Saeid Golkar's Captive Society: The Basij Militia and Social Control in Iran is the first book-length study in English on Iran's leading paramilitary organization, the Organization for the Mobilization of the Oppressed (Sazman-e Basij-e Mostazafan), known as the Basij. Under the umbrella of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, the Basij is commonly thought to be the strong arm of the Islamic Republic that readily suppresses dissent and morally polices society. For any scholar seeking to understand contemporary Iran and state power, the Basij are an ideal group to study. Given that the group was founded at the beginning of the revolution, its trajectory provides us with a means of tracking the many transformations in Iranian statecraft from the 1979 revolution through today. Despite this, the Basij and the Revolutionary Guard remain understudied because of issues of access. Golkar addresses the lack of access in his book by relying on textual sources produced by the Basij themselves as well as published studies for the United States Armed Forces by such think tanks as the RAND Corporation. Golkar also employs semiformal survey and participant-observation data that he collected while teaching at Iranian universities before his move to the United States.
A sociologically ambitious text, Golkar attempts to fill the gap in literature on the Basij by offering an overarching view of the organization from its inception. Focusing on the historical development of the organization in Iran and its role in the cultural, economic, political, and social landscape of the country, Golkar uncovers the layered and complex relationship between the Basij as a paramilitary organization and the trajectory of the Islamic Republic over the past three decades. Golkar traces the establishment of the Basij to 1980, right on the heels of the 1979 Iranian Revolution. Initially founded to recruit and organize Iranians to support the new constitution and the nascent regime, the Basij became formalized throughout the eight-year Iran-Iraq War (1980–88) and was a key component in recruitment efforts for the warfront. Formally called the Basij-e Mostazʾafin (literally the “Mobilization of the Oppressed”), the organization began as a volunteer paramilitary group. During the war effort, millions of men received training in the use of weapons and were deployed to the warfront (p. 15). By the late 1980s, some two million volunteers had been inducted, which constituted more than 75 percent of Iranian fighters during the war (p. 16). Today, long after the end of the war, the Basij remain one of the most important sites of state power and citizen participation in the Islamic Republic.
What is compelling about the book is Golkar's ability to outline the various ways in which Basij organizational bases exist at all levels of society in Iran. From schools to workplaces to rural areas, Golkar demonstrates the wide-reaching effects of this organization on Iranian society, and explains the ways in which Basij members are trained at various stages through ideological–political training sessions. As Golkar argues, the Basij are the main arm of the state in confronting citizens on issues of revolutionary morality, and as such, they focus a great deal of their efforts on, as they put it, “stopping cultural invasion.” Since the end of the war, hundreds of thousands of Basijis have been recruited solely for the purpose of confronting cultural invasions both from abroad and from within the country (pp. 68, 75).
Although Captive Society is the first in-depth look into the Basij and helps to fill holes in scholarship about this organization in Iran's sociopolitical history since the 1979 Revolution, four missed opportunities stand out in this work: an explanation of reformist tendencies among rank and file Basij; analysis of generational change among Basijis; addressing how the material motivations for joining the Basij could complicate the ideological–political training of the members; and analyzing the very different roles that the Basij play in urban centers versus towns and villages. Golkar implies throughout the monograph that the Basij receive ideological training to be loyal to the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei. He paints them as a monolithic organization in which orders are given at the top and are followed down to the rank and file. Nonetheless, Golkar does recognize that a vast majority of Basij and Revolutionary Guard members voted for the reformist president, Mohammad Khatami, in 1997, in his landslide victory over Ali Akbar Nategh Nouri, the Supreme Leader's favored candidate. Instead of offering an analysis of how this could happen, especially if the Basij is supposed to be a monolithic organization whose members take orders from the top, Golkar brushes over this significant incident and instead outlines how Khamenei attempted to fill its ranks with more hardline members after Khatami's victory. These are ripe instances in which the Basij as an organization could have been be further complicated and more agency can be granted to its members.
Furthermore, there is a striking absence of analysis of generational changes among the Basij and the ways in which the material motivations for joining the Basij affect the ideological training of its members. How do the ideological outlook of Basijis change as they grow older? What happens when young Basijis begin to change their ideological outlook? What room is there for difference of opinion? What are some of the generational differences between the original generation of the Basij from the war and today's younger members? Do these generational changes offer any insight into the future trajectory of the Basij? Golkar states that after the war, many young people admit to the fact that they join the Basij for the material opportunities that the organization provides its members. If that is the case, then how do these material motivations effect the members’ political–ideological training? Are the young members acting “as if” they believe, in the same light as members of the Syrian governing forces in Lisa Weeden's analysis in Ambiguities of Domination: Politics, Rhetoric, and Symbols in Contemporary Syria (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999), or is something else going on? In the same vein, although Golkar does a comprehensive job in outlining the various kinds of Basij in society, more work can be done comparing the types of work that the Basij carry out in big cities such as Tehran, with the more socially organizing roles they take on in smaller towns and villages.
In spite of these questions, Golkar's monograph is an important sociological account of the ways in which the Islamic Republic imagines the Basij as the force that holds its society captive. Golkar clearly demonstrates that the Basij are the prism through which the Islamic Republic negotiates the terms of ideal citizenship and revolutionary morality.
