Seneca and the Idea of Tragedy is a valuable addition to the debate concerning the relationship between Seneca's tragedies and his philosophic works. Although Seneca never explicitly outlines a theory of drama, by drawing on the statements that Seneca does make about poetry, Staley contends that Seneca's theory combined Aristotelian and Stoic ideas. This combination was influential for subsequent theories of tragedy, beginning with the rediscovery of Seneca's drama in the late Middle Ages up to the works of Sidney and Dryden. Even if we cannot be certain that Aristotle's Poetics directly influenced Seneca or that specific dialogues of Seneca influenced Sidney, this wide-ranging book sets out a convincing case that Seneca wrote his tragedies as a philosopher with an eye to the tradition of analyses of tragedy that stretches back to Plato.
As acknowledged in the book's preface, this study is deeply engaged with two works (viii). Eden's Poetic and Legal Fiction in the Aristotelian Tradition (1986) provides S. with evidence of the indirect tradition linking Seneca with Aristotle's theory of tragedy. Schiesaro's The Passions in Play: Thyestes and the Dynamics of Senecan Drama (2003) serves as S.'s main point of critique. For example, both authors look to Freud in order to elucidate their readings of Senecan tragedy. Schiesaro sees Seneca as the Freudian ‘dreamer-poet’ at play, whose tragedies unlock repressed and hidden desires that are antithetical to Stoicism. By contrast, S. argues that Seneca approached his tragedies as a psychoanalyst, critically revealing the hidden passions of the soul. Yet according to S., the psychological revelation that tragedy provides is ‘epistemological rather than therapeutic’ (18). With this point, S. connects Senecan tragedy with Aristotle, Sidney and Seneca's own theory of the passions. S. contends that the mimetic power of tragedy to make hidden psychological conditions manifest is what encouraged Seneca to write his own dramas. In On Anger, Seneca asks his readers to imagine the diseased soul that lies beneath the person who has become distorted and swollen with anger (2.35.4). S. argues that the monsters in Seneca's tragedies fulfill this point by providing ‘clear signs’ to the audience of their underlying psychological condition.
In the introduction and chs 1–2, S. gives a detailed overview and critique of several theories concerning the relationship between Senecan tragedy and philosophy, ranging from those who seek to harmonize Seneca's tragedy with Stoic views on poetry (e.g. Marti 1945, Nussbaum 1993, Gill 1997), to those who look to Plato's theory of the divinely mad poet (Dingel 1974, Schiesaro 2003). For S. they have not provided a satisfactory solution because ‘none focuses specifically on tragedy and the critical tradition in which it was featured’ (51).
Ch. 3 focuses on tragedy's relationship to epistemology and cognition. In contrast to Plato's critique that the poets are divorced from reality by six degrees, S. notes that both Aristotle and the Stoics stressed the truth-telling powers of mimesis and of images. S. explores the Stoic theory of phantasiai and of enargeia and argues that Senecan tragedy provides vivid images and ‘kataleptic impressions’ of the passions. S. critiques Eliot's claim that Senecan drama is all in the word by arguing instead that it is all in the image (54). In fact, Stoic theory probably combines the two. Phantasiai are also accompanied by propositional content, the incorporeal lekta or ‘sayables.’
Picking up on the work of Fillion-Lahille (1984) and Herington (1966), S. argues in ch. 4 that the presentation of passion in Senecan drama is closely linked to his discussions of the three stages of anger in On Anger 2.2–5. S.'s investigation of this passage serves as an important clarification to pp. 19–20 where S. gives the impression that Seneca says that we initially feel tristitia and timor when watching a play. S. considers whether the first movements ‘can in any way be pleasurable or helpful to our emotional and moral well-being’ (75). He investigates this question by considering whether Seneca intended his tragedies to produce ‘Stoic catharsis’. The remainder of the chapter focuses on the second stage of emotion, in which the soul is able to test and judge impressions. Because Seneca's plays present the ‘plot of the soul’ as it moves from impression to judgement to passion, S. argues that they enable the audience to understand and recognize the emotions.
Ch. 5 continues to cover a wide array of theoretical issues: Seneca's and Freud's interpretation of Vergil; further critiques of Schiesaro's use of Freud and of metatheatre; Stoic theories of allegory and divination; as well as ancient and modern theories of the grotesque. The main focus of this chapter is S.'s analysis of Tiresias' interpretations of monstra in Oedipus. According to S., Tiresias ‘is a model interpreter who can guide us in reading Seneca's “monsters”’ (105). Readers may wish that S. had offered fuller interpretations of the plays. This book does an excellent job outlining Seneca's philosophy, as well as his debt to the philosophical tradition and his influence on later theories, but the plays themselves receive less attention than one might hope. While S. argues ‘for Seneca monstrum is the core concept of tragedy’ (106), he does not back up this point with a sustained reading of an entire play or detailed look at the corpus.
The concluding chapter moves from Seneca's plays to his life. S. argues that ‘Stoic tragedy’ should be understood in two senses. Seneca's tragedies present the everyday world of madmen, fools and villains who are swollen with passions. Seneca's life and death, however, enacted the ‘truest tragedy’ of the Stoic saint who follows in the footsteps of Socrates. S. cites Seneca's discussion of the humanae vitae mimus (Ep. 80.7) to buttress his claim that Seneca believed all the world was not simply a stage but specifically a tragedy (123). Readers may not be convinced by S.'s interpretation of mimus as ‘image’ or ‘tragedy’, rather than simply ‘farce’. Furthermore, by using Seneca's comments on the ‘mime of human life’ to elucidate his theory of tragedy, S. may contradict his opening claim that we need to apply a genre-based approach to what Seneca has to say about literature (6–8).
The presentation is clear throughout, with very few, minor typographical errors. This book should become required reading for Senecan scholars and will also be of interest to those working more generally on the relationship between tragedy and philosophy.
