In Making a New World, John Tutino argues that the silver mines of central Mexico were the birthplace of capitalism. As stated in the introductory chapters, Tutino's goal is to place the origin of capitalism in Mexico. This is a book about the Mexican elite society over the course of the colonial period; it lays out the social connection among the powerful families and their relationships with the colonial economic and political structure from the dawn of their existence in 1500 to the eve of their separation from Spain.
Tutino's reliance on Braudel to frame the history of Mexican mining in a global, transatlantic and sociological context is the book's most salient contribution. It is also its greatest weakness. It is not an economic history of Mexican mining or about the origin of capitalism. It is, however, a deeply researched and enjoyable social history of the Mexican mining region from the early sixteenth century until independence.
Braudel was notoriously vague about what capitalism was, while being very clear about the nefariousness of capitalists, their penchant for monopoly and their predatory nature. Tutino also invokes these predators: “Predatory entrepreneurs ruled mining” (p. 454) and “A predator who destroyed competitors mines and workers lives” (p. 173). But then, Tutino also addresses the “protean” nature of capitalism, which allows capitalism to shift, change, and be part of a complex transformation of the Mexican Bajío. From this perspective, “British hegemony came late to capitalism” (p. 17) and capitalism was born in Mexico because the discovery of the New World integrated the global economy around the extraction and transport of silver, which was produced mostly in the Mexican Bajío.
Tutino sees in components of a capitalist system evidence of the system itself. This is not a new argument—Peter Bakewell claimed in 1995 that the entrepreneurial activity of Francisco Lopez de Quiroga, a seventeenth-century mining magnate in San Luis Potosí, proved colonial Mexico was capitalist. Edith Couturier's 2003 study of the Conde de Regla continued in this perspective. Tutino adds enormous depth with his analysis—the multiple portraits of elite families and individual members of these families are recounted through notarial records, wills, court cases, and letters, allowing the development of a deep social history. While Tutino's book is longer and the appendices more detailed, the problem remains: A few entrepreneurs do not capitalism make. Rent-seeking, commercial alliances, and abusive labor arrangements are evidence of markets but they are not evidence of the birth of capitalism.
Furthermore, the colonial silver mining industry operated under serious and unresolved resource constraints. Mercury shortages constantly threatened production and ore yields were fairly stagnant until the eighteenth century. The scale and scope of growth and falling transaction costs that are the hallmark of economic development never happened in the silver industry. The industry may have been crucial to the colonial economy, but Mexico's colonial mining industry was no capitalism incubator.
Any reader will enjoy revisiting Alexander von Humboldt's reports of his travels through Mexican colonial towns, which Tutino uses to great descriptive effect. The first part of the book, which covers the region from conquest to 1770, delves into the indigenous responses to colonization, the early alliance between church and land and capital, and rare in Mexican history books, the use of African slaves in the mines. Part one reaches all the way to Texas to cover a part of Mexico that is no longer Mexican. All this contributes to the “big history” aspect of the book, and works well with part two and the later chapters reconstituting the life of leading members of the colonial society. The reader will appreciate being immersed in the retelling of one patriarch's history (all of chapter 5) in an account that spans decades, one short marriage prematurely ended by a tragic death, possible flirtations with widows in neighboring towns, and ultimately taking the vows of priesthood, all while managing untold wealth in estates throughout regions near and far. In this second part of the book, the increasing tensions among developing cities as the Bourbon reforms tear at the fabric of colonial unity makes for riveting reading, and for those wanting more —Tutino says as much in the epilogue—there is a second tome in the making.
In reading this book, I was reminded that some books, like some trips, are more about the journey than the destination. Truth be told, if we ignore the title, the first chapter, and the theoretical aspirations of the book, and forgive Tutino's definitions of economic actors and processes that few readers of this Journal will accept, we enjoy the journey through colonial Mexico.
Tutino has written a dense social history of the hardships of labor in early colonial mining; of the life, mores, and wealth of the small number of elites who owned most of the land; and of the regional, cultural, and financial affairs they were involved in. It is a compelling history of the men that built Mexico. Come to think of it, that would have been a great title.
