Particularly in English-speaking countries, Max Reger (1873–1916) is most immediately identified with his organ music, a corpus that claims about 20 per cent of a voluminous oeuvre, comprising 146 opus numbers and many other works. In these two significant recordings, Henrico Stewen offers a thoughtful survey of pieces originating between 1899 and 1902, Reger's most intensive period of composition for the instrument that embodied for him the spirit of his idol, Johann Sebastian Bach. Both discs document organs from the composer's time that have undergone painstaking restorations in recent years. The earlier recording features the Wilhelm Sauer organ of the iconic St Thomas Church in Leipzig, built in 1889 and, after much alteration in the last century, now returned to the 1908 specification designed by Reger's principal interpreter, the St Thomas organist and later Thomaskantor Karl Straube. For the more recent disc, Stewen plays an organ built in 1909 by the Sauer pupil Eskil Lundén, an instrument given a similarly sympathetic refurbishment that honours its roots in the post-Wagnerian sound aesthetics of early modernism.
With one exception – the prelude Vater unser im Himmelreich from the Orgelbüchlein-like chorale collection Op. 67 – Stewen delivers two weighty programmes of non-chorale-based music, much of it infrequently heard even by organ audiences, but certainly a fair representation of Reger's extraordinary creative energies directed toward the organ in these years. The earlier disc includes the 1899 Introduction and Passacaglia WoO IV/6, the third of several such works for both organ and piano on the apparent model of BWV 582; the Toccata, Fugue and Benedictus from Op. 59, the latter probably still Reger's most played organ work; the Canzona from Op. 65; the Vater unser prelude from Op. 67; and the great leviathan of Reger's organ music, if not of his entire oeuvre, the Symphonic Fantasy and (double) Fugue Op. 57, also known as Inferno. Stewen constructs the second disc along similar lines: the Introduction and Passacaglia in F minor (perhaps the most undeservedly neglected of all these works) and the Prelude and Fugue in C minor/major, both pairs from the Monologue Op. 63; three further pieces from Op. 59; and the monumental Fantasy and (again, double) Fugue on BACH Op. 46, dedicated to the elderly Rheinberger as a response to Liszt's essay on the familiar cipher.
As both performers and listeners who have struggled with Reger's idiom know, this music often threatens to descend into a fragmented chaos of short motives that generate unrelentingly dense chromaticism and long stretches of opaque counterpoint. Probably more trenchantly than anyone else, Dahlhaus observes a ‘precarious … relationship between technique and expression’, or put more pointedly, ‘between rhetoric and pedantry’ in Reger.Footnote 1 Stewen almost entirely avoids the pitfalls of this dialectic with a finished technique, scrupulous attention to phrasing and musical motion, and a lively approach to the kaleidoscopic colour palette of both instruments. These recordings do their part to debunk the old myth that the organs of Reger's period, based so heavily in fundamental tone, more nearly obfuscate than clarify the composer's textures. For the earlier recording, Stewen has chosen to play two works from Op. 59 – the Toccata and Fugue in D minor/major and the Benedictus – from the editions of Reger's advocate Karl Straube, published in 1919 and 1912 respectively. As has been much discussed, both editions depart considerably in crucial respects from Reger's original, but Straube furnishes them with detailed registrations and manual changes that are clearly based on the St Thomas organ's stoplist. The remaining pieces on both discs are orchestrated – a fair word in this context – in Straube's style. Here, organist and instrument combine to offer authoritative renderings of music that has often suffered from reactionary efforts either to dismiss Reger or to rehabilitate his musical language according to the aesthetic standards of modernist Sachlichkeit.
From the performer's liner notes to these recordings, it is clear that Stewen intends both of them as a kind of aural appendix to his brief doctoral thesis at the Sibelius Academy in Helsinki, a revised version of which appeared in 2008.Footnote 2 Stewen here offers a theory, based on the controversial work of Willem Talsma concerning music of a hundred years earlier, that Reger notated metronome marks according to a double-beat system until about 1908, so that the music should proceed at (usually) half the tempo seemingly indicated.Footnote 3 For example, Stewen claims that the beginning of the Benedictus Op. 59 No. 9, notated by its composer at crotchet=64, is meant to be played at quaver=64, more sensibly corresponding to Reger's Adagio marking.
Particularly for those familiar with these works, this approach can produce some striking results. To take one of the most radical instances, illustrated by comparison to some other recent recordings: the gigantic Symphonic Fantasy and Fugue Op. 57 requires just short of 17 hectic minutes in the performance of Rosalinde Haas (1989), just over 22 minutes when played by Franz Hauk (2000), and just over 20 minutes in Edgar Krapp's interpretation (2006).Footnote 4 By contrast, Stewen's recording of 2011 issues the listener into a work of 35 minutes’ duration: the 142-bar fugue alone demands a long arch of almost 19 minutes. In this case, Stewen derives the tempi from a set of metronome marks provided by Straube for his pupil Heinz Wunderlich much after the fact in 1940, and interpreted here in double-beat terms.Footnote 5
Stewen's approach is motivated first by the fact that Reger's own metronome marks are nearly impossible to realize, or at least that one cannot reconcile them with the composer's Italian performance indications (as with the Benedictus). Second, Straube's own metronome marks in his editions and elsewhere tend more or less to halve those of Reger, a circumstance that has given rise to protracted discussions about Straube's fidelity to or misunderstanding of the composer's intentions. In the case of the 1912 ‘practical’ edition of the so-called Little Organ Mass from Op. 59, Straube's solutions are advertised on the title page ‘with the approval of the composer’.Footnote 6
It is not too much to say that Stewen presents his tempo theory as gospel, or as a relatively straightforward key to clarify a multidimensional question long recognized as central to Reger's music. There are many problems with this largely counterintuitive argument which Stewen does not address: there is no direct evidence from the composer or from anyone in his orbit that Reger adhered to a double-beat system, Talsma's thesis is accepted outright without critical analysis, and no justification is offered for retrofitting a theory about tempo in the Beethoven era to one about tempo in the Reger era.Footnote 7 Further and more crucially, we cannot know with certainty what role the assignment of metronome indications played in Reger's compositional process. (Did he arrive at the numbers while trying out passages at a piano, or at a writing desk, with a metronome at hand or from memory?) These kinds of questions invite a thorough investigation of tempo in Reger's music generally, along the methodological lines that used by Siegwart Reichwald for Mendelssohn and Bernard Sherman for Brahms.Footnote 8
Of course, Reger, Straube, and others repeatedly admonished performers to moderate tempo, particularly to slow down the fast passages. Stewen does not speak seriously to the possibility that the composer simply might have shot wide of the mark concerning tempo, a circumstance the composer himself admits, and one that plausibly may be inferred from what we know about his own performances. In his study of contemporary reception, Hermann Wilske convincingly shows that the pianist Reger, particularly in the early years that produced the works Stewen plays, was prone to exaggerated or even arbitrary tempi in performance.Footnote 9 Wilske further suggests that Reger may have employed his metronome marks as a way to define the outer edge of an acceptable tempo rubato.Footnote 10
Despite all this, Stewen's basic musical instinct is certainly right that fast tempi do no favours to this composer's dense musical arguments, and the aural results are worth repeated hearings. It is much better to have the probing performances on these recordings than to continue, as many organists do, in the assumption that Reger's music should sound as fast as it looks on paper. And the positive in Stewen's supporting academic work is to have renewed interest in questions of tempo as a – indeed perhaps the – decisive key to Reger.
