In May 1883, Amir ʿAbd al-Qadir ibn Muhyi al-Din al-Jazaʾiri was laid to rest near the great Sufi master Ibn ʿArabi's tomb in Damascus, where the Algerian and his large retinue had resided for several decades in exile. Best known for his determined resistance to the French army in Algeria between 1832 and 1847 and his decisive role in protecting the Christian inhabitants of Damascus during the 1860 uprisings—which earned him kudos from Abraham Lincoln—ʿAbd al-Qadir was also a highly original thinker. On 5 July 1966, the fourth anniversary of independence, the Algerian government repatriated his remains to the Carrée des martyrs in the El-Alia cemetery, calling home the native son to help heal the wounds of civil war and 132 years of colonialism. Yet even before his 1847 surrender to General de La Moricière in exchange for safe passage to the Ottoman Empire (a promise violated by France), ʿAbd al-Qadir had earned a transnational reputation that reached deep into the American heartland—to Iowa, in particular, which was (somewhat ironically) a former colony of New France. In 1845, on the eve of Iowa's admission to the Union the next year, Timothy Davis, a local surveyor who was scouting the Turkey River basin for land development, decided to name his settlement “ElKader.” (See Samuel G. Freedman, “Iowa Town Named for Muslim Hero Extols Tolerance,” New York Times, 4 May 2013, A16.) Davis had followed American newspaper coverage of the Algerian leader's struggles against France and decided that he would be a suitable hero, a founding father, for the new town. And so it remains ElKader until today. ʿAbd al-Qadir's life trajectory and multiple displacements, physical and otherwise, encapsulate Algerians without Borders: The Making of a Global Frontier Society.
Allan Christelow's most recent work invites us on a journey, one in which we accompany Algerians as they traveled far and near, willingly or not, and by so doing created a frontier society at home as well as diaspora communities scattered across much of the globe. This collective journey begins in the late 18th century and continues until the initial phases of the “Arab Spring” in late 2010, although the bulk of the work appropriately examines Algerians’ many histories from 1830 on. Significantly, the author treats the period from World War I until the years of early independence in a single narrative frame characterized as “Exchange and Innovation in the Revolutionary Era,” which reveals important continuities, in contrast to conventional scholarship that interprets 1962 as a moment of total rupture.
Throughout the work, Christelow employs biography as a powerful point of entry into a world of social flux and upheaval. We meet Algerians as ransom captives, exiles, muhājirūn, travelers, Sufis, defeated notables, students, colonial soldiers, and impecunious laborers, to name only a few of those who left the country; many returned, but many did not, as far as we know. From “Achmet Ben Ali,” a native of Algiers and a Mason, who found himself stranded in Philadelphia in 1794, to the Algerians residing even now in New Caledonia, the legacy of 19th-century forced migrations to the South Pacific, we observe people in motion. They followed older circuits, or became entangled in new ones, in response to a range of menacing, promising, or merely serendipitous events—the torque of trans-Mediterranean politics, emerging labor opportunities, novel transportation technologies, world wars and regional conflicts, the birth of international organizations, and shifting demographic and environmental realities. These displacements incubated unsettling ideas and mental cartographies regarding self, family, religion, and politics, while remapping others. In sum, the book triangulates between movement, life stories, and Algerians’ multiple religiopolitical and social identities across a number of registers, from the very local to the global, over two centuries.
One of the author's principal aims is to dislodge Algeria's historical experience from its current and somewhat narrowly construed subjectivity as a “former colony”—indeed, department—of France, and to tease out the longue durée connectivities between this region of the Maghrib, its heterogeneous peoples, and the many worlds beyond, whether Mediterranean, dār al-islām, or the Americas. However, then as now, Algerians did not simply move across boundaries of various kinds imposed, or delimited, by others, but themselves contributed to the placement and nature of borderlands. Too frequently, colonizers, invaders, and settlers have enjoyed the status of “people actively on the move,” while “the colonized” have been portrayed as curiously static and immobile—resisting, losing, and being subdued, even as they were cast out or elected to emigrate. This perspective is not some long-discredited artifact of colonial historiography but a position promoted by nationalist versions of the colonial and postcolonial past.
In addition, Christelow astutely observes that violence—colonial and otherwise—not only acted as a primary factor spurring Algerian expatriation but also influenced the reception accorded Algerians in homelands that were (perhaps) not of their own choosing, a phenomenon that tragically persists today. “Because Algeria has such a dramatic history, it has often assumed a special iconic status in discussions of global issues, from piracy to torture to terrorism” (p. 174). A fundamental argument made throughout the book is that there is a pressing need for genuine dialogue and communication across cultures, regions, and religions, which are never neatly bounded in any case, and that this becomes imperative with movement of various kinds. Very recent research reveals that even as the Algerian War of Independence (1954–62) entered its bloodiest phase, local daily communal ties between Christian progressives and Muslims, generated by interfaith dialogue and social welfare associations in Algiers predating the outbreak of hostilities, strove to find common ground. And this tradition survived 1962. In considering the crisis of the mid-1990s, Christelow contrasts the solutions proposed by the International Monetary Fund with those of the lay Catholic Community of Sant'Egidio that, together with the active participation of Algerians involved in earlier negotiations, organized the 1994 Rome Conference pressing for pluralism and democracy in Algeria and North Africa. His final chapter, devoted to new and old borders and border-crossings and how these currently generate collective morbid fears on a global scale in the post–Cold War and post–9/11 world, reprises the critical theme of dialogue. It speaks not only about, or to, North African or European audiences, but also to “everyone” out there; hopefully, they are listening.
Expatriation of various kinds is, and always has been, a family affair, even if women were “left” behind, were forced to move clandestinely because of social and other limitations on personal mobility, or could only legally join spouses or children by appeal to legal and familial authorities at home and abroad. While there is some discussion of women (but little of gender and migration), the reader longs for more treatment, biographical or otherwise, of Algerian women, of whatever background—Jewish, Berber, or Muslim. For example, the Kabyle woman Fadhma Amrouche (1882–1967) not only crossed numerous borders but also wrote one of the first, if not the first, autobiographies by an Algerian, Histoire de ma vie (which regretfully does not figure in the bibliography). And there are many more like Amrouche.
As is true of Christelow's work in general, this is a very solidly researched piece of scholarship. The author consulted seven major archival collections as well as a large number of published sources, including an exhaustive list of newspapers, magazines, and websites. There is a useful glossary but regretfully no maps or images, the latter surely due to the financial woes suffered by most academic presses these days. Students of modern Algeria will greatly benefit from Christelow's work; the lucid prose and the largely chronological chapter presentation render the book accessible to undergraduates, which makes a case for a paperback edition.
