When created in 1945, the Security Council was not intended as a forum to debate and devise solutions to human rights issues. Nonetheless, it is a body that is rooted in a social and legal structure sensitive to the human condition. Having experienced two world wars which ‘brought untold sorrow to mankind’,Footnote 1 the founders of the United Nations proclaimed their ‘faith in fundamental human rights’.Footnote 2 The contribution of women to the war effort had certainly not gone unnoticed.Footnote 3 The new order established in the aftermath of the war reflected the consequent change in attitude by breaking away from the inequality that had previously characterized male–female relations. In direct line with this profound transformation, the authors of the UN Charter reaffirm in the preamble their faith ‘in the equal rights of men and women’.
However, international human rights law at this early stage was slow to address the particular suffering of women. The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, in its great concision, refers only to equal rights for men and women with regard to marriageFootnote 4 and to the entitlement of everyone to the rights set forth therein, without distinction on the basis of sex, or other factors.Footnote 5 A similar provision is found in Article 2(2) of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Article 3 thereof confirms the equal right of men and women to enjoy all the rights set forth in the Covenant, while Article 7 insists on equal pay for equal work. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights likewise stipulates gender equality in the enjoyment of all the rights it contains.Footnote 6 It also protects pregnant women from sentence of death,Footnote 7 reaffirms the equal right to marry,Footnote 8 and bans all gender-based discrimination.Footnote 9
In the international system, the majority of provisions relating to the protection of women are designed to reduce and prohibit the many forms of gender-based discrimination against them. The efforts of the UN and its specialized agencies in this regard – including declarations, recommendations and resolutions – led to the adoption in 1979 of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women.Footnote 10 A committee to monitor its implementation (CEDAW) has been in place since 1982. Using an international investigation and individual complaint procedure, it works to ensure respect for women's rights.Footnote 11
Apart from the fight for equal rights, instruments relating to the vulnerability of women have had little success. The UN General Assembly's Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women is a case in point. It targets many forms of physical and psychological violence, which are in reality the consequence of persisting gender inequality.Footnote 12 The declaration, applicable primarily in peacetime, refers to physical, sexual and psychological violence occurring in the family,Footnote 13 violence occurring within the general community,Footnote 14 and violence perpetrated or condoned by the state.Footnote 15
This declaration is generally associated with the ConventionFootnote 16 and RecommendationFootnote 17 on Consent to Marriage, Minimum Age for Marriage and Registration of Marriages, as well as the earlier UN convention against the exploitation of the prostitution of others.Footnote 18 The latter serves to unify treaties drawn up before the UN was created.Footnote 19 Since 2000, trafficking in women and childrenFootnote 20 has been combated by the Protocol Additional to the UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime.Footnote 21
Whereas international law on the protection of women in peacetime has developed considerably, no specific convention has been adopted in this regard within the law of war. The only instrument to date is a six-point declaration made by the UN General Assembly,Footnote 22 which expresses the need to provide special protection for civilian women and children, who are the most vulnerable members of the population.Footnote 23 The declaration is somewhat limited in scope, as it essentially applies to those ‘finding themselves in circumstances of emergency and armed conflict in the struggle for peace, self-determination, national liberation and independence, or who live in occupied territories’.Footnote 24 For the protection of women in other types of conflict, therefore, we must turn to more general conventions of humanitarian law.
The first set of rules designed to protect women in war appears in the Lieber Code.Footnote 25 Article 47 provides for the punishment of those responsible for the rape of inhabitants of a hostile country. Despite all the atrocities of World War II, however, not one person was charged with this crime. The Charter of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East's criminalization of ‘violations of laws and customs of war’Footnote 26 as war crimes and ‘murder, extermination, enslavement, deportation, and other inhumane acts committed against any civilian population’Footnote 27 as crimes against humanity could have made way for the prosecution of rape. Yet the Tribunal failed to try Japanese soldiers for their violence against the ‘comfort women’.Footnote 28
To redeem the memory of the victims and survivors of those crimes, a 1998 UN Report on Contemporary Forms of Slavery seized the opportunity, for the first time, to establish the liability of the Japanese government for ‘Comfort Women Stations’ created during the war.Footnote 29 A symbolic judgement passed by the Women's International War Crimes Tribunal on Japan's Military Sexual Slavery (a people's tribunal organized by women's rights organizations) held the same view.Footnote 30 The 2001 final judgement found the Japanese Emperor Hirohito, along with other leaders, responsible as superiors and recommended measures of compensation to survivors.Footnote 31
In the judgements rendered at the Nuremberg trials, the terrible atrocities endured by women were ignored. Although rape was classified as a war crime in the charters of the national courts set up to try Nazi offences, they never carried out any prosecutions on that basis.Footnote 32 The rape of Berlin, for which the Soviet liberating forces are held responsible, likewise went unpunished.Footnote 33
International humanitarian law as developed in the Geneva Conventions is much more far-reaching in its protection of women. This protection was still in its early stages in the 1929 Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, where the only objective in that regard was to ensure different treatment adapted to the needs of female prisoners of war.Footnote 34 In the 1949 Geneva Conventions it was extended to about 19 provisions that are specifically relevant to women;Footnote 35 together with the 1977 Additional Protocols, there are now some 30 such provisions in all. However, these are subject to two major criticisms. Firstly, they fail to emphasize the gender specificity of the suffering endured by women.Footnote 36 Secondly, as a result, the gravity of offences against women is not sufficiently recognized.
Indeed, by stipulating the need to protect mothers (more specifically, expectant and nursing mothers), most of the provisions in the Geneva Conventions that relate to women are designed to protect children.Footnote 37 The other provisions refer to women's vulnerability to sexual violence. It can be argued, however, that the difficulties experienced by women in wartime are not confined to their roles as mothers and victims of sexual violence.Footnote 38 Besides being thus limited in scope, the protection offered also does not go far enough. Article 27(2) of the Fourth Convention half-heartedly states that, ‘Women shall be especially protected against any attack on their honour, in particular against rape, enforced prostitution, or any form of indecent assault’. Outrages upon women's personal dignity are not expressly included among the offences defined as grave breaches of international humanitarian law to which criminal liability is attached – the gravity of such crimes is consequently ignored.Footnote 39
Violations of humanitarian law have different legal consequences depending on their gravity. Grave breaches must be incorporated in national legislation as criminal offences and prosecuted through mechanisms of universal jurisdiction. All States Parties have the duty to search for and prosecute suspected perpetrators of a grave breach, regardless of their nationality or that of the victim, or alternatively to extradite suspects to states willing to prosecute them. For other violations, the Conventions simply stipulate that ‘[e]ach High Contracting Party shall take measures necessary for the suppression of all acts contrary to the provisions of the present Convention other than the grave breaches defined in the following Article’.Footnote 40 Additional Protocols IFootnote 41 and IIFootnote 42 did not progress much further in protecting women in situations of armed conflict. Article 76 of Protocol I largely reiterates Article 27 of the Fourth Convention, prohibiting any attack on the honour of women. Protocol II, in Article 4 laying down fundamental guarantees in times of civil war, does prohibit ‘outrages upon personal dignity, in particular humiliating and degrading treatment, rape, enforced prostitution and any form of indecent assault’, but there is no explicit acknowledgement of the gravity of these acts which would qualify them as international crimes. The Protocols are limited in their recognition of other specific rights for women, simply reaffirming those requiring their accommodation, when interned or detained, in quarters separate from those of men.
Humanitarian law has been repeatedly criticized by civil society organizations for its inadequate protection of women. Calls have even been made for some reformulation of the Geneva Conventions. It is within international human rights law, however, that their demands have been met. Though not fully satisfactory, the provisions within that body of law do at least help prevent the worst atrocities against women within the context of war. The World Conference on Human Rights, held in Vienna in June 1993, confirmed for example that ‘[v]iolations of the human rights of women in situations of armed conflict are violations of the fundamental principles of international human rights and humanitarian law’. The follow-up to this conference on women in war is worthy of consideration here.
In December that same year, the UN General Assembly proclaimed the Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women. The following year, the UN Commission on Human Rights established a mandate on the issue of violence against women, appointing Ms Radhika Coomaraswamy as the Special Rapporteur. Her report emphasized the need to revise existing international humanitarian conventions in order ‘to incorporate developing norms on violence against women during armed conflict’.Footnote 43 The sexual and physical integrity of women has, however, always had an important place in discussions on women's rights within the United Nations. In 1995, with this recommendation in mind, the former Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities initiated a more in-depth study of the issue, entrusting Ms Linda Chavez with a mandate on ‘systematic rape, sexual slavery and slavery-like practices during periods of armed conflict’.Footnote 44
Despite these efforts, and notwithstanding encouragement from the 1995 Conference in Beijing to pursue them (women and war featured as one of the 12 points on its Platform for Action), the international community has never adopted any significant instrument in this area. Indeed, humanitarian law efforts have consistently disregarded the far-reaching nature of the problems faced in situations of war by girlsFootnote 45 and women. For example, the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict raises the minimum age of recruitment from 15 to 18 years, yet remains silent about the plight of girl soldiers; and although the Optional Protocol on the Sale of Children, Child Prostitution and Child Pornography addresses sexual violence, it fails to tie the sexual abuse of girls to their roles in armed combat.Footnote 46 These issues are in fact governed by soft law, but it has distinct limitations, for reports, declarations and action plans are not legally binding normative instruments. They merely draw international attention to the special treatment required by women in war.
In reality, demanding more rights does not increase the likelihood that they will be respected. The international community's focus on sexual violence is understandable, however, given the systematic use of rape as a weapon of war. It is precisely because of the implications for international security of that systematic use that the Security Council has taken up the issue of women as victims of armed conflict.
The factual and legal foundations of the role of the Security Council
The growing international awareness of the atrocities suffered by women in war has coincided with the worldwide establishment of a responsibility to protect, through the intermediary of the Security Council.
Factual foundation: the inhumanity of armed conflict for women
The purpose of international human rights law is to protect women in peacetime. This does not mean that some of its principles cease to apply in times of war. On the contrary, they may well complement international humanitarian law. The Geneva branch of humanitarian law affords protection to civilians and to armed forces personnel no longer participating in the hostilities. Rather than attributing the shortcomings of international humanitarian law to a change in the nature of conflicts, there would be more reason to think that it was developed without taking the complexity of war into full account. The suffering women endure today is nothing new. The phenomenon of ‘comfort women’ predates the adoption of the 1949 Conventions. The weakness of humanitarian law in addressing women's difficulties is the result of deliberate oversight, or perhaps of purely fortuitous ignorance.
The reform efforts of 1977 were not, however, wholly satisfactory. They were praiseworthy in that they clearly defined the obligations of parties to an international conflict (Protocol I) and fleshed out Article 3 common to all four Geneva Conventions (Protocol II), but they once again stopped short at the problems of women in war. Yet it is well known that the intensification of violence against civilians, as a typical method of warfare, is more marked among women and girls owing to their vulnerability.Footnote 47 While men and boys are often forced into combat or killed in ethnic cleansing campaigns, the suffering of women is compounded by manifold abuses, facilitated by their gender and ranging from forced recruitment or conscription to rape or slavery in military camps and even murder.
Sexual violence has been by far the most frequently deplored abuse occurring during armed conflict.Footnote 48 It is generally perpetrated by all warring factions, as is the case in Colombia,Footnote 49 for it is a crime that achieves a number of objectives. The harm to the honour and dignity of the victim, though considered the main consequence of sexual violence, is certainly not the only one. Often systematic rape leads to or is accompanied by forced marriage and pregnancy, with the intent of changing the ethnic make-up of the population. It is in this context that sexual violence against women is now considered a ‘weapon of war’.Footnote 50 It becomes a method of warfare ‘[w]hen used systematically to torture, injure, extract information, degrade, threaten, intimidate or punish in relation to an armed conflict’.Footnote 51
In other circumstances, for instance in the event known as the ‘Rape of Nanking’ and the case of the ‘comfort women’ during World War II, the systematic violations of women's rights were not directly linked to the war objectives. Those women were used solely to gratify Japanese soldiers and kept in secret camps unknown to the enemy and to the public. They nonetheless served military aims, for they were used to motivate and reward combatants. In that sense, they involuntarily played a significant part in the war effort.
A brief review of armed conflicts reveals that such systematic violence against women cannot be traced back only to the wars of the early 1990s. Almost 200,000 women and girls were abducted and forced into sexual slavery by the Imperial Japanese Army during World War II.Footnote 52 More recent conflicts have seen a steady increase in violence against women. It is estimated that at least 5000 Kuwaiti women were raped by Iraqi soldiers during the 1990 invasion of Kuwait,Footnote 53 while a special UN report published shortly after the Rwandan genocide showed that during the fighting, sexual violence against women from the age of 13 to 65 was the rule and its absence the exception.Footnote 54 The Rwandan government reported 15,700 rapes, and 2000 to 5000 resultant pregnancies, whereas the Special Rapporteur – taking into account a margin of error and the possible unreliability of statistics, as well as unreported cases – put the figure closer to between 250,000 and 500,000 rapes.Footnote 55 This is an astounding figure in comparison with the genocide's total estimated death toll of 800,000. In the war that raged in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, which is still not definitively resolved, around 100,000 women were victims of sexual violence between 1998 and 2003.Footnote 56 There are reports of suffering on a similar scale in the conflicts in Liberia, Timor-Leste, Indonesia, the former Yugoslavia, Sudan and Afghanistan.Footnote 57 In the conflict in northern Uganda, 20 to 30% of the child soldiers recruited and abducted are girls.Footnote 58 According to Human Rights Watch, 100% of those who eventually escape the grip of the Lord's Resistance Army have a sexually transmitted disease.Footnote 59
Debates on the effectiveness of humanitarian law have resulted in new approaches towards the treatment of women, and the ICRC has conducted a number of studies to stress that women feel the impact of war in many different ways.Footnote 60 By intervening in the human rights field, however, the Security Council can offer more comprehensive protection for women in war, since it can repress violations affecting them and promote their rights during peacekeeping operations. Let us now look at the foundations of the Council's competence in this regard in international law.
Legal foundation: establishing a responsibility to protect
While the Council's role in implementing international law is unquestioned given the weight of the authority conferred on it by the UN Charter, its human rights role is a major innovation. Since the end of the Cold War and the fall of the Berlin Wall, the focus in international security has shifted towards the resolution of internal and transnational conflicts, in which violence against civilians predominates. The Gulf War, as an example of an inter-state conflict, did give rise to the United Nations Compensation Fund, but the fact that claims must be submitted through governments diminished its potential utility for victims of armed conflicts. Since the Security Council has been freed from the ‘veto straitjacket’Footnote 61 (in that permanent members have less recourse to it), and above all has been marked by the failures in the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, it has included human suffering on its agenda. The continuous expansion of its powers clearly poses a problem in terms of a democratic deficit,Footnote 62 but this is now rectified by the near complete consensus on its responsibility to protect. After much prevarication about the controversial principle of humanitarian intervention and the relationship between peacekeeping and strengthening democracy, the rule of law and fundamental freedoms,Footnote 63 a consensus was eventually reached during the 2005 World Summit. In a final declaration, seemingly admitting failure of the project to reform the UN system, Member State governments adopted a historic position, appointing the Security Council as the last resort for victims of armed conflict. They announced that they were:
‘prepared to take collective action, in a timely and decisive manner, through the Security Council, in accordance with the Charter, including Chapter VII, on a case-by-case basis and in co-operation with relevant regional organizations as appropriate, should peaceful means be inadequate and national authorities are manifestly failing to protect their populations from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity’.Footnote 64
Hence when all diplomatic means have been exhausted and the traditional system for protecting the individual – based on state responsibility and international co-operation – has failed, the responsibility to protect rests with the Security Council. This implies that in many cases the only possible means of ending the atrocities will be to resort to force. However, as we have seen in practice, the Council has complete freedom to choose its means of action. Chapter VII has indeed been used to justify intervention in conflicts where international crimes were being committed,Footnote 65 but the Council also likes to see itself as a legislator and advocate of human rights in war. In this sense, it has always been mindful of the suffering of women.
The twofold objective of intervention by the Security Council
The Council's intervention with regard to women's rights during armed conflict helps to strengthen international humanitarian law and to promote women as stakeholders in the peace process.
Reinforcing humanitarian law
The inadequacy of provisions to suppress violence against women has long been the main weakness of international law for their protection. The Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) has nevertheless helped to move the debate forward within its mandate to promote implementation of the 1979 Convention. As the convention had failed to address violence against women,Footnote 66 the Committee adopted a general recommendation on that subject in 1992,Footnote 67 which inspired the Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women made by the UN General Assembly in the following year. According to the Committee's recommendation, gender-based violence constitutes a form of discrimination when directed against a person specifically because of his or her gender.Footnote 68 By turning its attention to the situation of women in war, the Committee is helping to reinforce humanitarian law. The steadily growing violence against women in this context calls for specific protective and punitive measures.Footnote 69 These would comprise access to health care, rehabilitation and counselling services for all victims, and appropriate legal measures, including civil remedies and penal sanctions, against violators of women's rights.Footnote 70
The recommendation does not fully compensate for the gaps in the Geneva Conventions, but it does acknowledge that sexual crimes against women are sufficiently serious to warrant penal sanctions. The 1999 Optional Protocol to the 1979 Convention also reflects this standpoint.Footnote 71 It officially entered into force in 2001, introducing two major changes. The first enables female victims of discrimination to make a formal complaint to the Committee. The second, more importantly, gives the Committee the competence to conduct investigations in the territory of State Parties in the event of grave and systematic violations of women's rights.
Action by the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women is nonetheless limited, for although its mandate has been considerably extended, the authority of its decisions is undermined by the inherent weakness of international law, in particular the lack of enforceability. Similarly, as responsibility for compliance with human rights obligations is assigned to each individual state, penal sanctions are bound to fail in the absence of judicial mechanisms powerful enough to impose them. Moreover, state structures very often break down during armed conflict. Ad hoc interventions on the part of the Security Council became an option when it established international criminal tribunals.
In the terms of their founding resolutions, the International Criminal Tribunals for Rwanda (ICTR) and the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) are subsidiary bodies of the Council. Their creation confirmed its ability to exercise executive and legislative as well as judicial functions. The importance of its role in the advancement and protection of women's rights can no longer be ignored, for the two ad hoc Tribunals have established a jurisprudence that reinforces humanitarian law and also shows that the suffering inflicted on women is primarily of a sexual nature. They thus achieve two goals in that respect: sexual violence against women now constitutes a crime, and that crime is defined in international law.
By criminalizing such conduct, the jurisprudence of the ad hoc Tribunals has given a broader meaning in international law to the concept of violence against women in armed conflict.Footnote 72 The qualification of sexual violence as a grave breach of international humanitarian law amounts to a revision of the Geneva Conventions. The Tribunals have the power to prosecute persons committing grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions,Footnote 73 but also violations of the laws or customs of war,Footnote 74 genocideFootnote 75 and crimes against humanity.Footnote 76 As the seriousness of violence against women is not acknowledged by the 1949 Geneva Conventions, which do not include it in their list of grave breaches, such acts are mostly prosecuted as war crimes, acts of genocide or crimes against humanity.Footnote 77 However, the notion of ‘laws and customs of war’ is generally considered to be ‘a catch-all provision’Footnote 78 whose vague termsFootnote 79 allow for the inclusion of a number of humanitarian commitments.Footnote 80 The ICTY has thus interpreted it as banning sexual violence, including rape, against civilian populations.Footnote 81 It is consequently established that violence against women is likewise prohibited by the law of armed conflict as a grave breach warranting prosecution by an international tribunal. It is questionable whether states can in such cases actually exercise universal jurisdiction without a relevant treaty-based provision. Sexual violence can, however, be prosecuted under universal jurisdiction as a crime of genocide when it is deemed to ‘caus[e] serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group’ with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.Footnote 82 The definition of crimes against humanity already contained a provision explicitly prohibiting rape directed against a civilian population,Footnote 83 but the problem of applying it remained. This task was to be assumed, for the first time, by a body with international jurisdiction.
The concept of violence against women in the jurisdiction of the ad hoc Tribunals is at times restrictive (penalizing only rape) and at other times broad (penalizing sexual violence in general). It is not easy to broaden the concept, for sexual violence comes in many forms that tend to overlap and it is difficult to make a clear legal distinction between them.Footnote 84 For example, rape and sexual slavery can be perpetrated separately, concurrently or consecutively.Footnote 85
In Kunarac et al., the ICTY punished rape as a crime against humanity, in accordance with its Statute. As a war crime, the act has been sanctioned on the charge of torture, inhuman treatment, and wilfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health.Footnote 86 The ICTY understands torture and outrages upon personal dignity as being violations of the laws or customs of war, including crimes of sexual violence committed against detainees.Footnote 87 The Trial Chambers have therefore concluded on several occasions that rape and other forms of sexual violence, including forced public nudity, cause severe physical or mental pain and amount to outrages upon personal dignity,Footnote 88 and also that rape or sexual violence can be equivalent to torture for others besides the victim, particularly if the acts are committed in their presence.Footnote 89
This definition of rape nonetheless provoked controversy, which the Kunarac case seems now to have settled. The first definition appeared in the Akayesu case, in which the ICTR classified rape as ‘physical invasion of a sexual nature, committed on a person under circumstances which are coercive’.Footnote 90 In the Furundžija case the ICTY confirmed this definition, dividing it into two parts:
1. the sexual penetration, however slight:
a) of the vagina or anus of the victim by the penis of the perpetrator or any other object used by the perpetrator; or
b) of the mouth of the victim by the penis of the perpetrator;
2. by coercion or force or threat of force against the victim or a third person.Footnote 91
Criticized for insisting that the proof of rape lies in the use of force, the formulation in the Akayesu and Furundžija cases was amended by Kunarac, defining rape as a violation of the sexual autonomy of the victim and qualifying any sexual act as rape if:
1. the sexual activity is accompanied by force or threat of force to the victim or a third party;
2. the sexual activity is accompanied by force or a variety of other specified circumstances which made the victim particularly vulnerable or negated her ability to make an informed refusal; or
3. the sexual activity occurs without the consent of the victim.Footnote 92
Subsequent debates were centred on the notion of consent. In the Gacumbitsi case,Footnote 93 the ICTR Appeals Chamber was called upon to determine whether the burden of proof falls on the Prosecution, namely to prove absence of consent, or on the Defence to prove the contrary. In spite of the provisions designed to protect rape victims concerning evidence of the crime,Footnote 94 the Chamber accepted that the absence of consent remained an element of crime that must be proved by the Prosecution.Footnote 95 However, this requirement is significantly eased by the Chamber's acknowledgement that absence of consent can be inferred from the circumstances surrounding the crime, i.e. the context of genocide or the victim's captivity.Footnote 96 The same applies if the Prosecution can establish that the accused was aware that the coercive circumstances in which the rape took place undermined the possibility of genuine consent on the part of the victim.Footnote 97
Unlike rape, which is a crime under Article 5 of the ICTY Statute, other acts of sexual violence have become criminal offences through the jurisprudence of the Tribunal and are not laid down as such in its Statute. The Tribunal will, however, shortly establish its competence vis-à-vis such offences by including sexual violence in Article 3 as a violation of the laws or customs of war. The ICTR Statute, on the other hand, provides for the prosecution of both rape and sexual violence as a violation of Article 3 common to all four Geneva Conventions and of Protocol II on the protection of civilians in non-international conflict.Footnote 98 It is therefore only natural that the ICTR was the first to formulate a definition of sexual violence, stating that it was ‘any act of a sexual nature which is committed on a person under circumstances which are coercive’.Footnote 99 In light of the Statute of the International Criminal Court, the ICTY regards sexual violence as a concept that extends beyond rape to encompass sexual slavery and any other assault of a sexual nature.Footnote 100
Promotion of women's rights
The questioning of the Security Council's capacity to assume a normative function is reflected in the promotion of women's rights. Serges Sur states ‘[t]he Council … has always preferred acting and making decisions on a case-by-case basis, rather than formulating declaratory norms’.Footnote 101 The Council has now begun issuing international regulations in support of this preference – which either reinforce existing regulations or place new obligations on states – and in so doing is clearly going beyond the bounds of the specific situation defined in Article 39 of the Charter. This approach, meanwhile consolidated by persuasive practice, runs counter to the exceptional nature of the authority granted to it by Chapter VII.Footnote 102 In this way, the Council has over the past decade been adopting so-called thematic or declaratory resolutions which, being non-restrictive and non-binding, are no more than pale imitations of international conventions,Footnote 103 and often the most disregarded ones at that. The human implications of armed conflict have been by far the Council's foremost concern. To date, the following issues have been examined: children in situations of conflict; the protection of civilians during hostilities; HIV/AIDS and international peacekeeping operations; and the protection of UN staff, associates and humanitarian workers, journalists, war correspondents and the media in wartime. The Council has also issued two thematic resolutions on women, peace and security.Footnote 104
Before the first resolution on women, peace and war, of 31 October 2000, the Council adopted a resolution on 17 September 1999 more generally addressing the protection of civilians in war.Footnote 105 In this resolution, the Council was already evidencing a grave preoccupation with the status of women in war and formulating various recommendations; it expressed its concern at the fact that the vast majority of victims in conflicts are civilians, particularly women, children and other vulnerable groups, and acknowledged the direct impact of conflict on women. The solutions proposed are no less than declarations of international law.
The Council, for instance, points out the importance of widely disseminating international law on the protection of civilians, and of relevant training for civilian police, armed forces, and members of the judicial and legal professions, civil society and personnel of international and regional organizations.Footnote 106 It consequently encourages an acknowledgement of the need for gender-specific humanitarian aid and recognition of the violence women suffer. The Council also favours incorporating special protection provisions for vulnerable groups, including women and children, into peacekeeping mandates.Footnote 107 United Nations personnel involved in peacemaking, peacekeeping and peacebuilding activities should therefore have appropriate training.Footnote 108 The Council calls upon States to ratify instruments of international humanitarian, human rights and refugee law.Footnote 109 Additionally, all parties to conflict are bound to comply with their obligations under those bodies of lawFootnote 110 and states are bound to prosecute in the case of non-compliance.Footnote 111 In Resolution 1265 (1999) the Council provides, for the first time, for the possibility of intervening in situations of armed conflict where civilians are being targeted or humanitarian assistance to civilians is being deliberately obstructed.Footnote 112
In Resolution 1325 (2000), the Security Council highlights that the threat to women in war is distinct from that facing the civilian population as a whole, as it had previously done in the case of children.Footnote 113 This resolution expands on the provisions relating to women contained within Resolution 1265 (1999). It points out that women are being increasingly targeted during armed conflict and stresses the importance of full respect for international law relative to protecting women from gender-based violence – particularly rape and other forms of sexual abuse – and all other forms of violence in situations of armed conflict, and calls upon states to take special measures to protect women.Footnote 114 The resolution stipulates that those crimes cannot be included in any amnesty provision,Footnote 115 and that states have a responsibility to prosecute any perpetrators of such acts. In the same resolution, the Council also urges that the gender-specificity of needs be taken into account in mine clearance and mine awareness programmes,Footnote 116 disarmament, demobilization and reintegration;Footnote 117 it calls for men and women to be equally represented among peacekeeping operations personnel, and for all to receive training on gender issues. Similarly, it states that a gender perspective should be adopted when negotiating peace agreements.Footnote 118 The resolution breaks new ground not only in the area of protection, but also in promoting women both as the solution to their own suffering and as active and valuable participants in the restoration of peace and security. The measures set forth by the Council to this end are the following:
1. increased representation of women at all decision-making levels in national, regional and international institutions and mechanisms for the prevention, management, and resolution of conflict;
2. increased participation of women at decision-making levels in conflict resolution and peace processes;
3. the appointment of more women as special representatives and envoys to pursue good offices on behalf of the UN Secretary-General, and the creation of a roster of female candidates for this role;
4. expansion of the role and contribution of women in United Nations field-based operations, and especially among military observers, civilian police, human rights and humanitarian personnel;
5. incorporation of a gender perspective and gender component into peacekeeping operations;
6. training by and guidelines for Member States on the rights and particular needs of women, as well as on the importance of involving women in all peacekeeping and peacebuilding measures.Footnote 119
The implementation of these recommendations relating to the promotion of women as agents of peace has been the subject of a comprehensive assessment by the Security Council. Resolution 1889 (2009) reports a mixed result. It welcomes some achievements such as the efforts of States to implement Resolution 1325 (2000) at the national level through action plans,Footnote 120 the efforts of the Secretary-General to boost more women to senior United Nations positions, and the establishment of a United Nations Steering Committee on Resolution 1325 (2000).Footnote 121 However, the Council remained concerned about the under-representation of women at all stages of peace processes, and the persistence of obstacles to their participation, such as violence and intimidation, insecurity and lack of rule of law, cultural discrimination and stigmatization, lack of access to education, marginalization and lack of funds for efforts to rehabilitate women.Footnote 122
Resolution 1820 (2008) on women, peace and security – although expressing concern about the general situation of women in war and the obstacles to their participation in the promotion of peace – puts the main emphasis on rape and other acts of sexual violence against them during conflict. The resolution thus acknowledges that since 2000 violence against women has intensified in the majority of conflicts worldwide. This phenomenon is especially prevalent in Africa, in the bloody conflicts of the DRC, Uganda, the Central African Republic, Sierra Leone, Liberia and Sudan/Darfur. The Council recognizes that women and girls are particularly targeted by sexual violence ‘including as a tactic of war to humiliate, dominate, instil fear in, disperse and/or forcibly relocate civilian members of a community or ethnic group’.Footnote 123 It furthermore stresses that sexual violence against women can exacerbate armed conflicts and may impede the restoration of peace, and reaffirms its readiness to adopt appropriate measures to address widespread or systematic sexual violence on a case-by-case basis.Footnote 124 Resolution 1820 (2008) recommends both short- and long-term action to be taken.
In the short term, the Council can condemn all forms of sexual violence committed in armed conflict,Footnote 125 demand their immediate cessation,Footnote 126 and take targeted measures against parties to conflicts who commit these crimes.Footnote 127 Longer-term measures include promoting activities to prevent and address rape and sexual violence, protective action by states in accordance with their obligations, and punishment of the perpetrators of sexual crimes.
The responsibility for promoting a response to rape and sexual violence rests largely with the UN Secretariat and those agencies intervening in conflict zones, whose personnel must be trained in preventing, recognizing and responding to sexual violence. This applies particularly to peacekeeping operations personnel,Footnote 128 given the zero-tolerance policy established by the UN Secretariat vis-à-vis the sexual exploitation and abuse of civilians during such operations.Footnote 129 With regard to promotion, the Secretary-General is requested to develop guidelines and strategies to enhance the ability of peacekeeping operations to protect women and girls from all forms of sexual violence.Footnote 130
The protective measures formulated by the Council are intended to be more concrete. It places a number of specific obligations on parties to conflict, such as enforcing appropriate military disciplinary measures and upholding the principle of command responsibility, training troops on the prohibition of all forms of sexual violence against civilians, debunking myths that fuel sexual violence, vetting military personnel during recruitment to take into account past actions of rape and other forms of sexual violence, evacuating women and children under imminent threat of sexual violence to safety,Footnote 131 and protecting women and girls in and around refugee camps.Footnote 132 The Council also urges Member States to provide medical care and follow-up to victims of outrages upon their personal dignity.Footnote 133
Regarding the suppression of sexual violence against women, the Council's proposals reaffirm the exclusion of such acts from amnesty provisions, in recognition of the gravity of such acts and their inclusion as crimes in the statutes of the ad hoc Tribunals and the International Criminal Court. Member States must ensure that all victims of sexual violence have equal protection under the law and equal access to a justice system that takes account of their suffering.Footnote 134 According to the Council, it is important to react to these crimes not only for the sake of justice, but also for sustainable peace, truth and national reconciliation.Footnote 135
The limited impact of Security Council intervention
It is necessary to analyse the impact of the Security Council's sudden entry into women's rights matters, taking account of the fact that its resolutions are addressed to parties to armed conflict or to UN bodies.
Resolutions addressed to parties to armed conflict
An intervention can be ad hoc and confined to a particular context, as is generally the case when the Council responds to a threat to the peace, breach of the peace or act of aggression. In the cases of the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda – where massive human rights violations, including systematic and widespread rape and sexual violence, were deemed to be affecting international peace and security – the Council set up prosecution mechanisms, the ICTY and ICTR. Since it acted under Chapter VII of the UN Charter, its decisions were binding and enforceable; this established the authority of the judgements handed down by its subsidiary bodies. For the first time ever, those bodies imposed international sanctions on perpetrators of sexual crimes against women during conflict. These judgements have left a remarkable legacy, for the ICC, along with the international criminal courts created after the ICTR and the ICTY, reflect the advances accomplished: rape and other forms of sexual violence are now punished as international crimes, and are excluded from all amnesty agreements. In this sense, the Council could quite rightly be considered as having aroused the law of armed conflict from the latent state it had been in since its codification. The Council has done much to render its implementation more viable and the law itself better adapted to the atrocities of war, in which the use of rape and other forms of sexual violence as a method of warfare had hitherto been trivialized.
On the other hand, when the Council goes beyond the bounds of Chapter VII and adopts resolutions declaratory of international law, the impact of its intervention is somewhat limited, for thematic resolutions do not impose the same binding obligations as those of decisions made in response to a threat to the peace or international security. Yet their value should not be underestimated. The very position of the Security Council in the world order is in itself an inducement to give renewed meaning to the international obligations imposed by treaties and conventions on belligerents with regard to women's rights. Nevertheless, it should be recognized that the Council's authority has not changed the behaviour of the parties to conflicts regarding crimes of sexual violence. The recent review of Resolution 1820 (2008) by the Council in its Resolution 1888 (2009) is far from promising. The Council found absence of progress regarding situations of sexual violence in armed conflict, and recognized the ineffectiveness of its resolutions to curb the violence.Footnote 136
Resolutions addressed to UN bodies
The effectiveness within the UN system of the 2000 and 2008 resolutions on women, peace and security is indisputable. United Nations peacekeeping operations and subsidiary bodies are now gender-mainstreamed, which means there is increased participation of women in peacemaking and peacebuilding processes. There is also a greater capacity for understanding the psychological effects suffered by victims of sexual violence during conflict, which is the function of the ‘gender’ sections of peacekeeping operations. The UN Mission in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (MONUC) was required to take exceptional measures in light of the sheer scale of the use of sexual violence. In the context of DRC peace initiatives a separate UN task force was set up to address violence against women. Co-ordinated by the UN Development Fund for Women and composed of UN agencies, the Congolese Ministry of Gender, Family and Children and 16 civil society organizations, the mandate of this task force is to combat sexual violence and impunity.Footnote 137 The main stumbling blocks to full compliance with the said resolutions on women are those provisions addressed to parties to conflict and states. That is why a follow-up mechanism is necessary.
The Council remains focused on this need in relation to the issue of women, peace and international security. The 2000 resolution did not formally provide for follow-up, asking only for a review of the situation of women to be included in the Secretary-General's report to the Council. It also invited the Secretary-General to conduct a study on the impact of armed conflict on women and children. The 2008 resolution, on the other hand, requested him to submit a report by 30 June 2009 on the implementation of the recommendations made by the Council. It was to include, inter alia, information on situations of armed conflict in which sexual violence had been widely or systematically employed against civilians; analysis of the prevalence and trends of sexual violence in situations of armed conflict; and proposals for strategies to minimize the susceptibility of women and girls to such violence.Footnote 138
The Secretary-General met this request on 15 July 2009 and submitted a 24-page report to the Security Council. His study was confined to conflicts during the past 20 years in which sexual violence had been widely or systematically employed against civilians, with implications for international peace and security.Footnote 139 The main recommendations made by the Secretary-General urge the Security Council to pay greater attention to ongoing conflicts where sexual violence is being widely employed against civilians.Footnote 140
The Council's resolutions under Chapter VII of the Charter could consequently also indicate appropriate measures of prevention and protection. Similarly, the Council is invited to mandate its sanctions committees to pay particular attention to individuals and parties who perpetrate sexual crimes during conflict. The report furthermore recommends that a commission of inquiry, supported by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, be established to investigate and report on human rights violations, with a dedicated focus on sexual violence in ongoing conflict situations in the DRC, Sudan and Chad. Lastly, the Secretary-General proposes that a mechanism be established at institutional level to act upon sexual violence allegations, that a multi-agency approach be adopted in the UN Action against Sexual Violence in Conflict, and that the remit of the Council's working groups on this issue be broadened.
Resolutions 1888 (2009) and 1889 (2009) have addressed some of these recommendations, and Resolutions 1325 (2000) and 1820 (2008) now have well-developed monitoring mechanisms. The Council has specifically encouraged the Peacebuilding Commission and Peacebuilding Support Office to continue to promote gender equality and women's empowermentFootnote 141 and requested a report of the Secretary-General on the participation of women in peacebuilding.Footnote 142 It also welcomed the establishment of a post of special advisor to the Secretary-General on the implementation of Resolution 1325 (2000)Footnote 143 and requested the appointment of a Special Representative of the Secretary-General on sexual violence in armed conflict.Footnote 144 The Secretary-General was called upon to deploy a team of experts to assist States in strengthening the rule of law in situations where sexual violence is a particular concern.Footnote 145 The Council also requested that the Secretary-General develop proposals on ensuring monitoring and reporting,Footnote 146 and report on the implementation of Resolutions 1820 and 1888 on an annual basis.Footnote 147
Conclusion
The intervention of the Security Council in matters of human security reflects the shift in international security concerns from the state to the individual. Essentially the only body granted legitimate authority to resort to force in international relations, the Council is no longer acting solely in the field of jus ad bellum, but is intervening more and more in that of jus in bello, and thus in the protection of civilians. The increasingly widespread use of violence against women in recent conflicts has impelled the Council to adopt so-called declaratory resolutions that reinforce existing international mechanisms and institutionalize new practices, in particular gender mainstreaming and a zero-tolerance policy towards sexual exploitation or abuse of civilians during peacekeeping operations. In view of the magnitude of the suffering endured by women and its implications for peacebuilding, a Security Council special committee modelled on the Council's Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict (which highlights the scale of the child soldier phenomenon) would clearly be welcome.
