With the United States experiencing a deep recession, it is hardly surprising that cries of an immigration and boundary enforcement crisis have emerged loudly yet again in mainstream political discourse. Nonetheless, the movement of migrants – most notably of the ‘illegal’ variety – across an ever-hardening US–Mexico boundary continues. The three books discussed in this review provide valuable insight into that movement and the lives of the associated individuals and communities who reside across and along the US–Mexico boundary. In doing so, the three works illustrate the transformational power embodied in the dynamic connections between the United States and Mexico as well as the great efforts employed, most markedly on the part of the United States, to distinguish the two countries from one another.
Migration from the Mexican Mixteca takes an in-depth look at two towns with intimate ties: San Miguel Tlacotepec in the southern Mexican state of Oaxaca, and Vista in California. As stated by the editors in an overly brief preface (a weakness compounded by the lack of concluding remarks at the book's end), natives of Tlacotepec ‘have built parallel communities’ on either side of the US–Mexico divide. Tlacotepec is, as chapter 8's authors assert, a community caught between ‘the world of tradition, faith, and community, and the world of consumerism, transnationalism, and modernization’ (p. 237). Moreover, it is one also profoundly affected by ‘an increasingly fortified international border’ (p. viii). The book's chapters are the outgrowth of hundreds of formal and informal interviews conducted between late 2007 and early 2008 by a binational team of 33 interviewers – who are also the authors of the individual chapters – trained and supervised by the book's four editors. The result is a highly interesting, multifaceted, in-depth examination of various aspects of the ‘transnational’ ties that shape and reflect life and death in the social space of Tlacotepec–Vista.
As the authors of the first chapter discuss, Tlacotepec has long been a community of migrants. Outmigration to the United States from Oaxaca and Tlacotepec was formalised beginning in 1942 with the establishment of the Bracero Program, a series of accords between the Mexican and US governments that brought millions of (male) contract labourers to the United States over a 22-year period. When the programme ended in 1974, Tlacotepenses continued to migrate to el Norte, but outside a legal framework. Today, emigrants from Tlacotepec are much more likely to head to the United States, where they can earn, on average, four times the salary they would in Oaxaca, than to a site elsewhere in Mexico as they would have decades ago.
The resulting migratory regime has brought many benefits to Tlacotepenses, the various chapters show, but at the same time has also given rise to myriad challenges. Those living in Vista, for instance, achieve greater educational levels than their compatriots in Tlacotepec. At the same time, however, they experience high levels of educational marginalisation, like Mexican Americans in general, and thus confront significant challenges vis-à-vis socio-economic and political integration into the United States. And while remittances from the United States boost the incomes of many Tlacotepec households, there are high levels of nutrition-related illness, a manifestation of changing dietary practices related to the ‘importation’ of US consumption habits and higher demand for cheap, relatively unhealthy, industrialised food products. At the same time, outmigration has led to a rise in mental illness, particularly depression, within divided families, and various forms of antisocial behaviour. What has intensified the hardships associated with the migratory regime is the sharp heightening of enforcement by US authorities since the mid-1990s, along the international boundary as well as within the interior. This has entailed a massive infusion of personnel, equipment and infrastructure and a dramatic rise in immigrant detention and deportations, the latter having resulted in the separation of hundreds of thousands of US-citizen children from at least one parent.
One can trace the origins of this build-up to various points in time going back to the founding of the United States. In Blockading the Border and Human Rights, however, sociologist Timothy Dunn, author of the pioneering book The Militarization of the U.S.–Mexico Border, 1978–1992, concentrates on its roots in the early 1990s. Dunn's geographic focus is on the area of El Paso, Texas, the ‘twin’ city of Mexico's Ciudad Juárez and the site of the Border Patrol's Operation Blockade (later changed to Operation Hold-the-Line to assuage Mexican sensibilities during NAFTA negotiations). It is a strategy, according to the subtitle of what is sure to become the definitive account of Blockade, which dramatically altered immigration and boundary enforcement nationally.
Begun on 19 September 1993, Blockade involved the round-the-clock, high-visibility deployment of 400 agents along the Rio Grande. As Dunn demonstrates, the operation, one launched by a public-relations-savvy Border Patrol chief and that proved to be very popular locally, emerged out of circumstances and pressures unique to the area. Specifically, myriad abuses by Border Patrol agents against local residents had led to a plummeting of public support for the agency, culminating in a lawsuit that forced the Border Patrol to end ethno-racial profiling. The verdict, argues Dunn, made it effectively impossible for the Border Patrol to maintain its modus operandi in El Paso: ‘roving patrols of predominantly lower-income, Mexican–American neighborhoods near the border’ (pp. 51–2). Blockade was the ‘answer’ to this problem.
Although the Border Patrol describes such operations as ones of ‘territorial denial’ or ‘prevention through deterrence’, Dunn persuasively shows in the case of greater El Paso that they are effectively more about displacement. Blockade, rather than first and foremost preventing migrants from entering the United States without authorisation and putting an end to Border Patrol mistreatment, instead led to a spatial shift of migrant traffic and the abuses associated with border policing to less urbanised, more remote, less visible areas, and the populations associated with them.
Dunn seems at various points to offer a conventional conceptualisation of human rights by emphasising violations – for example, those related to physical abuse, cruel and degrading treatment, unjust and excessive uses of force, and arbitrary arrest. Yet he also exhibits an appreciation for a broader notion when he discusses migrant deaths that occur in the process of unauthorised crossings. (Over 6,000 migrant bodies have been recovered across the US–Mexico borderlands in the last 15 years.) While Dunn's treatment of these deaths would seem to suggest that he sees enforcement itself as a human rights violation, this is not something that he explores.
David Spener, however, takes on this matter directly in his path-breaking book. In Clandestine Crossings the sociologist investigates coyotaje – the strategies and practices employed by those (‘coyotes’) who migrants hire to help them enter the United States clandestinely – as no other author has, in order to shed valuable light on the experiences of Mexican men and women compelled to cross ‘illegally’ given the impossibility of obtaining US government authorisation. Basing his rich analysis on scores of extensive interviews with migrants and coyotes alike over an almost eight-year period, as well as relevant secondary literature, Spener characterises border enforcement in the US–Mexico case as ‘no less morally problematic’ than ‘race-based restrictions of movement in Apartheid South Africa’ (p. 14).
While Spener is not the first to employ the idea of global apartheid in relation to immigration policing, he greatly adds to our understanding of the concept by exploring how contemporary migration across the US–Mexico borderlands relates to a history of Anglo/US American conquest and colonisation of the region, with a specific focus on southern Texas and its peoples. He thus concretises the concept in very helpful ways. Given his analytical framing, Spener sees the movement of migrants outside state structures as a legitimate and necessary form of resistance to injustice, one that ‘challenges both the forcible segregation of populations into zones of affluence and zones of poverty that defines global apartheid as well as the monopoly exerted by nation-states’ over human mobility (p. 19).
Central to this resistance is coyotaje. It is, as Spener carefully illustrates, ‘a social process that is embedded in networks of social relations and underwritten with social capital and cultural funds of knowledge’ (p. 163). And it is because of such embeddedness that it is so successful in helping migrants overcome the US regime of exclusion and ensuring the well-being of migrants during the process of crossing. (In the Tlacotepec case, for example, one chapter's authors report their finding that 92 to 98 per cent of the town's emigrants – two-thirds of whom rely on coyotes – eventually succeed in entering the United States.) It is not that terrible abuses with tragic consequences don't occur, but as Spener convincingly demonstrates in deconstructing dominant narratives that paint coyotes in the worst possible light, they account for a very small percentage of the overall number of coyote-led journeys. And to the extent that abuses do take place, Spener pushes the reader to appreciate that large structures of violence – the intensifying regime of exclusion and its associated injustices – need to be first and foremost the focus of scrutiny given ‘the extreme pressures brought to bear on migrants and coyotes alike’ (p. 223).
All three books show an appreciation for these pressures – where they differ is in what they suggest to do about them. Of the three, Migration from the Mexican Mixteca is certainly the most conventional, with the authors of one chapter proposing ‘a renewed emphasis on interior enforcement, especially in the workplace’. In addition to being ‘more cost effective’ than cracking down on the border, such an emphasis, they imply, will help limit ‘a continued culture of illegality that is undesirable for both U.S. and immigrant communities because it discourages assimilation and social integration’ (p. 58). Clearly the easiest way to rid the United States of an alleged unauthorised-immigration-induced ‘culture of illegality’ would be to decriminalise migration. That the authors seemingly can't even imagine that possibility serves as an example of what Dunn advances as one of the two competing analytical and normative frameworks for analysing state immigration enforcement practices: the citizenship–national sovereignty view (the other being the human rights perspective).
Dunn explores these two counterposing frameworks as they play out in relation to debates surrounding boundary enforcement in the El Paso area by drawing on his deep ethnographic research conducted over 13 years. In the process, he offers rich insight into state–society relations and the often overpowering ability of the state to construct collective – to borrow John Berger's phrase – ‘ways of seeing’. Dunn thereby illustrates how a failure to call into question not how the policing apparatus does things, but, first and foremost, what it does – that is, immigration enforcement – reinforces inequalities of power while further marginalising the most vulnerable. It thus institutionalises what Spener refers to as the ‘structural violence’ that facilitates the everyday abuses experienced by migrants and communities of colour along the US southern boundary with Mexico. Indeed, as Dunn painstakingly demonstrates, the nature of the criticism of the Border Patrol in El Paso and the associated advocacy in the years preceding Operation Blockade – which were largely of the citizenship–national sovereignty perspective – ultimately contributed to the border build-up.
Not surprisingly, Dunn supports a human rights approach – one that will ultimately result in ‘open borders’, or freedom of movement across and residence within international boundaries. Before realising that goal, however, Dunn proposes several interim steps, a number of which Spener echoes given that he foresees the prospects of undoing global apartheid as ‘impossibly utopian’ (p. 234). But it is exactly such an undoing that Spener hopes the resistance embodied in autonomous migration, one facilitated by the coyotaje he upholds as part of a necessary strategic alliance between migrants and coyotes, will help bring about. The goal, Spener states at his book's end, is one of a US–Mexico boundary ‘of inclusion, permitting the unfettered mingling, interaction, and cooperation of neighboring peoples, whose differences it recognized, but whose divisions it no longer enforced’ (p. 236).
As the three books demonstrate, the realisation of such a vision will be anything but easy. But the struggle to bring it about is certainly central to the promotion of the well-being of the peoples and places in the Americas – from Vista to Tlacotepec to El Paso, and all points in between and beyond.
