This important new contribution to the literature on religions and ecology presents three case studies of communities in India that have environmental sensibilities rooted in traditional or indigenous sources: the Swadhyaya movement, the Bishnois, and the Bhils.
The book devotes a chapter to each community, and these are framed by chapters at both beginning and end devoted to theorizing about religion and ecology in India. The first study is of the Swadhyaya movement founded by Pandurang Shastri Athavale and active in India's western states where its activities include the establishing of tree temples. The second concerns the Bishnoi people of Rajasthan, famous since the early eighteenth century for their commitment to animal and forest protection. The third study, although not as developed as the other two, is on the tribal Bhils and their sacred groves. The argument is that environmental protection advocated by these groups is not derivative. Jain distinguishes this rural, vernacular Hinduism from urban, English-medium Hindu organizations such as ISKCON, the Ramakrishna Mission, TM, etc. that have added environmental concerns to their agendas informed by a global environmental discourse.
In contrast, Jain contends, his rural and vernacular communities have long been involved with environmental protection without using the vocabulary of international environmentalism. Part of the argument of this book is with a previous Ashgate title also concerned with religion and ecology in India, Biodivinity and Biodiversity: The Limits of Religious Environmentalism (Aldershot, Hants, England: Ashgate, 2009) by Emma Tomalin that had argued that it is important to distinguish “nature religion” from “religious environmentalism” (to this reviewer, an important distinction). The former (biodivinity) sacralizes trees, rivers, or mountains, but without this having any automatic positive environmental impact, while the latter, for Tomalin, is concerned with ecology and environmental protection—something that is a comparatively recent phenomenon (mostly since the 1960s) rooted largely in a Western romantic and postindustrial ethos. Jain counters Tomalin by highlighting his three communities in India that promote environmental sustainability but that cannot be said to derive this from Western models. They behave well environmentally without recourse to any environmentalist theory or vocabulary. Contra Tomalin's phrase that “religious environmentalism offers an interpretation of tradition rather than a traditional interpretation,” he maintains that the Swadhyayis, Bishnois, and Bhils have indeed been inspired by the traditional interpretation.
Jain prefers to locate their way of life under the rubric “dharmic ecology” rather than “religious ecology” because the communities he has studied do not posit a separate sphere of “religion” over or against another of “ecology.” The polysemous dharma integrates the dimensions of ethics, duty, and piety towards a universal order (including an ecological order) and thus, he maintains, is much more apt for the Indian context.
Jain also argues that, for India, the “dharmic approach” to the environment transcends a shallow ecology that measures the environment only in terms of human utility and is simultaneously superior to “deep ecology,” which privileges nature over humans. Rather, he claims, for traditional India, the dharmic unites the human and the natural in a divine unity.
Without question, this study advances the conversation on religion and ecology in India. We may discern three phases in this literature. The first might be characterized as enthusiasm for the potentially eco-friendly aspects of Hinduism sometimes celebrated in a rather uncritical way. The second may be seen as a critique of the naïve assertion of the intrinsic environmentalism of Hindu philosophy and praxis, a critique voiced by scholars like Emma Tomalin or Lance Nelson. Pankaj Jain perhaps inaugurates a third phase where the critiques of the second phase are fully acknowledged—but also contested; his three case studies are put forward to underline that there are religious movements in India that are not simply “otherworldly” and that do instantiate practical programs for environmental sustainability based on ancient Hindu sensibilities.
Jain has produced a study of interest both to those concerned with the general areas of religion and ecology and those whose interest is specifically Indological. (Valuable here are the appendices that provide translations of primary texts from the Bishnoi tradition.) Often the style and syntax of the book reveal its origin as a dissertation that could have benefitted from a more rigorous copyedit—but this is a minor quibble. It is a major contribution to the study of religion and ecology in India and debates within this domain. This volume is of obvious importance given the rapidly growing and globalized Indian economy and resultant stresses on Indian ecosystems. Beyond India, it is especially timely and pertinent given the contemporary situation where globalized consumerism, dependent on enormous energy consumption, generates global worries about impending ecological collapse and where many search for models of environmental protection and an ethos of sustainability.
