The history of the assertion that science and religion are inevitably in conflict is dominated by two late nineteenth-century narratives; John William Draper's History of the Conflict between Religion and Science (1874) and Andrew Dickson White's A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom (1896). The present very welcome volume contains seventeen essays that examine these classic texts, their reception by contemporaries and the subsequent history of the conflict thesis. As Laurence Principe and several of the other contributors make clear, Draper and White offered significantly different analyses of the science–religion relationship and therefore of the source of conflict. For Draper, a devout positivist, Catholicism was the enemy of progress, while White considered that dogmatic theology was the antagonist.
Several of the chapters focus on responses to the conflict thesis in different religious and national contexts. By showing that local political and social factors are relevant, these studies help to undermine the frequently stated claim that the conflict thesis is a universal, atemporal truth. With respect to local differences, Efthymios Nicolaidis makes the important point that, unlike Protestantism, the conflict thesis had little purchase in Eastern Orthodox Christianity. In particular, the modern Greek state encompassed both science and religion as it saw itself as heir to both ancient Greek science and traditional Orthodoxy. Turning to America, Bradley J. Gundlich shows that in the late nineteenth century Protestant evangelicals managed to accommodate science, even evolutionary theory, while waging war against religious reform. However, with the rise of fundamentalism around the turn of the century, evangelicals increasingly portrayed evolution as incompatible with Gospel Christianity. By contrast, as Jon H. Roberts argues, liberal Protestants in America rejected the notion of conflict and generally opted for a separation of the two domains, thus significantly distancing themselves from fundamentalists.
A very different perspective is offered by Noah Efron, who argues that American Jews of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries perceived the conflict as being not with religion but with Christianity. Fearful that Christians were seeking to undermine their status as Americans, Jews embraced science as a natural ally against Christian hegemony, with many Jews pursuing careers in science. During the same period Muslims in the Ottoman Empire generally emphasized the harmony between Islam and science as a way of showing that Islam could encompass modernity. Yet, as M. Alper Yalçinkaya also shows, there were some dissenting voices who reflected the social tensions of the period. The complexities of Roman Catholicism's reactions to science are ably discussed by David Mislin, who draws attention to the Church's stand against such morally questionable practices as eugenics, but also its attempt to silence such internal critics as St George Mivart.
The use of history is a recurrent theme in this volume. Historical evidence was used by Draper and White to support their assertions about the conflict between science and religion. However, as several of their contemporaries noted, their historical examples were often badly flawed. The inadequacy of their histories – and other histories evoking similar conflicts – has likewise enabled modern historians to challenge the conflict thesis effectively. The recent writings on issues of science and religion by historians – many of whom will be familiar to readers of this journal – are discussed by John Hedley Brooke, whose own sophisticated contributions have demonstrated the many layers of complexity in any historical situation so that any simple conflict (or harmony) thesis is thereby rendered inadequate.
The role of history – or, more exactly, its absence – is also highlighted in the essay by Ronald Numbers and Jeff Hardin, who point out that none of the four principal New Atheists – Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, Daniel Dennett and the late Christopher Hitchens – appeal to historical examples to support their case. This raises the prospect that these New Atheists consider that science and scientism are not only in conflict with religion but also with the historians’ mode of understanding. Perhaps, then, we are dealing with a conflict between broader alternative world views, of which religion forms just a part.
A recurrent issue in this volume is implicitly raised by its subtitle, ‘the idea that wouldn't die’. Why, despite the efforts of many historians and others to show the inadequacy of the conflict thesis, is it still so prevalent? (On several occasions I have seen people on the London underground reading Dawkins's The God Delusion.) As John H. Evans points out, one reason for its popularity is that the press and other media thrive on controversy and are far more likely to give space to Dawkins et al. than to those who have more nuanced but less contentious ways of interrelating science and religion. Textbooks used by students in several fields, especially in the social sciences, also often make assertions about conflict, sometimes citing the Galileo affair or evolutionary biology as apparently definitive examples.
As the chapter by Elaine Howard Ecklund and Christopher P. Scheitle shows, the scientific community is far from unanimous on the issue, with many opting for the independence of science and religion, while others see these two domains as natural allies. Interestingly, the highest percentage of scientists who adhered to the conflict thesis was in the UK (35 per cent), followed by the US (29 per cent), while scientists in Asian countries less frequently perceived conflict. The reasons for these national differences and especially the popularity of the conflict thesis in the West and especially in the UK clearly deserves further analysis. Although this impressive volume covers a wide range of important topics, there is more to say about a related issue. While historians have worked hard to refute the conflict thesis and thus dismiss it as a myth, myths nevertheless usually perform significant social, political and psychological functions that need to be analysed and understood. Thus there is scope for further research on the function and relevance of such conflict narratives – and their staying power – to the individual, to specific social groups and to society at large.
