Perhaps few other theologians have suffered so much at the hands of their biographers as Jonathan Edwards. Take, for instance, the two most influential twentieth-century accounts of Edwards’ life. The work of Perry Miller, the Harvard historian of the post-war generation, kickstarted the modern interest in things Edwardsian. He painted a picture of Edwards as a precocious and febrile intellect tragically incarcerated in the cage of Puritan divinity, which stifled his scientific and philosophical genius. Yet he was so farsighted that we moderns are only just catching up with him. The key to unlocking Edwards’ work is not to take it at face value, according to Miller. It is an immense cryptogram which must be ‘seen through’ in order to glimpse the real story that lies beneath. In a rather different way, Ola Winslow's biography, which won the Pulitzer in 1941, paints Edwards as a tragic figure, one who was overtaken by events, whose Calvinism was a generation too late to be truly effective.
In more recent times, Edwards has had several more sympathetic biographers. In the 1980s, Iain Murray penned a lucid and careful hagiography of ‘America's Theologian’, whilst Patricia Tracy wrote an outstanding critical study of Edwards’ pastoral ministry in Northampton. In the present century, and in the wake of Marsden's first biography of Edwards, Philip Gura has written a compact ‘consideration’ of some central themes in Edwards’ life. But, amongst Edwardsian scholars, George Marsden's magisterial account of the Northampton Divine (Jonathan Edwards, A Life, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2003), which appeared in time for the tercentenary celebrations of Edwards’ birth, is the biographical benchmark. There is no danger of this monument to painstaking historical scholarship being overturned any time soon. For Marsden is not only a fine scholar who has done a terrific amount of spadework in the Edwards’ manuscripts, he is also a historian who has the unusual capacity to write sober history as compulsively readable as a paperback thriller. These qualities are evident in his short life of Edwards. It appears in the Library of Religious Biography series, edited by Mark Noll, Nathan Hatch and Alan Guelzo, which is concerned to bring serious scholarship to a broader audience. You will not find a single footnote in this volume, although there is a short bibliographical essay at the end in keeping with the series’ format. This leaves Marsden free to retell the story of Edwards’ rise to fame, and then his decline and early death as the President of the College of New Jersey (later Princeton University). The book is not an abridgement of his earlier biography, though, of course, it contains some of the same information. It is a deliberate attempt to represent the life of Edwards with this wider audience in view and, therefore, with a lighter touch. Yet the scholarship has not been sacrificed – for those inculcated into the arcana of Edwardsian literature, it can be found in gems of material which crop up as Marsden chases Edwards through the eight chapters of this little book.
The volume is short enough to recommend to undergraduates or those with little previous background in the period or in Edwards’ thought. Marsden has really attempted to ‘do things differently’ here, in comparison to his larger account. This can be seen in a theme which recurs throughout the book concerning the relationship between Edwards, as the man of ideas and of faith, and Benjamin Franklin, as a rather different sort of intellect, a practical man, even a pragmatist. All of which makes for an interesting counterpoint that enables Marsden to bring out the different ways in which Edwards and Franklin responded to their age, as well as showing how they were, in their very different ways, men of their age. Here too we find an Edwards ‘warts and all’ as we did in the previous biography. Marsden is no hagiographer, though he is also no iconoclast. His attention to the detail of eighteenth-century New England life, his familiarity with Edwards’ world, and his willingness to let us see Edwards in all his human frailty, is deeply refreshing. Too often in the past Edwards has been painted as an alabaster saint, or a hellfire preacher, or a disappointed intellectual. But for those whose primary interest is in Edwards’ ideas, there is rather less here than in the larger Life. This, if anything, is the shortcoming of the book. That said, Marsden's work has, in the opinion of this reviewer, gone further towards retrieving Edwards from some of his interpreters than anyone else – at least, amongst those who have a historical interest in Edwards. Its accessibility may mean it is more widely read than its predecessor. That is no bad thing. This is certainly a popular account of Edwards, in the best sense of that much misused term. In fact, it is probably the best popular biography of Edwards we are likely to see for some time.
