Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T11:43:17.539Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Vortex pairing in jets as a global Floquet instability: modal and transient dynamics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2019

Léopold Shaabani-Ardali*
Affiliation:
LadHyX, École polytechnique–CNRS, 91120 Palaiseau, FranceDAAA, ONERA, Université Paris-Saclay, 92190 Meudon, France
Denis Sipp
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris-Saclay, 92190 Meudon, France
Lutz Lesshafft
Affiliation:
LadHyX, École polytechnique–CNRS, 91120 Palaiseau, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: leopold.shaabani-ardali@ladhyx.polytechnique.fr

Abstract

The spontaneous pairing of rolled-up vortices in a laminar jet is investigated as a global secondary instability of a time-periodic spatially developing vortex street. The growth of subharmonic perturbations, associated with vortex pairing, is analysed both in terms of modal Floquet instability and in terms of transient growth dynamics. The article has the double objective to outline a toolset for the global analysis of time-periodic flows, and to leverage such an analysis for a fresh view on the vortex pairing phenomenon. Axisymmetric direct numerical simulations (DNS) of jets with single-frequency inflow forcing are performed, in order to identify combinations of the Reynolds and Strouhal numbers for which vortex pairing is naturally observed. The same DNS calculations are then repeated with an added time-delay control term, which artificially suppresses pairing, so as to obtain time-periodic unpaired base flows for linear stability analysis. It is demonstrated that the natural occurrence of vortex pairing in nonlinear DNS coincides with a linear subharmonic Floquet instability of the underlying unpaired vortex street. However, DNS results suggest that the onset of pairing involves much stronger temporal growth of subharmonic perturbations than that predicted by modal Floquet analysis, as well as a spatial distribution of these fast-growing perturbation structures that is inconsistent with the unstable Floquet mode. Singular value decomposition of the phase-shift operator (the operator that maps a given perturbation field to its state one flow period later) is performed for an analysis of optimal transient growth in the vortex street. Non-modal mechanisms near the jet inlet are thus found to provide a fast route towards the limit-cycle regime of established vortex pairing, in good agreement with DNS observations. It is concluded that modal Floquet analysis accurately predicts the parameter regime where sustained vortex pairing occurs, but that the bifurcation scenario under typical conditions is dominated by transient growth phenomena.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Experimental visualisation of pairing in a jet, snapshot of a movie by Schram (2003).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Pairing dynamics observed experimentally in turbulent jets at $Re=O(10^{4})$, forced at a Strouhal number $St_{D}$ with amplitude $a_{f}$. No subharmonic forcing is applied. From Broze & Hussain (1996).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Vorticity snapshots of the periodic paired and unpaired states, obtained naturally for two different parameter settings. Forcing amplitude, Reynolds and Strouhal numbers are defined in § 3.1. (a) Paired state ($2T$-periodic) at $St_{D}=0.6$, $Re=2000$ and $A=5\,\%$ at $t=3T/2$. This is the same state as in figure 4(d). (b) Unpaired state ($T$-periodic) at $St_{D}=0.6$, $Re=1300$ and $A=5\,\%$ at $t=T/2$. (c) Unpaired state ($T$-periodic) stabilised using time-delayed feedback control, defined in § 4.1, at $St_{D}=0.6$, $Re=2000$ and $A=5\,\%$ at $t=T/2$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Vorticity snapshots of a paired case at $Re=2000$ forced harmonically at $St_{D}=0.60$ and $A=5\,\%$. Only the region near the inlet is shown. The colour coding is the same as in figure 3.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Total energy of the fundamental $\hat{\boldsymbol{u}}_{1}$ and subharmonic $\hat{\boldsymbol{u}}_{1/2}$ Fourier components in each plane $z=\text{const.}$ as a function of $z$ at $St_{D}=0.6$, $Re=2000$ and $A=5\,\%$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Phase speed along the line of maximum subharmonic mode of the subharmonic and fundamental modes of a paired jet at $(Re=2000,St_{D}=0.60)$, and comparison with the phase speed of the fundamental mode along the lime of maximum fundamental mode of the corresponding stabilised (unpaired) jet. The phase of the Fourier mode is denoted as $\unicode[STIX]{x1D711}$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Occurrence of vortex pairing as a function of Reynolds number and Strouhal number for configurations with forcing amplitude $A=5\,\%$ and initial shear layer thickness $\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}_{0}=0.025$. Only points near the pairing boundary are represented.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Occurrence of vortex pairing as a function of the Reynolds and the Strouhal number for two different forcing amplitudes $A=1\,\%$ and 10 %. The same symbols as in figure 7 are used.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Total energy of the fundamental and subharmonic modes in each plane $z=\text{const.}$ as a function of $z$ at $St_{D}=0.6$ and $Re=2000$. Three values of the inlet forcing amplitude are considered, $A=1\,\%$, 5 % and 10 %.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Vorticity snapshots at $Re=750$, $St_{D}=0.60$ and $A=5\,\%$ with $A_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}}=1.0\,\%$ taken at two different times, and both at the same phase. Pairing is intermittent, occurring in (a) and not in (b). The colour bar is rescaled compared to figure 3(b), to magnify the behaviour of downstream vortices.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Vorticity snapshots at $Re=1300$ and $St_{D}=0.60$ with $A_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}}=0.1\,\%$ taken at two different times, and both at the same phase. This shows the pairing location fluctuation, emphasised in grey, in this set-up. The colour bar is in figure 10.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Vorticity snapshots at $Re=1000$ and $St_{D}=0.60$ with $A_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}}=1.0\,\%$: (b) is taken two forcing periods after (a). The three vortices located in the shaded area in (a) merge altogether in (b), as an example of collective interaction. The colour bar is in figure 10.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Absolute value of the dominant subharmonic Floquet multiplier for different $(Re,St_{D})$, obtained for $A=5\,\%$. When the system is unstable, the most unstable mode is always subharmonic (e.g. real negative), except for the two labelled cases in (b), where the most unstable mode is almost subharmonic. When the system is stable, the represented modes are the least stable of the subharmonic domain. Black and grey bars represent parameter regimes with and without vortex pairing, according to uncontrolled DNS (see figure 7).

Figure 13

Table 1.Parameter combinations for which Floquet analysis is performed.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Vorticity component of the most unstable Floquet mode at $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.60$. It peaks far downstream.

Figure 15

Table 2.Evolution of the most unstable Floquet multiplier with the forcing amplitude for $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.60$.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Vorticity snapshot of the base periodic unpaired flow at $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.6$ slightly perturbed by the most unstable Floquet mode: $\boldsymbol{u}^{\prime }=\boldsymbol{U}^{\boldsymbol{u}}+\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}\tilde{\boldsymbol{v}}_{1}$, with $\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}=0.2$.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Real part of the vorticity component of the second most unstable Floquet mode at $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.6$. Its peak is located far downstream.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Growth of non-harmonic components in simulations with and without added initial noise. The modal Floquet growth rate is indicated for comparison.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Vorticity snapshots at five different instances without added initial noise. The colour coding is the same as in figure 3.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Perturbation magnitude $\Vert \boldsymbol{u}(t)-\boldsymbol{u}(t-T)\Vert$ at five different instances without added initial noise.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Vorticity field of the perturbation without any forcing applied at $t=40T$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Five snapshots of vorticity, evolving out of initial white noise level $10^{-3}$. The colour coding is the same as in figure 3(b).

Figure 23

Figure 22.Perturbation magnitude $\Vert \boldsymbol{u}(t)-\boldsymbol{u}(t-T)\Vert$ at five different instances evolving out of an initial white noise level $10^{-3}$.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Vorticity field of the perturbation with random forcing (level $10^{-3}$) at $t=5T$.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Norm of the time-shift operator for different Reynolds and Strouhal numbers, with a 5 % forcing level and a normalised momentum thickness of 5 %. The grey or black domains represent the parameter values for which DNS calculations show that the ‘natural’ solution is unpaired or paired, as shown in figure 7. In (b), the leading amplification rates are also depicted rescaled over one dimensionless time unit. Additional singular values for lower Reynolds number flows are discussed in § 5.4.

Figure 26

Table 3.Evolution of the optimal perturbation gain over one period with the forcing amplitude for $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.60$.

Figure 27

Figure 25.The twenty largest singular values of $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6F7}^{\prime }$ for $Re=2000$, $St_{D}=0.6$ and $A=5\,\%$.

Figure 28

Figure 26.For $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.6$, vorticity of (a) the optimal perturbation and (b) its response after one flow period. The maxima are located close to the inlet.

Figure 29

Figure 27.Superposition of the base flow and (a) the optimal perturbation, (b) the associated linear response after one flow period. The total vorticity is shown, for velocity fields $\boldsymbol{u}^{\prime }=\boldsymbol{U}^{\boldsymbol{u}}+0.05\boldsymbol{u}_{\mathbf{1}}$ and $\boldsymbol{u}^{\prime }=\boldsymbol{U}^{\boldsymbol{u}}+0.05\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}_{1}\boldsymbol{v}_{\mathbf{1}}$, respectively, for the case $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.6$. Both $\boldsymbol{u}_{\mathbf{1}}$ and $\boldsymbol{v}_{\mathbf{1}}$ have unit norm.

Figure 30

Figure 28.For $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.6$, vorticity of the second singular mode: (a) perturbation and (b) its response after one flow period. The maxima are located further downstream than in the optimal setting shown in figure 26.

Figure 31

Figure 29.Transient growth gain achieved by a $(Re=2000,St_{D}=0.60)$ jet forced with 5 % amplitude and comparison with modal growth.

Figure 32

Figure 30.Projection of the optimal initial perturbation and response at time $nT$ over the optimal initial perturbation and responses at times $T$ and $50T$ for a jet at $Re=2000$ and $St_{D}=0.60$ forced with a 5 % amplitude. While the optimal initial perturbation experiences little change, the optimal response changes drastically. All vectors considered have unit norm.

Figure 33

Table 4.Scalar products (4.7) between the Floquet mode $\tilde{\boldsymbol{v}}_{1}$ and the optimal finite-time initial perturbations $\boldsymbol{f}_{n}$ and responses $\boldsymbol{r}_{n}$. All modes and perturbations have unit norm. Consistent with the notations introduced in § 5.2, $\boldsymbol{f}_{1}$ is identical to $\boldsymbol{v}_{1}$, and $\boldsymbol{r}_{1}$ to $\boldsymbol{u}_{1}$.

Figure 34

Figure 31.Marginal gain $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}_{m}(nT)$ of the optimal perturbation at the horizon time $nT$ for $Re=2000$, $St_{D}=0.60$ and $A=0.05$. The marginal growth rate asymptotically converges towards the modulus of the most unstable Floquet multiplier.

Figure 35

Figure 32.Transient growth gain for a jet forced at $St_{D}=0.60$ with 5 % amplitude at different subcritical Reynolds number values.

Figure 36

Table 5.For $St_{D}=0.6$ and $A=0.05$, evolution of the least stable subharmonic Floquet multiplier and of the maximum growth rate over one period as a function of $Re$ in the stable case.