In Heroes and Martyrs of Palestine, Laleh Khalili traces a portentous transformation in Palestinian national narratives of commemoration, which first were oriented around heroism and then around suffering. She attributes this transformation to both regional institutional changes and international political developments. Especially for scholars of nationalism, Palestinians, nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), human rights, or liberation movements, this book offers a vital and incisive analysis of the high stakes of transnational humanitarian institutions and their discourses for local politics. This volume also constitutes a major contribution regarding the conceptualization of Palestinian martyrdom in the context of both international and local politics.
The book focuses on the thawra in the Palestinian camps of Lebanon (1969–82) and its long, more amorphous aftermath. The thawra involved the mobilization of dispossessed refugees into guerrilla soldiers—a symbolic transformation that forged a sense of heroism for Palestinians in the face of practical defeats. Khalili demonstrates that after 1982, Palestinian refugees of Lebanon felt increasingly isolated and marginalized, as resistance was refocused in the occupied territories during the first intifada and then, critically, as the Oslo agreements yielded a statist Palestinian Authority unconcerned with Palestinian refugees outside of the occupied territories. The single chapter on the occupied territories is intriguing because it suggests that due to the different relationship with Israel that the Lebanese camps and the occupied Palestinian territories have, and due to the presence of the Palestinian Authority, the contours of discursive transformation are quite distinct in the occupied Palestinian territories.
One of Khalili's central theses is that “in the crucial interface between the local and the transnational, nationalist commemorations, stories of peoplehood, and strategies of mobilization are forged, reproduced, and transformed” (p. 4). She traces the historical connections among Iranian, Lebanese, and Palestinian forms of commemoration. She also shows that the shift from Pan-Arab to Islamic discourses about political transformation was not an abrupt one; indeed, the two movements included many of the same key actors. There are strong similarities, she argues, between statist, liberationist, and Islamist ideas about heroism, self-sacrifice, and the reclaiming of history and identity both in the Palestinian movement and in other regional movements.
It is the liberal, universalist rights discourses of human rights and humanitarianism, she asserts, that shape quite different narratives. These discourses gained global power in the post-Cold War era and took root in the camps in Lebanon in the form of NGOs after armed struggle waned as a Palestinian strategy. NGO discourses often revolve around stories of abject suffering and have entailed a shift from a hypermasculine portrayal of the Palestinian hero to a feminized portrayal of the victim. This shift frames historical events differently, and different events are highlighted in Palestinian collective memory. During the thawra, Palestinians commemorated battles like Karama and Tel Al-Zaʿtar. As the discourse of tragedy or suffering has taken hold, massacres have become more important to Palestinian national memory—and nationalist commemorations have especially highlighted those massacres, like Dayr Yasin, that figure Palestinians as victims rather than as fighters, with no ambiguity whatsoever.
Another major contribution of this book is its intervention in popular Western notions of the exceptionality of Palestinian forms of commemoration. Martyr posters and mothers apparently celebrating their sons' self-sacrifice have often been viewed from the West as evidence of Palestinian aberrance. Khalili productively argues that Palestinians have much in common with other national groups, including in the United States, Europe, and Israel, in their ideas about self-sacrifice. Citing a verse from America the Beautiful, she argues that “blood-sacrifice for the nation is embedded in the patriotic rhetoric of all nations” (p. 23). She also elucidates the ambivalence that accompanies Palestinian mothers' most energetic exhortations to their sons to participate in national struggle.
Khalili's interlocutors are refreshingly diverse, and her research on nationalism, commemoration, and Palestinian politics is comprehensive. Chapter and subchapter headings are accompanied by quotes from poets, scholars, and activists as diverse as Mahmoud Darwish, Kwame Nkrumah, Edward Said, Michel Foucault, Franz Fanon, Susan Slyomovics, and former Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine guerrilla Maher Yamani. She utilizes long and rich quotes from interviews she conducted with men and women from Lebanese refugee camps. She writes about remarkably varied forms of commemoration, including music, oral history, martyr posters, cartoons, the Internet, pedagogy, naming practices, martyr funerals, and ceremonial gatherings, and she explains the specificity these forms take in a stateless context. In covering such a great number of forms across a considerable amount of time, she also opens further questions about media and commemorative practice, some of which she has addressed in shorter articles elsewhere. Given that she deals with such a wide scope of sources across decades, it is understandable why she leaves to others more in-depth and ethnographic research into NGOs themselves; such research might allow even more specific connections to be drawn between international discourses, local institutions, and political change.
This eloquent, engaging, well-researched book would make an excellent addition to courses on nationalism in the Middle East, human rights, NGOs, and, of course, Palestinian history. It adeptly fills a research gap about Palestinians in Lebanon and is an essential volume in any collection on Palestinian politics and society.
