The New Atlantis is replete with mysteries and puzzles. In the fable, an enigmatic, educated, European sailor recounts his experiences on the “wonderful strange” Island of Bensalem, which for the last nineteen hundred years has remained unknown. While hidden, the House of Salomon, the scientific society that is the “lanthorn” of the island, has been studying the “Causes, and secret motions of things.” The House of Salomon not only possesses extensive knowledge of both nature and the rest of the world, but also wields unparalleled technological power. When the fable begins, the sailors are lost at sea and about to die. Salvation is found on Bensalem. The sailors are granted hospitality, protection, and limited access to the island. The narrative is dense and complex: it includes the island's conversion to Christianity; history with the great Atlantis; inception of the laws of secrecy; betrothal customs, which include physical inspection prior to marriage; procreative honors at the Tirsan festival; and the House of Salomon's mandate, structure, rituals, and technological abilities. After a Father of Salomon's House reveals the abilities of the House for “the enlarging of the bounds of human empire, to the effecting of all things possible,” the narrator is permitted to share Bensalem with the world, thereby ending the island's seclusion and concluding the text. Francis Bacon is tricky. His texts are designed to challenge his readers, inspire us to think through his arguments, and reconsider our beliefs and opinions.
Kimberly Hurd Hale accepts Bacon's challenge. She expertly incorporates the secondary literature, and draws heavily on the work of Howard White, Jerry Weinberger, and Paul Rahe. Her book encourages us to reconsider the purpose of the New Atlantis, its relationship to Bacon's Instauration, and Bacon's expectations for his project. At times, her account warrants further explanations and evidence to support her provocative arguments.
The fundamental interpretive question is whether Bacon intends the New Atlantis to extol the benefits of science or to warn against the dangers of technological power. Hurd Hale argues “that Bensalem may be an impossible, devastating dream—one that mankind will pursue unto our destruction” (87). In contrast to Benjamin Farrington, Howard White, Richard Kennington, Robert Faulkner, and Timothy Paterson, Hurd Hale claims that the New Atlantis depicts “the dangers of a scientific society devoid of liberty” (2). Following Tobin Craig's suggestion, Hurd Hale believes that Bensalem is not a regime to be implemented. This interpretation is persuasive. Despite the professed happiness of the Bensalemites and the stated heavenly nature of the island, there is ample evidence that discredits both their happiness and Bensalem's benevolence.
If Bensalem is not an archetype for Bacon's ideal of a scientific republic, the New Atlantis is, as Hurd Hale contends, a cautionary tale. Following Jerry Weinberger's analysis, there is something about the island that is not quite right. Hurd Hale claims that Bensalem is an island-sized Petri dish. Despite mention of a monarchy, the island, she argues, is covertly ruled by the Fathers of Salomon's House. Isolated from the rest of the world and ignorant of their own servitude, the people of Bensalem are at the mercy of these dangerous, unethical scientists who experiment on the island and its inhabitants. Hurd Hale's assessment rests on four pieces of textual evidence: first, the Fathers of Salomon's House conduct experiments to prolong life, cure disease, and strengthen human bodies; second, they have the ability to induce natural disasters and physical calamities; third, they educate the people to protect themselves against diseases and natural disasters; and fourth, the Fathers do not disclose all of their discoveries and inventions. It is unclear, based on Hurd Hale's analysis, precisely why Bensalem's practices indicate pernicious intent. Many contemporary liberal regimes conduct experiments to increase longevity, health, and well-being. Second, many contemporary liberal regimes have access to potentially destructive technologies. Third, many contemporary regimes undertake widespread educational campaigns to prepare people for calamities and to educate them about disease prevention. Fourth, government and private industry endeavor to protect their scientific discoveries and mechanical creations. Although Hurd Hale has begun to construct a convincing argument, more evidence is required.
One of the puzzles of the New Atlantis is the relationship between Bacon's text and its title. In addition to the titular mention, Atlantis is discussed in a single conversation that is initiated when the sailors ask how the island can be unknown, yet possess knowledge of the rest of the world. Atlantis is introduced by the governor-priest of the Strangers' House to explain the ancient history of the island. His disclosure is incomplete: the governor-priest “must reserve some particulars, which it is not lawful for [him] to reveal.” Atlantis is identified by the governor-priest as America, a once great nation destroyed roughly three thousand years ago by a great flood. Hurd Hale's presentation of the relationship between Bacon's new Atlantis and Plato's great Atlantis, recounted in the Timeaus and the Critias, is one of the book's strengths. She suggests that the new Atlantis is, in fact, Bensalem. She draws parallels between the great Atlantis and Bensalem, and she concludes that Bensalem, despite its technological prowess, is in danger of destruction.
If, indeed, the New Atlantis warns of a possible future wherein science is a means to oppression and Bensalem is a dangerous and malicious regime, Bacon has a far more nuanced understanding of science and the potential dangers of technological progress than is often acknowledged. Based on this interpretation, the New Atlantis is a corrective to Bacon's endorsement of science in his other texts. As do the Bacon of Howard White, Jerry Weinberger, Laurence Lampert, and Heidi Studer, Hurd Hale contends that Bacon recognizes the potential dangers of science and yet is willing to take that risk. Hurd Hale explains Bacon's influence on both Hobbes and Condorcet and claims that the New Atlantis is a guide for those who live in the world shaped by modern science. However, she does not adequately explain why modern science is worth the potential risks of a new Bensalem.
This text certainly fulfills many of its promises. At the conclusion of the text, however, one is left wanting more. If Bensalem is a corrupt regime and “an example of what not to do” (7), what is the alternative? How can a regime avoid the potential dangers of science? Hurd Hale suggests that liberty is the antidote to the dangers of science. While liberty may ameliorate some of the dangers of science experienced by regimes similar to Bensalem, liberty itself is not an antidote to all of the potential harms that science may induce in a state. Even liberal regimes may experience complications that arise from scientific mastery and technological advancement. Francis Bacon's “New Atlantis” in the Foundation of Modern Political Thought is an innovative, creative, and controversial analysis of the text. It challenges many of the dominant, long-standing interpretations of the text and, as a result, provides substantial grounds for further study and analysis.
