The Libertine's Friend is a nuanced study of male homoeroticism and its relationship to concepts of masculinity and romantic love (qing) from the late Ming to the mid-Qing. Based mostly on his reading of vernacular fiction, from Stories from the Water Margin (1550) to Precious Mirror for Ranking Flowers (1849), which includes many pornographic stories, Giovanni Vitiello successfully illustrates the shifting, competing, and sometimes contradictory meanings of male-male sex relations, and relates them to changing ideals of masculinity in late imperial China.
Vitiello sets the stage by briefly summarizing two contradictory attitudes in classical Chinese writings regarding sexual relations between men. On one hand, the value assigned to male beauty (nanse) of a boy is comparable to that given to female beauty (nüse). Politically, a beautiful boy could be as dangerous as his female counterpart, for he could distract a ruler from his official duties and ruin the country. On the other hand, classical writings maintain a certain degree of sympathy for the ideal boy and romanticize male bonds. These perspectives can still be detected in later periods of Chinese history.
Tracing the rich vocabulary of male beauty in the Chinese language, Vitiello's chapter 1 argues convincingly that sex with a boy and the desire for male beauty were normative activities for an adult man. He thus disagrees with Sophie Volpp's contention that the characterization of male homoerotic culture as a “southern mode” (nanfeng) suggests its marginalization. Vitiello contends that the “south” could well include Jiangnan, which was located at the very center of the empire and set the cultural trends for the whole of late imperial China.
The language of male homoeroticism constructed a normative hierarchy of age, class, and gender, in which an upper-class older man typically penetrated a young boy of lower class status. However, chapter 2 demonstrates that this norm could be transgressed, and it illuminates how sex and love between two “decent” upper-class men, including the penetration of a young man from a respected family, were justified in pornographic fiction. As a reaction to the “soft” Confucian man, late Ming culture valorized a chivalric (xia) spirit, and the emergent ideal of masculinity combined chivalry and scholarly knowledge. The prized male friendship was an egalitarian homosocial relationship between men who both embodied this chivalric spirit. Furthermore, this model of male friendship became the basis for a gender-blind ideal of romantic love (qing). Chivalric and talented courtesans could join the ranks of honored males, and the cult of romantic love, in turn, condoned sexual relations between men. It was thus within the special context of late Ming culture that sex between men of the same social status and the penetration of a respected young man became possible and acceptable. On this basis, Vitiello challenges Timothy Brook's earlier observations by arguing that “male homosexuality in the late Ming period is not simply the mark of a decadent elite but a sexuality widely spread across the social spectrum” (p. 90).
R. H. van Gulik's influential work on sexual culture in China posited that the Manchu conquest led to a conservative alien culture replacing a sexually open-minded Han Chinese culture. In chapter 3, Vitiello traces changing representations of the libertine character from the late Ming to mid-Qing and argues that while a tendency toward sexual conservatism was detectable after the conquest, a marked change did not occur until the Yongzheng period (1723–35). This finding is also supported by the work of historian Matthew Sommer, who shows that the Qing state tightened laws on sexual behavior during this period. Vitiello finds a corresponding change in the representation of the libertine: the ideal masculine figure becomes sexually impenetrable around the same time.
Chapter 4 further explores these shifting boundaries of ideal masculinity by analyzing the anti-libertine hero of three eighteenth-century novels, “an energetic, hypermasculine Confucian scholar who redeems the male kind, if not the whole empire” (p. 133). Sex between men was no longer an example of romantic love, but was instead condemned as a sign of masculine deficiency. This militant hypermasculine trend, however, was only one side of the coin. The eighteenth century also saw the equally anti-masculinist male protagonist Baoyu in Dream of the Red Chamber, and the male romance A Precious Mirror for Ranking Flowers. In his final chapter, Vitiello persuasively reads Baoyu as the ideal of feminine masculinity, and he refutes Martin Huang's desexualization of the relationship between Baoyu and Qin Zhong. More importantly, Vitiello provides a convincing queer reading of the Mirror, which successfully debunks David Wang and Chloe Starr's previous thesis that the male actor is a female substitute and that the male romance is actually a heterosexual love story.
While paying very close attention to differences and changes in the conceptualization of male same-sex relations, Vitiello chooses to use the historically and culturally specific term “homosexuality” interchangeably with homoeroticism, homosexual relations, male romantic bonds, and sex and love between men to describe male same-sex relations during the late imperial period. One may be left wondering what this study would gain if the author had deployed the modern term “homosexuality” more carefully. That said, Vitiello's book provides a sophisticated understanding of male homoeroticism, ideal masculinity, and romantic love in late imperial China. It is an important work for the study of gender and sexuality in China.
