Richmond, Virginia: the capital of the Confederacy and a hotbed of the American Civil War. It's a city that's full of history, but not the type of history I teach. Or, at least, that's what I thought when I started my tenure-track job in modern European history at the University of Richmond in 2018, halfway through Donald Trump's first term. What I didn't realise at the time was how strongly the city itself would shape both my research and my teaching about fascism.
I moved to Richmond just one year after the deadly 2017 Unite the Right rally in the nearby city of Charlottesville, during which neo-Nazis and white supremacists marched with torches, shouting ‘Blood and soil!’ and ‘Jews will not replace us!’ In Richmond itself, controversies about the removal of Confederate monuments raged on, amplified by the Black Lives Matter protests in the summer of 2020. Just months before, the Proud Boys, a militant far-right group, had descended upon the Virginia State Capitol in protest of new gun control laws.Footnote 1 Years later, I drove down to Charlottesville myself. I was subpoenaed to testify as an expert witness for the prosecution in the criminal cases against two of the torch marchers. I sat in the witness booth explaining to the jury what ‘Sieg heil!’ means and what a Hitler salute is. The second of these trials took place in March 2025, just two months after Elon Musk proudly performed the Hitler salute after Trump's inauguration, igniting frustrating public debates about whether Musk's gesture was, in fact, a Hitler salute. The gravity of the moment was not lost on me as I gave my testimony.
As my own city and state turned into a battleground over history and memory, I couldn't help but wonder whether there might be parallels or even connections between far-right extremist movements in Germany and the United States. This question launched me into my current book project about the transatlantic networks of German and American neo-Nazis, which reveals how American white power extremists have actively sought to collaborate with Germans and re-Nazify Germany from 1945 to the present. The fact that I spend so much of my time thinking about the transatlantic far right has fundamentally shaped the way I teach the history of fascism. At a small private liberal arts college like the University of Richmond, where my history colleagues and I teach only undergraduates and where we develop close working relationships with our students, cultivating synergy between my teaching and my research is among the most valuable and rewarding parts of my job.
My introductory course ‘Nazi Germany and Fascism’ typically receives high enrolment, a testament to students’ enduring interest in what, unfortunately, has become an increasingly relevant topic. It attracts a wide swath of undergraduates: senior history majors and minors, first-years looking to fulfil their general education requirements, students who are simply fascinated by World War II and military history, and Jewish students with grandparents or other family members who survived or perished in the Holocaust. For years, I had titled the course simply ‘Nazi Germany’; however, I recently added ‘and Fascism’ to the title in order to tap into the growing public discussion over the term fascism itself. While I have not substantially altered the content of my course, the title change signals to students that my course is not only a place where they can learn about the distant past, but also where they can engage with a topic of immense contemporary relevance. At a time when many Americans use fascism as a buzzword with little contextualisation, students come away from my course with a deep understanding of Nazi Germany as a crucial case study.
Precisely because of the transatlantic nature of my research, I've found myself especially susceptible to the same questions about German and American comparisons that so many of our colleagues face in the classroom. My undergraduates seem to expect that I, as a scholar of both the German and American far right, might have something especially valuable to say about whether contemporary US politics is similar to the Third Reich, whether Trump is a fascist, or whether the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is the Gestapo. These are questions that I, quite frankly, am not interested in answering – in large part because I don't find them to be analytically useful. I often direct my students, among many other resources, to Gavriel Rosenfeld's article ‘An American Führer? Nazi Analogies and the Struggle to Explain Donald Trump’, which analyses the so-called ‘fascism debate’ that took place around the 2016 election and Donald Trump's first term.Footnote 2 Whether or not my students do this extra reading is unfortunately out of my hands.
My reluctance to engage with comparative questions does not mean, however, that I omit the transatlantic aspect from the classroom – far from it. In fact, I extensively incorporate the American context into my course. But I do so only under two crucial conditions. First, rather than veering into present-day American politics, I ground our discussion of the United States firmly in the past. Second, I focus on entanglements rather than comparisons. Among many other subjects, I teach my students about Americans’ support for Hitler, the shared climate of eugenics in which German and American race laws were crafted, former Nazis who emigrated to the US and the postwar transatlantic far right. Considering that my university is located in the American South, where students are typically at least somewhat familiar with the histories of anti-Black racism, Jim Crow laws, and the Ku Klux Klan, Jonathan Wiesen's article ‘American Lynching in the Nazi Imagination: Race and Extra-Legal Violence in 1930s Germany’ has proven an especially stimulating text to discuss.Footnote 3
Incorporating the local history of Richmond into my classroom has resonated especially well with my students, inspiring them to connect meaningfully to a history that took place over eighty years ago and an ocean away. For one of my writing assignments, my students conducted research in the online archive of our local newspaper, The Richmond Times-Dispatch. I gave them clear parameters for this assignment: they needed to search for ‘Hitler AND Jews’, confining the date range from 30 January 1933 to 31 May 1933. After perusing the eighty-three results, the students chose three robust and rhetorically rich articles and used those articles as evidence to answer the question: ‘What did Richmonders know about Hitler's rise to power based on what they read in their local newspaper’? My students have often been surprised to see how frequently news from Nazi Germany was reported in Richmond's newspaper, and how local Jewish groups in Richmond responded. The assignment also fulfils my goals of introducing my students to the skills of historical research, primary source analysis and defending an argument with evidence.
The Virginia Holocaust Museum, located in downtown Richmond just twenty minutes from our campus, has proven to be an excellent partner for community-engaged learning. The museum's exhibition, which offers ‘a unique Virginia perspective’ on the Holocaust, narrates the Holocaust through the family stories of survivors who settled in Richmond after the war.Footnote 4 Each semester, I take my students on a guided tour of the museum, and we have also had the opportunity to meet and hear testimony from local Holocaust survivors and their children. One semester, a select group of students in my sophomore seminar on ‘Remembering the Holocaust in Today's Germany’ partnered with the museum to design and facilitate a five-hour workshop attended by over twenty local middle and high school teachers. The workshop, which my students titled ‘Decoding Deception: How to Teach about Nazi Propaganda’, was a meaningful way for my students to put their knowledge about the Holocaust and its memory into practice, and to give back to our community.Footnote 5 For future semesters, I am thinking of developing a project that would allow students to conduct research on-site in the museum's archive.
I also bring my own research about the postwar transatlantic far right into the classroom. Towards the end of each semester, I assign my students one of my articles, ‘The American Influence on German Neo-Nazism: An Entangled History of Hate, 1970s–1990s’, and they ask me questions about the research and writing process.Footnote 6 They get especially excited hearing about my experiences testifying in court, interviewing neo-Nazis and digging through far-right paraphernalia in archives that span the Atlantic, from Berlin and Koblenz to Texas, Kansas and Rhode Island. Over the years, I've advised undergraduate summer research projects and honours theses on a wide array of related topics: homosexuality and the far right, punks and skinhead violence in 1980s Germany, and far-right extremism and social media, to name a few. Considering that there is overlap among some of our research topics, I've accompanied my undergraduate research advisees to nearby archives in the Washington, D.C. area (just two hours from Richmond) like the National Archives and Records Administration and the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. One summer, I researched alongside a student at several German archives, including the Antifascist Press Archive and Education Centre in Berlin and subsequently co-authored an article with him.
Alongside transatlantic entanglements, I also emphasise a temporal dimension: I often choose to teach my Nazi Germany class in the spring semester, which at my university runs from January through May, because it coincides with the period of Gleichschaltung (coordination), the first several months of Nazi rule in 1933. The timeline of key dates in Hitler's rise to power maps eerily onto our semester, allowing students to experience, in ‘real time’, just how swiftly fascism took hold. These dates include Hitler being appointed chancellor (30 January), the Reichstag Fire (27 February), the opening of Dachau (22 March), the Enabling Act (23 March), the boycott of Jewish businesses (1 April), the Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service (7 April) and the banning of the trade unions (2 May). Nearly every day, I start class with, for example: ‘Today is January 31, and yesterday is the date that Hitler was appointed chancellor in 1933’. As time flies by and we reach graduation week, students are surprised to hear that the Nazis had already burned books (10 May). And, as I forebodingly preface this timeline on the first day of the semester, quoting the nineteenth-century German poet Heinrich Heine, ‘Where they burn books, they will ultimately burn people’.
Amid all the doom and gloom, I've also found it imperative to emphasise Jewish joy and resilience – especially considering that I, as their professor, am Jewish. I make my background explicit to them, knowing that my ancestors in Eastern Europe were murdered in the Holocaust. This positionality also allows me to share aspects of Jewish culture with them, such as beginning each class session with a Yiddish word of the day – which often brings a smile to the students’ faces as they struggle to pronounce funny-sounding words like meshugenneh, shvitzing and fakakta. I've invited some of my smaller classes to my house for a homemade meal of matzah ball soup and potato kugel, and we once had a Hanukkah party in class to celebrate the end of the fall semester. Students have responded well to this approach, with one writing in an anonymous course evaluation that I ‘navigated the emotional burden of Nazi Germany exceptionally well’. Another noted: ‘[T]hough the course subject was deeply tragic, Dr. Kahn was able to balance it with stories of Jewish perseverance and her own sense of humour and often positive outlook’.
As I continue revising this course, I plan to incorporate two new thematic components, both of which respond to the contemporary political moment. The first is a focus on resistance. Previously, I covered resistance only in a twenty-minute lecture that preceded our discussion of Gad Beck's An Underground Life: Memoirs of a Gay Jew in Nazi Berlin. Footnote 7 Beck's memoir has always yielded a meaningful discussion not only about queer lives under Nazism but also about Jewish survival strategies and the underground resistance group Chug Chaluzi (Pioneer Circle). Nevertheless, in the current political climate of Trump's second term – where so many of my undergraduates feel that they want to do something to combat the far right but feel powerless to do so – a more robust unit on historical opposition to the Third Reich promises to resonate strongly with them.Footnote 8 The second is to begin the semester with a more explicit discussion of fascism itself, which corresponds to the change in the course's title. I had long omitted definitional and theoretical questions from my course, in large part because I simply chose to focus our limited time on other content. But considering how quickly many of my students have come to label contemporary US politics as ‘fascist’ since the start of Trump's second term, a unit devoted to unpacking the term ‘fascism’ itself seems essential.
I'd be lying if I said that this political climate hasn't put somewhat of a chilling effect on my teaching. It's not just the personal slog of waking up every day in a country where democracy is being eroded right before our eyes, nor is it just the exhausted looks on my students’ faces as they walk into class increasingly disheartened with the state of the country and the world. It's also the experience of teaching in a climate in which academia itself – and especially the historical profession – are under attack. I haven't engaged in self-censorship, nor have I omitted any material from my classes; however, I have become increasingly careful of what I say and how I say it. While I try to build a climate of trust and mutual respect in my classroom, the threat that students might be recording their professors, waiting on any soundbite to throw us under the bus, is omnipresent.
As faculty members on both sides of the Atlantic grapple with the rise of far-right politics, we can all take inspiration from the recent Pocket Guide for Academics Under Attack. Footnote 9 Published in 2026 by a group of European scholars in cooperation with the Documentation Centre of Austrian Resistance, the pocket guide advises academics on how to identify warning signs for attacks on academic freedom, how to recognise when we are unknowingly complying or engaging in self-censorship, resources to contact in the event of attacks, survival strategies and strategies for digital resilience and data protection. In cases of targeted harassment or doxxing, we can also consult the Online Harassment Field Manual compiled by PEN America, an American nonprofit organisation that raises awareness about the protection of free expression in the US and worldwide.Footnote 10
As a private small liberal arts college with a $3.5 billion endowment, the University of Richmond has been able to weather this storm better than most. Our administration appears sympathetic and responsive to our faculty's increasingly vocal concerns about the federal and state governments’ encroachment upon academic freedom. I continue to teach my other history courses, on topics like ‘Race and Immigration in Europe’ and ‘Gender and Sexuality in Europe’, with no pushback. When I recently got doxxed on a far-right website after publishing an op-ed, I was impressed by how responsive and supportive my university was.Footnote 11 I feel fortunate to teach in a close-knit community where I know my dean and provost personally. Still, it's not lost upon me that neither academic freedom nor tenure is guaranteed; they must be continually fought for, even at an institution as supportive and well-resourced as mine.
Teaching about Nazi Germany in the capital of the Confederacy over the last decade of tumultuous transatlantic far-right politics has reinforced an important point: our approach to teaching and researching fascism must not rest solely on comparisons but must also trace entanglements and mutual influences. Many of our students are eager to engage with uncomfortable questions that connect to their own lives and contexts, but those questions need not always involve contemporary resonances of interwar fascism in Trump's America. Fascism and far-right politics have never been nationally bounded, but have also relied on flows of ideas, people and money across borders. Encouraging students to historicise these transatlantic connections, and to explore how the local communities near their campuses grappled with European fascist movements, can help them engage more deeply with a history that feels simultaneously too distant and too urgent.
Michelle Lynn Kahn is an Associate Professor of Modern European History at the University of Richmond, the author of Foreign in Two Homelands: Racism, Return Migration, and Turkish-German History (Cambridge University Press, 2024), and the co-editor of Racism and Antiracism in Divided Germany (Cornell University Press, 2026). Her current research investigates the transatlantic connections between German and American far-right extremists from 1945 to 2000.
