This book is the revised version of a doctorate submitted in 2010 in the Medical Faculty at Friedrich-Alexander University, Erlangen-Nürnberg. It deals with the formulae for medical magic preserved in the sole surviving work of the Latin doctor Scribonius Largus written between a.d. 43–44 and 48. Machold's book contains four chapters, a bibliography, an index of names and another of concepts, places and subjects. The very extensive bibliography mainly contains titles in German and English but also seminal works on Scribonius by Sergio Sconnochia in Italian and Joelle Jouanna-Bouchet in French.
The first chapter, on Scribonius, surveys, with one or two slips, the well-known outline of his life and book. The second defines ‘iatromagic’ and its types. Rather than following Graf's identification, in historical analysis, of magic as that which was considered to be magic in antiquity, M. bases his work on the research of H. Versnel and J. Braarvig and uses the categories of ‘extratextual’ (corresponding to existing, particularly Western, definitions), ‘intratextual’ (the conception of magic by the writer), and ‘intertextual’ (what was understood by the writer's contemporaries). M. assumes an extratextual perspective, the better for him to understand the choices and kinds of action found in magical remedies, without neglecting the two other approaches. Following K. E. Rothschuh, he defines ‘iatromagie’ as thought and activity designed to translate personal will into the environment and to compel the development, maintenance or return of good health. Relying largely on the categories established by Rothschuh, M. distinguishes between a medical magic based on similarity, Similitätsmagie (the most important category) and one based on singularity (Singularitätsmagie). In the former category he differentiates ‘isodynamie’, the use of a body part similar to the one affected; ‘morphoanalogie’, the use of a remedy similar, in shape or appearance, to the illness or affected part; ‘chromanalogie’, where the remedy is similar in colour; ‘dynamoanalogie’ (assimilation of the force of the remedy); or (building on Rothschuh's sketch) ‘ergoanalogie’, which puts together actions similar to the disappearance of the illness (transfer, imitative magic …). In terms of a magic of singularity, M. identifies therapeutic practices which depend on unusual appearance or characteristic, or on ominous influence (unheimliche Austrahlung, for example the use of owls), or vital force, or abstract mysticism (abstrakte Mystizismus). The third chapter considers the magical formulae in Scribonius and classifies them under these headings. The fourth chapter offers a brief conclusion which groups the formulae as extratextual, intratextual and intertextual, or all three.
The book offers an exhaustive catalogue of the formulae in Scribonius Largus which may be magical, and the classification of perspectives and the notes on the materials used are both judicious. Nonetheless, M. relies on traditional anthropological approaches which invoke supernatural power and sympathies between man and his environment to explain magical remedies. He ignores the justifications offered during the imperial period itself. From the Hellenistic period onwards, the importance of ‘sympathies’ and ‘antipathies’ throughout nature was taken as scientific fact, thus any supernatural action was rejected (this natural approach allowed some doctors (see Archigenes in Galen) to prescribe magical remedies); in this framework, the emphasis was on ‘antipathy’ as the effective mechanism (see Soranos and Galen). Scribonius Largus' silence on this topic demanded consideration, particularly as the problem of sympathy and antipathy in medicine is foregrounded in Pliny the Elder and doctors such as Soranus and above all Galen refer to it. It is true that Scribonius, referring infrequently to magical remedies and commenting seldom on them, is not a well-chosen author for a study of ‘iatromagic’ (24 formulae are studied from 271 chapters, of which 11 are magical only in the extratextual sense).
In other respects, the classification adopted can be questioned. Most of the categories depend on the distinctiveness of the substance used; the ‘ergoanalogie’ is a rag-bag of a category, just like, above all, the woolly ‘abstackte Mystizismus’, which could just as well embrace the use of products burnt to ashes and excrement as that of amulets, alone considered magical by contemporaries. The end result is to privilege the material — which can in any case be efficacious for doctors — as the thing which identifies ‘magic’ and lessen the importance of ritual aspects to which contemporaries were most sensitive in defining a remedy as magical (see for example the choice of popular remedies found in the rationalist Celsus, where there is almost nothing ritual). Ultimately, then, M.'s book — which is easy and useful to consult — is missing a historical perspective on the issue of magical remedies in the medical writings of the Roman period from the point of view of the period's doctors.
