Did homosexuality exist in the Arab World in the premodern period? Can we even speak about homosexuality as a category of human behavior before it was conceptualized by European positivists in the latter half of the 19th century? Do homosexual acts signify the existence of homosexuality? Is the very notion of premodern homosexuality in the Arab World an orientalist invention? These are just some of the questions raised by Khaled El-Rouayheb's insightful book in the University of Chicago Press series on gay and lesbian studies.
El-Rouayheb's book is part of a growing corpus of work on sexuality in the Middle East and homosexuality in particular. His discussion of the absence of a concept of sexual orientation in Arabic literary sources from 1500 to 1800 touches on some of the same themes of nuanced premodern elite sexual practices explored by Afsaneh Najmabadi in Women with Mustaches and Men without Beards: Gender and Sexual Anxieties of Iranian Modernity (2005). Edward Said's introduction of the work of Michel Foucault to Middle East studies is also in evidence here. Although Foucault's notions of hegemonic discourse and the relationship of textual authority to power have become almost clichés, El-Rouayheb is one of the first to source his three-volume History of Sexuality (1978–86). His exploration of how we interpret sexual behavior in a historicized context coincides with a much fuller discussion of Foucault's imprint on Middle East studies in Janet Afary and Kevin Anderson's Foucault and the Iranian Revolution: Gender and the Seductions of Islamism (2005)—and more is on the way. In Sexual Politics in Modern Iran (2009), Janet Afary, like El-Rouayheb, centers homosexuality as one of the most problematic cultural signifiers of modernity in the Middle East.
Literary references to homosexual acts, whether they are found in Sufi love poems or in the opinions of Islamic jurists, are interesting sources for the kinds of concerns that preoccupied premodern elites in the Arab provinces of the Ottoman Empire. However, texts offer us little reflection of actual social practices. Textual sources more directly relate to the sexual fantasies and interpreted reality of their authors. El-Rouayheb comprehensively sifts through the full array of extant Arabic sources available and organizes subjects according to the nature of homosexual acts and the categories of writers who contemplated them. Among Sufi poets and some religious scholars there was a continuous record of commentary on male attraction to unbearded youths. Islamic jurists were concerned about what constituted religiously prohibited sexual acts and those with whom sexual contact was forbidden. At least within the confines of the textual universe of elite Ottoman culture, anal intercourse—whether with a man or a woman—was generally regarded as an abhorrent practice that had religious significance related to the role of sexuality in procreation and casting a moral shadow over the imperative of establishing legitimate heirs. Premodern authors were more attuned to the implications for a person's status when engaging in sexual acts than to what the repetition of certain kinds of sexual acts said about a person's moral rectitude. Most agreed that anal intercourse negatively impacted the moral reputation of the passive partner more than the person who was the active penetrating participant.
El-Rouayheb's study concludes, “There was simply no native concept that was applicable to all and only those men who were sexually attracted to members of their own sex, rather than to women” (p. 153). However, every imaginable homosexual act was contemplated by writers, poets, and Islamic jurists. The more surprising conclusion is that from 1500 until the end of the 19th century there was almost no consensus on how to interpret the meaning of homosexual acts in religious law. Were they permissible? Were they prohibited? Were they punishable? If so, to what extent? El-Rouayheb makes clear that his study does not imply that there was a past age of tolerance—more that there was a former rich discourse of nuance, contestation, and moral ambiguity that disappeared as European powers imposed their own cultural norms on the Middle East and the Islamic world beginning at the end of the 19th century. It is ironic that by the middle of the 20th century the premodern authors and poets who wrote about sexual acts between men were heavily censored or no longer published at all. New Arabic words entered the vocabulary that approximated European medicalized terminology for same-sex acts that connoted perversion and degeneracy. In the modern period, homosexuality becomes a stock trope in a negative moral discourse, and Arabic language publishers busy themselves purging the premodern literature of references to even the hint of homosexual acts, whether they appear as poetic metaphors or legal commentaries.
