No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
In Daniel L. Byman's most recent work, Keeping the Peace: Lasting Solutions to Ethnic Conflicts, the reader is treated to some of the most concise and understandable analyses of ethnic conflict in the literature today. Byman is able to explain the most difficult concepts in the fields of ethnic conflict and security in terms anyone can read, avoiding the jargon and impenetrable approaches so common in the field of international politics. In thirty-one pages, Byman is able to explain the field better than most authors do in two hundred.
The main thrust of the book is to unpack the difficult concept of ethnic conflict to shed light on how to prevent future conflicts. Thus, Byman's approach is not merely a theoretical treatise without reference or application to the real world. Byman nuances the concept of “hegemony” in a way that encapsulates the subtleties of power relations and examines state policies used to suppress minority groups. He also includes many issues long ignored by other scholars in the field. For example, he rightly includes the impact of education and language policies as a mechanism of exacerbating or mitigating ethnic conflicts—something that has had huge impact on community relations but is rarely ever mentioned by scholars.
Although Byman's explanation of outbidding could use a more robust definition, the review of the literature is where he excels at making accessible and clear security studies and theory. He nuances different forms of control and assesses whether they succeeded or failed in exacerbating conflicts or unleashing the security dilemma. Byman intersperses his theoretical arguments drawing on empirical cases, most of which, relevant for this journal, are in the Middle East. This is a valiant attempt to theorize a region long under-theorized because of the almost dictatorial control of regional specialists who argue the sui generis character of the Middle East and each case in particular. This is especially the case with regard to any treatment that contrasts the Palestinian–Israeli conflict with other conflicts in the region—for example, between the Kurds and Iraq or Turkey—or tries to contextualize the Palestinian issue within the global phenomenon of ethnic conflict. Byman does this precisely—contrasting the same control mechanisms across cases and across time, at the same time making reference to non–Middle Eastern cases such as Sri Lanka. His portrayal of Israeli policies in the initial period until 1956 is an exceptionally well balanced account of the mistakes made; some IJMES readers may find that he has let Israel off easily. Much to the contrary, Byman's portrayal is an objective one that avoids the usual vitriol common in any discussion of such highly charged issues. Israeli policies are contrasted with Iraqi policies under the Ba

th vis-à-vis the Kurds, leading up the Anfal campaign of 1987–88 in which thousands of Kurds in the northeast were systematically rounded up and killed by the regime. Byman succinctly explains the details of his cases, although he is sometimes too abbreviated in his treatment. The cases would have benefited from more detail; nevertheless, he gets the main thrust of conflicts in the region and elsewhere to make cogent points.
In his chapter on co-optation, Byman effectively explains how elites in Morocco have been successful in co-opting ethnic groups by preventing political organization by quashing independent association and forms of civil society, making it wholly subservient to the monarchy. “When independent leaders arose, they were given a simple choice: join the government publicly or be removed from the public sphere” (p. 90). This form of control avoided much of the nastiness of other mechanisms of control outlined in the book. He contrasts this co-optation with policies of the Ba

th regime under Assad, which was decidedly more repressive that those of the king.
Byman distinguishes ways of manipulating ethnic identities from Bakhtiyaris in Iran to Berbers in Morocco and Kurds in Iraq and discusses how partition, a hotly debated issue at the moment, is effective or ineffective by contrasting the experiences of Israel and examining how the safe havens in Iraq have protected lives but also complicated Iraqi politics. In essence, Byman takes an advocacy position and bravely concludes that borders should not been seen as permanent if their continuation does nothing but foster hatred, oppression, and violence. Although he emphasizes that this should be a rare occurrence, he argues that it should remain an option if it promotes peace (p. 174).
Essentially, Byman boldly discusses many of those taboo topics (e.g., “transfer” or population exchanges, military intervention, or backing one side) of control policies but does so creatively, fairly, and objectively. This book is an excellent example of balanced scholarship that travels throughout this highly contentious region to highlight the similarities and differences among diverse Middle Eastern cases. The book makes an important contribution to the fields of political science and Middle East studies and should serve as an example of the care and sensitivity with which we should all approach contentious topics. This book is appropriate for specialists in the field as well as the general reader, in large part because of Byman's masterly treatment of obtuse concepts that makes them easily accessible to non–political scientists. Keeping the Peace is sure to become a classic in the study of ethnic politics and seminal to the study of Middle Eastern conflicts.