This book offers a rich and highly informative ethnographic study of the ways in which nationalism and citizenship in Turkey have been pervaded by a discourse and culture of militarism, which resulted in what Altinay calls a “military-nation.” Altinay argues that this myth, which establishes the Turkish nation as defined by an essentially militaristic quality, is so pervasive that it is perceived as a natural and commonsensical condition of Turkish nationhood which leaves it closed to any negotiation and contestation. In her book, Altinay provides a richly illustrated answer to the question, “how is it possible that the military as an institution and ‘military nationhood’ as an idea have been so omnipresent, yet a discussion of militarism and militarization so absent?” (p. 3)
This is the first comprehensive—and much needed—book in English that takes a close look at militarism as a culture and the core of national ideology in Turkey. This feature alone makes this book a must for anyone interested in a more insightful view of the role and the centrality of the military in Turkish society and political culture. It is also highly relevant for those who are interested in the study of nationalism and citizenship and their relation to gender and militarism, but because the author provides only ethnographies and does not engage in a discussion with these more abstract issues directly, readers with such general interests are left to draw their own conclusions.
In six chapters, Altinay demonstrates the ways in which the myth of being a military-nation was produced and inculcated upon public culture in Turkey. After exploring the making of the myth of the Turkish military-nation through the writing of official national history in the early years of the republic, Altinay goes on to examine the gendering of citizenship in relation to this pervasive discourse of militarism. Even though this chapter provides a thorough account of Turkey's first female pilot, Sabiha Gokcen (who was also the first female combat pilot in the world), the highly complex and intricate relationship between gender and militarism is unfortunately reduced to the discussion of the presence (or absence) of women in the military. The presentation of the Gokcen's memoirs and the ways in which the state invests in her public image hints at very interesting questions about how the discourse of militarism is used in the construction of gendered notions of citizenship involving not only femininity but also masculinity, and yet the author does not offer such an analysis. She suggests that the discourse of militarism is about state control over women's bodies, but in fact most of her examples and observations in other chapters illustrate the ways in which militarism is more directly and centrally about state control of men's bodies. This indifference to the symbolic significance of men and their bodies in relation to the discourse of militarism only contributes to reproducing the same paternalist/masculinist discourse that treats the male subject as the invisible, unmarked norm, which the author is critical of.
Altinay also investigates antiwar movements and other challenges to the discourse of the military-nation. Enriched by the personal accounts of various conscription evaders and of gay activists who were declared unfit to serve in the military due to their alleged “psycho-sexual problems” (p. 80), this section illustrates how such counterdiscourses challenge the masculinist and militaristic norms of citizenship. However, the author does not elaborate further on whether these challenges change, subvert, or simply reinforce the dominant discourse of the military-nation. Indeed, some stories of gay activists and conscription evaders do not go beyond a complete and uncritical acknowledgement of the militaristic/masculinist standards of citizenship in Turkey. These sections necessitate a much more thorough analytical account of how exactly such counterdiscourses challenge, if at all, the dominant myth of the military-nation.
Examining the building of the myth of the military-nation in education, the last section of the book provides interesting observations on a crucial yet ignored issue, namely the “National Security Knowledge” courses that are compulsory in all high schools throughout Turkey and are taught by appointed military officers instead of civilian teachers. The significance of these courses is that this is one window in the national education system that is directly controlled by the military, giving it access to the students. Altinay brilliantly illustrates how the military uses these courses to teach students that the “right political perspective is the military perspective” (p. 137). In addition, Altinay's observations again illustrate the ways in which the discourse of the military-nation, as it is produced through these courses, establishes masculinist norms of citizenship, excluding women all together from being equally valued and rightful citizens. Even though these courses are taught to both male and female students, the ways in which the texts introduce the military and norms of citizenship, and the teachers address their audiences, treat women as if they are virtually nonexistent. Unfortunately, the author does not elaborate further on how these courses function to instill a very masculine and militaristic sense of nation and norms of citizenship in schools.
One of the most serious oversights in this work is the total neglect of the impact of Turkey's close alliance with Germany before and during World War II, and of the Cold War on the development and institutionalization of the centrality of the military in Turkey's political discourse and public life. In tracing the roots of the significance of militarism, Altinay looks only at the modernization efforts of the 19th-century Ottoman state, which, one can claim, plays only a minor role. Nowhere in this book is there mention of Turkey's close alliance and cooperation through the founding years (1930s) with Germany, which, at the height of its militarism, had a very powerful impact on the country. This influence is evident, for example, in the German-built Guven (Security) Monument marking the center of the capital, Ankara, and displaying a very masculinist and militaristic sense of nationhood. This insistence on militarism was further fueled by the Cold War and particularly Turkey's relationship to NATO as the only member country with a border with the Soviet Union. During this time, Turkey prided itself on being the NATO country with the second largest army after the United States.
Overall, Altinay provides an original, rich, highly informative, and well-illustrated account of the discourse of the military-nation in Turkey using case studies, interviews, personal stories, and observation. She is correct in drawing attention to the curious disregard for militarism as such a centrally constitutive feature of public and political culture in Turkey. It is unfortunate, however, that there is no elaboration on this work's theoretical and conceptual implications and Altinay's specific conclusions about the significance of the unique features of the military-nation myth in Turkey. When it comes to the theoretical, Altinay relies too heavily on secondary literature on discourses of militarism elsewhere. This book would be more complete if the author summed up her conclusions and the contributions her study makes to literatures on nationalism, militarism as a discursive practice, and citizenship. I speculate that the reason for such a significant oversight is because this work remains too confined to the disciplinary interests of anthropology and ethnography and fails to take up a more interdisciplinary approach that such a study of the culture of militarism begs for.
