Mohras are metal face-images of Hindu deities and seers. In the Kullu valley, in the mountains of northern India, an area which has been inhabited for a long time, ritually enlivened mohras are treasured members of prosperous village communities. With the collaborative and hierarchal production of these objects and the dynamics of their performance and consumption as her twin-foci; Alka Hingorani has authored the first book-length study on art and life in the Western Himalayas that is equally attentive to ethnography and to art historical writing and methodology.
Making Faces is divided into five profusely illustrated chapters and a brief epilogue. In Chapter 1, the author compares two types of journeys that mohras are taken on. One type is exemplified by an annual pageant at which processions of porters and pilgrims from all over the region carry rows of flower-bedecked face-images enthroned on sedan chairs and caparisoned palanquins to the town of Kullu. Like the ceremonial excursions of chieftains who formerly governed the region, the mohras come to Kullu to see and to be seen. They congregate in the town centre and, with their devotees’ assistance, pay homage to the great gods, renew pledges to their subjects, negotiate their place in an increasingly crowded pantheon, and try to extend their authority. At other times of the year, the mohras are carried to those settlements in which their devotees wish to establish or renew marriage and kinship ties. In the author's perception, these journeys exemplify the second type of journey.
In Chapter 2, Hingorani discusses an unevenly published corpus of mohras and their appurtenances dating from the ninth-century to the present day. Tracing continuities and shifts in their iconographies and cultic affiliations, she emphasizes that mohras are generally not inscribed and are periodically remade by melting down and remoulding. Therefore, in lieu of a conventional construction of stylistic chronologies, and a straightforward account of the development of artisans oeuvres’, readers are offered a rich narrative that emphasizes the ritual and material life-cycles of these objects. Techniques of production, changing appearances, private and public presentations, and legends of valorous deeds are privileged over provenance.
Focusing on two objects which Hingorani was able to observe the creation of at close quarters, Chapters 3 and 4 describe not only the processes of manufacture, but also the immediate reception of mohras and associated implements after their creation. One object, a golden parasol—which was to be placed over a mohra—was fashioned by Taberam Soni, an itinerant artisan. Soni received this important commission from the elders of Kot village and he made the object at a specifically designated site near Bhargole, a nearby village. For much of the process, a team of high-caste Hindus from Kot and Bhargole assisted Soni—cooking his meals, and offering companionship, critique, prayer, and security. Hingorani commissioned Labh Singh to make the second object, a copper mohra. Singh chose to make a mohra of Shiva, a pan-Indic deity—in an idiom inflected by the conventions of calendar art—rather than that of a village god rooted in a regional aesthetic. He worked on the mohra at his residence in Bali Chowki village. Like other landmark studies of Indian manufacturers (e.g. Louise Allison Cort and Purna Chandra Mishra's Temple Potters of Puri Ahmedadad, 2013 and Jyotindra Jain's, Ganga Devi: Tradition and Expression in Mithila Painting, Grantha, 1997), Hingorani records the procedures, and materials used to create these metal objects as well as the lifestyle choices adopted by their makers. These details, along with a meticulous documentation of design decisions exercised by Soni and Singh, encourage us to regard these men as simultaneously traditional artisans and modern artists, rather than anonymous craftsmen creating wares in an unchanging style.
While Chapters 3 and 4 considered how lumps of gold and sheets of copper were transmuted into aesthetically pleasing and ritually efficacious objects, Chapter 5 explores how master artisans are able to shape and reflect caste-conscious Hindu society in the Western Himalayan foothills. Taberam, as Hingorani's perceptively notes, “is a raconteur; his rendering of words as much an art as his execution of objects”. Through accounts of his contacts with the wider world of plains-towns and merchants—as also creative retellings of Puranic legends—which he narrates to his captive audience of high-caste hills men, Taberam elevates his status. At the same time, by using tools that he received from his grandfather and by repeatedly bringing him into his conversations, Taberam sensitises his patrons to the subtleties of his hereditary profession and admits his lowly social status as an artisan, rather than a priest.
The monograph's five chapters and epilogue neatly cohere with one another. However, there is a tendency to avoid situating Kullu mohras and their appurtenances within a wider and longer story of art production in the Western Himalayas. For example, both Chapter 1, which discusses mohras in history, and the epilogue, which considers the consecration of a modern shrine, pay little attention to mohras’ relationships to traditions of Nagara temple architecture in the region. At the medieval Nagara temples at Hanol and Lakhamandal the incessant mobility of mohras appears to have been deliberately curtailed by permanently housing them in windowless sanctums and/or by carving representations of them on over-door panels. Likewise, by narrowly focusing her gaze on the lives of Soni and Singh, Hingorani fails to recognise that peripatetic metal smiths—like travelling architects, master masons and sculptors—have long played a crucial role in the formation of Western Himalayan aesthetics and politics. For example, the Rajatarangini, a twelfth-century chronicle, narrates how an “architect born in the country of the Turks” once approached a Kashmiri king for employment and received a commission to manufacture a gold parasol for a Shiva temple. During the architect's tenure, the king's minister discovered that the architect was in fact gilding a copper parasol with gold rather than making a purely golden one. He extracted the specialised knowledge of gilding from the architect, who thereafter felt uneasy and left the kingdom. Finally, Making Faces, completely ignores the many and varied traditions of metal portraiture that historically thrived in Kashmir, Ladakh, Spiti, Guge, Kumaon, Karnali, Kathmandu, and Purang. By neglecting all these materials, Hingorani misses an opportunity to contribute to an ongoing conversation on what constitutes Himalayan art that curators, critics, and scholars are equally engaged in.
These drawbacks aside, the author's nuanced descriptions, nearly 130 colour photographs, lucid glossary, detailed bibliography, accessible index, and clear lay out, make this monograph not only an exciting contribution to the field but also an ideal opening text for a broadly conceived postgraduate course on art and life in the Himalayas. With baited breath, we now await the publication of Hingorani's next book.
