by researching their own historical figure—and those of their adversaries. In short, the Reacting game immersed students in many of the primary and secondary sources common to regular history courses.
Yet it can be fairly argued that Proctor's students did not evoke the actual past but instead created a vividly inaccurate rendering of historical people and events. Most students would forever associate Margaret Sanger with Ellie, and Gurley Flynn with Kristina. The woman suffrage movement, the Wobblies, and the bohemian pursuit of “the New” would always be entangled in students’ minds with the oddball actions of their classmates at Simpson College. And no fusion of radical labor, woman suffrage, and the bohemians ever occurred in real history.
But the game succeeded in persuading students that the past matters. Unlike so many of their peers, who deny the relevance of the past to their own lives, Proctor's students learned that the past could speak to them—and in a powerful way. They learned that history could be a vital force in their lives. During the final two weeks of the game, for example, Ellie “devoured” Sanger's writings. And in the process of learning “everything I could about her,” Ellie also “reinforced” her research, speaking, and social skills. She also decided to become a teacher and is now enrolled in a master's program in education. Kristina, too, was changed by her experiences—especially the walkout. “I don't really think there are words to truly describe how it felt to challenge a professor,” she recalled. “I do know that after that experience I was never afraid to question what I was learning”—though she insisted that she did so politely. She added that she “started to see myself as a leader.” During the next two years she organized Women's History Month events and received awards for on-campus activism.
* * *
The traditional pedagogical tools of the historian have endured in part because they are effective at teaching historiography along with skills of critical analysis. But such teaching tools are insufficient. The first step in learning a subject is caring about it. Reacting to the Past games show students that history can be more compelling than fraternity antics, beer pong, video games, social media, or any of the other activities that sap their time and energy. History can become the center of their lives. This, too, would have baffled Dewey, who dismissed the past as little more than a set of benchmarks to chart the advance of civilization.Footnote 19 But with his gaze resolutely fixed on a rationalist future, Dewey and many other progressives failed to discern the importance of play—exciting, imaginative, silly, and edgy.
Dewey would likely have been appalled by the Reacting to the Past pedagogy. He surely would have disapproved of the intense competition, and of young adults “building up an imaginary world” and pretending to be historical figures within it. Moreover, because the game was run by students themselves, it lacked the coherence and order he regarded as concomitants of effective pedagogy.
But Dewey would likely have been heartened—and doubtless surprised—by the outcome. Competition did not engender selfish individualism but instead drew the students together as never before. Their immersion in “make-believe” roles did not trap them in a fantasy land but showed that individuals could march boldly into the real world. And their challenge to Proctor—and to the customary hierarchies of knowledge he represented—gave them the nerve to take on the world they will shape as adults.
