Scholars of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, along with graduate and undergraduate students, will find A Companion to the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, edited by Christopher McKnight Nichols and Nancy C. Unger, an essential resource. The thirty-four essays contained within it, arranged in eight thematic sections, are authored by a combination of the field's leading scholars and its rising stars. These pieces range from good to excellent. Overall, this volume combines a profound appreciation for the historians who have long defined this period—especially Richard Hofstadter, Robert H. Wiebe, and C. Vann Woodward—with a commitment to moving beyond the belief in American exceptionalism that, consciously or not, guided their writings. Specifically, key essays in this Companion contextualize the GAPE within a global framework.
Articles by Ian Tyrrell, Allan E. S. Lumba, and Katherine Unterman formally take on the responsibility of globalizing the GAPE in a section called “The United States and the World.” Tyrrell's “Connections, Networks, and the Beginnings of a Global America in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era” focuses on the central role that technology and nongovernmental actors played in paving the way for American imperialism, especially in Latin America and Asia. Works about reformers, engineers, missionaries, businessmen, and promoters of popular culture are showcased in his essay. Lumba concentrates on imperial practices and the vernacular of American exceptionalism underpinning it in his “Empire, Expansion, and Its Consequences.” He takes us from William Appleman Williams and the Wisconsin School's focus on political economy through Amy Kaplan's work on the culture of empire, and he synthesizes the two approaches. Lumba concludes by calling on future scholars to avoid the exceptionalism trap by ceasing to present U.S. imperial realities as contrary to the republican aims of the period. By focusing on “the expansion of international policing, increased global interconnectedness, and the involvement of the United States in World War I,” Unterman demonstrates that scholars engaging in the history of the United States in the world outside of formal foreign policy studies have avoided the paradox that Lumba identifies (republican ideals versus imperialist realities). She highlights recent scholarship that incorporated the views of Filipinos, Haitians, and Dominicans in reaction to U.S. imperial projects to illustrate how white supremacy and capitalist hegemony animated both colonialism and republicanism.
Other essays by Amy Louise Wood on the South, Alexandra Harmon on American Indians, Julie Greene on migration and race, Matthew Bowman on religion, and Lloyd E. Ambrosius on the Woodrow Wilson administration further illustrate how this global approach dominates the GAPE's cutting-edge works. Looking globally allows us to recognize how these processes worked. Southern whites turned to other nations to define racism more broadly in a defense of white supremacy. Native Americans at the World's Columbian Exposition asserted that depraved whites from Europe attacked established native civilizations. Immigrants provided the labor that produced the wealth that made the United States the richest nation in the world, which elites then used to fund America's colonial projects. Missionaries paved the way for industrialists and soldiers to impose U.S. dominance over weaker states. And Wilson used U.S. armed forces to undermine numerous leftist uprisings while proclaiming his belief in the self-determination of other nations. Together these scholars articulate how the ideology of colonialism moved from subduing the continental United States to focusing on Latin American and Asian countries, and how those committed to this imperial outlook used the power of the state to turn the United States into an empire.
Although this global gaze influences many of the pieces in this volume, there is no overriding theme the editors expected the authors to promote. A number of pieces continue to question “how ‘gilded’ was the Gilded Age” and “how ‘progressive’” the Progressive Era. Heather Cox Richardson's “Reconstructing the Gilded Age and Progressive Era” starts off this collection calling on us to expand the beginning of the GAPE to the end of the Civil War. She contends that the same questions about race, industrialization, and citizenship—which shape notions of the state's role, enfranchisement, and wealth distribution—extended from 1865 through World War I, thus making differentiating Reconstruction from the GAPE artificial. Others such as James M. Beeby and Brian M. Ingrassia, Michael B. Kahan, Thomas J. Jablonsky, and Omar H. Ali noted that the class, race, and gender of historical subjects—as well their location in Chicago, on a Louisiana plantation, in a Colorado mining town, or in the Panama Canal zone—determined how scholars situated their work in these never-ending fights over periodization. In other words, outside of Richardson's bold offering, The Wiley Blackwell Companion to the Gilded Age and Progressive Era does not seek to provide solutions to long-standing debates about defining the GAPE. It does, however, provide excellent starting points to understand the historiographies of industrialization, proletarianization, urbanization, middle-class consumerism, immigration, colonialism, political power, art, architecture, popular culture, and the struggles against racism, sexism, nativism, and capitalist exploitation.
The nuances presented on every topic within this volume will significantly assist not only specialists, but anyone who wants to update her lectures or think about primary sources to assign. Pieces by David Huyssen, Kimberly A. Hamlin, and Noam Maggor demonstrate this point. Huyssen calls our attention to the fact that W.E.B. Du Bois, Nellie Bly, and influential social scientists of the period—including Amy Tanner and Annie Marion MacLean—addressed African American and women workers’ issues at the same time the Commons School focused exclusively on white male unionists to establish the field of labor history. To truly understand working people in this period, we must incorporate all of these works into lectures and reading assignments. As with the field of labor history, Hamlin's chapter, “Gender,” reminds us that gender ideology originated in the GAPE, as challenges to the ideas of what was natural likewise applied to the categories man and woman, as it had to the economy. She urges us to examine “the supposed binary between men and women … [and] merge the history of gender more closely with that of sexuality” (98). This focus, she suggests, will help future scholars to bridge the divide between the history of science and political history. Maggor contends that we should stop presenting the GAPE as the era when the advent of capitalism occurred, and instead focus on it as the transition from slave-produced commodities traded across the Atlantic to the period when domestic production took over. Applying these three approaches will help us put gender and race at the center of our courses.
Other good points to stress to students include Bruce J. Evensen's reminder that journalism was the mechanism through which reform messages informed the public, especially during the Progressive Era. Essays by Alan Lessoff, Julia Guarneri, and David C. Hammack about art and architecture, popular culture, and nonprofits give overviews of topics that deserve more attention in our discussions about the GAPE. Also, Maureen A. Flanagan's chapter, “Decades of Upheaval and Reform,” provides a contextualization of essential primary sources that captured the different versions of democracy offered by intellectuals, industrialists, and journalists, as well as those advocating for the rights of women, African Americans, farmers, and workers.
There are some deficiencies in this volume. Most notably, the excellent work in Asian American and Mexican American history produced since the 1990s only makes brief appearances here. These topics merit their own essays. Nevertheless, the editors and authors should be commended for creating this valuable resource.
