Laura Cull and Will Daddario's edited collection, Manifesto Now! Instructions for Performance, Philosophy, Politics, evinces the resurgence and renewed relevance of the manifesto in recent decades. The collection takes stock of the manifesto's continued life in the context of its longer genealogy by asking contemporary artists and scholars to write provocation pieces—either essays about manifestos or manifestos proper—that demonstrate the complex ways in which the manifesto employs elements of tactical theatricality in its aesthetics while mobilizing the illocutionary force of its performatives to make new meanings, instantiate new possibilities for social change, and imagine alternative realities in the present and future.
The book's curation is guided by an original methodological approach. The twelve pieces are paired to form a series of analogues in the sense offered by Brian Massumi in his Parables for the Virtual, wherein, in Cull and Daddario's words, “analogue denotes processes of co-operation, transformative integration, translation and relay” (11). The analogues cover vast and rich terrain: performance and protest; twenty-first-century socialist art and the Freee art collective; methods of reading the manifesto through the work of Yugoslavian screenwriter and film director Dušan Makavejev; education and the university in the context of neoliberalism; performance, immanence, and transcendence; and the nonhuman. The editors encourage readers to treat the book like a CD or a playlist, moving in a nonlinear fashion through the analogues according to their predilections. In the spirit of these instructions, I share some of the more memorable tracks from my own playlist.
In search of soothing harmonies for the academic so-called prioritization process currently underway at my university, my playlist jumped straight to Analogue 4 featuring a manifesto by Stuart McLean titled “What Is the University For? A Story from the Dreamtime of a Possible Future” and dancer-choreographer Mary Overlie's “Manifesto for Reification.” McLean scrutinizes the “rhetorics of both the free market and neo-Darwinism” (118) by which universities are conceived as institutions that must adapt to changing times and prepare students for the reality they will encounter upon graduation. McLean queries these assumptions, inviting us to conceive of a university that does not serve a society's needs—needs that are seen as phenomena generated outside the university and by the “vicissitudes of the capitalist workplace” (119)—but rather functions as an “incubator[ ] of new social possibilities” (120). Overlie's manifesto offers a glimpse of what the embodied practices of such an incubator might look like. Overlie takes the reader through the philosophical underpinnings of her Six Viewpoints with a particular focus on the exercises that call students' attentions to the process by which unreflective experience moves from the un-reified to the reified—terms that Overlie is careful to differentiate from their more pejorative senses derived from Marxist theory—and that prepare students for their encounters “with the unknown” (135).
I backtracked to Analogue 1, where Michael Shane Boyle's sharp “Absent Futures: The Ironic Manifesto in an Age of Austerity” makes a persuasive case for the political efficacy of the ironic manifesto based on an analysis of UC Movement for Efficient Privatization (UCMeP), one of the more radical student activist groups that emerged from the coordinated days of action that swept across University of California campuses in September of 2009. In his analysis of UCMeP's strategies, Boyle effectively demonstrates how the ironic manifesto refunctions “familiar features of [neoliberalism's] authoritative discourse” (31) and “expos[es] the gap between [its] promised futures” and the “material realities that neoliberalism conditions” (30). The companion piece in this analogue, “Duration and Space: The New Manifesto of Occupy Wall Street,” by Maurya Wickstrom and Stephanie Vella, pursues questions concerning temporality and the manifesto by examining the ways in which the occupation of Liberty Park by the Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement might be seen as an “embodied manifesto” (49) that is durational, a “manifesting” (50) that “reconstitutes politics in the now, as a presence, offering a crack in the wall of late-capitalist mythology” (50).
This processual aspect of the embodied manifesto leads fluidly into the following analogue featuring a manifesto by the London-based Freee art collective. Freee uses collectively generated manifestos to engage participants in “the idea of building a committed and politicized art rooted in democratic socialist society” (77); their methods emphasize democratic process and democracy both in and as practice. Drawing on the ideas of Hugo Chávez in their call for “Twenty-First-Century Political Art” rooted in democratic socialism, Freee acknowledges that one of the “primary roots of the new socialist project can be found in the socialism of indigenous peoples” and that “indigenous practices … must be rescued and empowered” (78). These remarks resonated as I moved through the volume since they spoke to a curiously absent perspective within the collection. Given that so many of these manifestos are searching for alternative epistemologies as a way of rethinking and reimagining the current world order, a more active inclusion of artist-scholars working from decolonial and indigenous perspectives would have added significant weight and depth to the book's overarching project.
The most provocative piece to take us in this direction is the manifesto/script offered by Electronic Disturbance Theater (EDT)/b.a.n.g. lab titled “Sustenance: A Play for All Trans [ ] Borders.” EDT aims to generate an alternative borderlands aesthetics in order to interrupt the dominant discourse that positions the migrant as “debris or felon” (166). In a move that recuperates movement from the stigma of transience consigning the migrant to a citizenless subject without rights, EDT “maps walking as practice, as a tool for ethical survival” and “recognize[s] the legitimacy of walking, of would-be-crossers' continental philosophy” (165). Through a clever expropriation of “continental philosophy” to generate transborder solidarities grounded in “the landscape, ‘la tierra’ … of an inter-Americanist ‘libertad’” (165), and a mobilization of the possibilities laden in the trans- prefix, EDT uses the performative power of the manifesto to open up new pathways for alternative epistemologies and decolonial crossings.
The pieces in this collection that undertake the intellectual risk of writing a manifesto proper leave a lasting impression. Editor Laura Cull, for example, offers a hybrid piece, using the peripheries of the page for a manifesto that stages an inspired incursion into her own more conventionally scholarly reflections on the implications of Deleuzo–Guattarian immanence for performance. The collection as a whole makes an exciting and valuable contribution to the fields of performance philosophy and contemporary political performance, and demonstrates the creative and critical potential of the manifesto for scholarly and artistic inquiry.
