One would need look no further than the topic of disease in the early modern period to see how scholarship on the history of the Ottoman Empire continues to lag behind that of other parts of the world. While scholars of western European, Atlantic, and US history have pinned, in part, such weighty historical developments as the demise of feudalism in Europe and the emergence of the trans-Atlantic slave trade on epidemic diseases, Ottoman historians, until quite recently, were still working out the basic timeline of the appearance and spread of epidemic diseases in the early modern Ottoman Empire. Historiographically speaking, this geographic unevenness in disease histories has forced Ottoman imperial historians to fight a rearguard action against the twinned Orientalist tropes of Islamic fatalism and the Ottoman Empire as a perennial source of epidemic diseases.
Thanks to Nükhet Varlık we can now begin the process of putting this unhappy state of affairs behind us and look forward to a productive period of scholarship on epidemic diseases and their impact on the trajectory of the Ottoman Empire in the early modern period. In her magisterial Plague and Empire in the Early Modern Mediterranean World: The Ottoman Experience, 1347–1600, Varlık (bridging the chronological gap between the scholarship of Michael Dols and Lawrence Conrad on the medieval Islamic Middle East and Daniel Panzac and Süheyl Ünver on the 18th and 19th centuries) plugs the enormous hole in our knowledge of plague in the early modern Ottoman Empire. In and of itself this foundational spadework would constitute an immense service to the field. As an indication, however, of the tenacity and determination that is consistently on display throughout this book, Varlık labors on to erect the scaffolding for future scholarship on plague and disease in the early modern Ottoman Empire. Moreover, and perhaps most importantly, Varlık puts to rest, once and for all, the corrupted yet tenacious paradigm of the “fatalistic Turk” and the long-held belief of a one-way (i.e., east to west) transmission of plague in the early modern period. As a result of Varlık's hard work, we now have a firm understanding of the spread of plague in the Ottoman Empire in the early modern period, the first shoots of knowledge on the social and political consequences of epidemic diseases in the Ottoman context in the early modern period, and a more nuanced grasp of the complex networks of exchange that existed in the eastern Mediterranean in the 15th, 16th, and 17th centuries.
Although the book is organized around a chapter structure, it can more logically be divided into three sections. The first 130 pages or so are introductory in nature and are devoted to unpacking the historiography of plague in both Ottomanist and non-Ottomanist contexts. While such a long wind-up (occupying as it does roughly 40 percent of the book) might be considered problematic, this background discussion is essential for setting up and appreciating the groundbreaking aspects of Varlık's research. In these introductory sections Varlık rains blow after devastating blow to the Eurocentric historiography of early modern plague histories. Specifically, on pages 70–88 she systematically lays waste to what she terms the “epidemiological orientalism” (p. 88) embedded both in the memoirs of western travelers to the Ottoman Empire and the scholarship of western historians who rely almost exclusively on these travel accounts in their (now even more outdated) histories of the Ottoman Empire. As a subset of environmental history, disease studies are a natural point of convergence for the methodologies of the social and hard sciences and, in my estimation, Varlık herein provides us with a sterling example of the analytic utility of this combined methodological approach. Varlık's ability to “translate” the science surrounding disease into jargon-free historical writing is impressive, and is most obviously on display in the early parts of the book. Her sustained discussion of plague hosts, plague vectors, and the plague pathogen Yersinia pestis is a model of clarity.
The heftiest parts of this work are through the middle section as Varlık endeavors to plant her intellect on the terra incognita of the history of plague in the early modern Ottoman Empire. Drawing on an impressively broad and deep source base (consisting of Ottoman chronicles, Arabic plague treatises, Ottoman governmental archives, and primary and secondary accounts in a wide range of European languages) Varlık methodically takes the reader through a chronological overview of plague outbreaks in the early modern Ottoman Empire. In compensation for her heavy lifting here Varlık earns the right to make several important and thought-provoking points. Her arguments for the multidirectional flow of disease in the early modern eastern Mediterranean and on the connection between human mobility, trade, imperial expansion, and the spread of epidemic diseases are airtight and convincing.
The final section of the book is the most analytical. Focused almost exclusively (as Varlık herself admits) on Ottoman cities (principally Istanbul), Varlık engages in an intriguing discussion of what she terms the “naturalization” of plague in postconquest Istanbul. According to Varlık, by the end of the 16th century the Muslim inhabitants of Istanbul had come to accept disease as a regular feature of urban culture in their imperial capital. Quick to dispel any equation of this naturalization process with fatalistic acquiescence and/or passivity, Varlık notes that elites and those who could afford it consistently fled from disease-ridden parts of Istanbul. Additionally, she clearly demonstrates that in order to “sanitize” the city, both physically and spiritually, the Ottoman state developed and implemented innovative public health policies and regulations.
In places, Varlık seems to hedge her bets and the reader is often left with an unslaked thirst for more of Varlık's erudition. For example, early on she posits the notion of a “unified microbial zone of the Mediterranean” and later follows up with a reference to the circulation of medical knowledge in the early modern eastern Mediterranean. While these categories are alluded to (or implied) throughout this book, the reader is left wanting more from Varlık on the Mediterranean front. Additionally, the midstream shift in the analytical frame of the book from a birds-eye perspective on Ottoman imperial space to a ground-level look at plague in Istanbul is a tad jarring. It is a testimony, however, to Varlık's research ability and intellectual nimbleness that these slight shortcomings do not in any way detract from the overall originality of this book.
In a short epilogue, Varlık conscientiously lays out a future research agenda for plague in the early modern Ottoman Empire. Among her recommendations are: to begin the process of filling in the temporal and spatial spectrum of Ottoman plague histories during the expansionary early modern period; to open up, where sources allow, provincial and rural vistas on Ottoman plague histories; and, perhaps most importantly, to explore and develop further our understanding of how the environment affected “the etiology and epidemiology of plague in the diverse Ottoman landscape” (p. 293). Finally, Varlık makes a strong case for more comparative scholarship on disease and empire. To the list of empires (Ottoman, Mughal, Safavid, and Habsburg) which Varlık identifies as worthy subjects for further comparative study, I would add the Russian Empire, given the many and varied ecological zones encountered by the expansionary Russian state.
