Thomas Dixon helpfully reminds readers of this volume, echoing his pathfinding From Passions to Emotions (2003) and the guiding voice of Lucien Febvre, that ‘modern psychological categories’, which are in any case unstable, have no place in the history of emotions. The adjective ‘emotional’, he points out, was not in use in English until the 1830s, and ‘emotions’ themselves, in the eighteenth century and earlier, were not those phenomena that have been brought under the purview of psychological and physiological sciences since the late nineteenth century. Any historical discussion of feelings and experiences that, for the sake of convenience, we put under the head of ‘emotions’ must be undertaken with the utmost care, making use, where possible, of the ‘language available to and used by historical actors’ (p. 138). Dixon's approach is prudent, and the effect illuminating. His chapter on the changing bodily practice of weeping in the eighteenth century, as an aspect of religious enthusiasm or piety, as a marker of national character and manliness/effeminacy, is exemplary of the virtues of the history-of-emotions approach. Dixon shows most ably how tearful displays and associated feelings were bound up with contexts, expectations, spaces, places and specific times.
It is a pity that the editor and the other contributors to this volume did not follow Dixon's advice or his caution. The collection aims to do two things, principally to propose and substantiate a theory of space as it relates to emotions, and to document emotional change over time, in ‘sociabilities’. The geographical focus on Britain supplies a common reference point the better to chart change over time, and the book is therefore self-consciously arranged in a rough chronological order. With a couple of notable exceptions, the book misses its aims, presenting a confused and unworkable notion of ‘space’ and a muddled conceptual understanding of ‘emotions’ over the two centuries here considered. The contributors do achieve a rhetorical consistency in referring to things that are ‘emotional’ and to ‘spaces’ or ‘sites for feeling’, suggesting an editorial gloss of coherence among essays that do not obviously sit well together, and which do not, in the main, do what I would recognize as the history of emotions.
The editor (who refers to herself, in reference to her other two chapters in this book, in the third person) gamely tries to establish the parameters of a spatial theory of emotions. ‘Spaces for feeling’ are, she notes on more than one occasion, broadly defined: they are ‘communities’ in which shared identities or goals are ‘practised’ through ‘emotional expressions, acts or performances’ in a ‘specific space or site’. If this is not broad enough, these sites are either ‘physical or conceptual’ (p. 1). This is where the confusion is introduced, since it is hard to imagine a community practising through performance inside a concept. Clarification is partly achieved in individual chapters, but the overall range of possibilities seems limitless. ‘Spaces for feeling’ are ‘physical locations’, nation states, ‘social products’, households, ‘epistolary spaces’, objects (‘teapots, paintings, or printed media’), ‘imagined or conceptual sites’, the ‘family or dynasty’, and ‘psychic spaces’ (pp. 5–7). Space is stretched so thinly it can apparently mean anything at all.
The chapters work hard to fit the brief of talking about space and emotions, but much of the excellent archival work here would have been better served by not being forced into a framework such as this. There are important observations made about gender, power and domesticity in particular that stand by themselves as historiographically worthwhile. Stephanie Trigg's chapter on the ‘emotive syntax’ of the ‘speaking face’ (Chapter 9) in Austen's novels is the book's other high point, notable for its complication and augmentation of William Reddy's theory of emotives, adding facial expression and gesture to the mix. If the reader is able to receive the expressions of Austen's characters as if timeless, it is precisely because the facial expressions themselves are barely described, only the sentiment or feeling communicated. Yet tellingly, Trigg shows us that even the plainest of expressions is not accessible to all and depends to a large degree on the extent to which actors in a scene all have access to the same cultural script.
On the whole, however, both the emotions analysis and spatial theory seem superficially applied. Perhaps there is no greater indicator of this than the abundant presence throughout of that adjective – ‘emotional’ – that Dixon pooh-poohs as anachronistic. When specific emotions are called up – pity, love, fear – they are not themselves historicized, but rather invoked as if their meaning is readily understood. At one point, the emergent eighteenth-century novel is called a ‘highly emotional medium’; in another place the ‘public sphere’ of Habermas is effortlessly elided with the ‘emotional community’ of Barbara Rosenwein; in yet another place, a child who cried ‘as if it had been worried’ is analysed without any apparent realization that to be ‘worried’, in the 1720s, meant to be strangled or suffocated; and William Hazlitt is said to have developed a ‘theory of “empathy”’ in the early nineteenth century, despite the concept not existing until the early twentieth. Some might argue that such slippages in language use and emotion terminology are superficial, and do not alter the tenor or substance of the narrative. To my mind, and as Dixon warns, without careful use of language, the history of emotions has no purchase. If we rely on contemporary psychological categories and contemporary assumptions about the meanings of emotion words then we are not engaging in a history of emotions at all, but dabbling in anachronism and pop psychology. The community of scholars now engaged in the history of emotions, intent on making a serious contribution to knowledge about ‘emotions’ and cognate experiences, can ill afford to offer our critics such low-hanging fruit.
