Holiday in Mexico is an important contribution to tourism studies, a relatively new interdisciplinary field that emerged in the 1970s and achieved scholarly legitimacy with the publication of John Urry's The Tourist's Gaze: Leisure and Travel in Contemporary Societies (Sage, 1990). Tourism scholars from geography, anthropology, history, urban studies and area studies critically interrogate the institutions and practices of a modern form of leisure travel that involves what Urry has defined as the production and consumption of places, images, icons and signs. Tourism is ‘extra-ordinary’ in that it is a practice performed outside the safe familiarity of one's everyday life; indeed, the encounter with the other and otherness is central to the tourist experience.
The editors of this volume, Dina Berger and Andrew Grant Wood, have assembled a collection of 12 essays that survey the political, economic and cultural history of tourism in Mexico and the production of the tourist experience from the mid-nineteenth century to the present day. The volume is loosely organised chronologically. The first essay by Andrea Boardman proposes that the US–Mexican War marks the ‘beginnings of American tourism in Mexico’ and classifies US soldiers as the first tourists who encountered Mexico through a ‘tourist gaze’. Barbara Kastelein's concluding essay, ‘The Beach and Beyond: Observations from a Travel Writer on Dreams, Decadence, and Defense,’ explores the future of tourism in Mexico through her perceptive analysis of three different sites: Acapulco, Oaxaca and Amecameca.
The remaining ten essays examine the ways in which tourism was invented and revised through the independent and cooperative efforts of the various stakeholders in the tourist system: federal and local administrative bodies, business communities, and national and regional cultural promoters, as well as foreign and domestic tourists in search of pleasurable, educational and exotic experiences. As the essays in this volume reveal, the growth of the Mexican tourist industry in the twentieth century developed through the multifaceted efforts of official initiatives and policies, business entrepreneurship, the expansion of transportation systems and interstate and international highway systems, and the active participation of diverse cultural groups. Mexico as a tourist destination was created through the blending of two seemingly contradictory discourses: on the one hand an archaeological and anthropological history that glorified a mysterious indigenous past, and on the other, the production of a globally inflected modern place that was both exotic and up to date, safe yet exciting.
While the federal government and private industry certainly had a hand in this history, research into various geographic destinations reveals the roles that local governments, cultural groups and individuals, as well as tourists themselves, had in the expansion of tourism from Acapulco in the west to the Yucatán in the east and numerous regions in between. Individual essays consider the range of actors who participated in Mexican tourism, including the state, business owners, tourist industry workers – such as hotel owners and service workers, tour guides, entrepreneurial craft producers and vendors – and tourists themselves, and closely examine a number of major destinations developed as tourism centres, such as Veracruz, Tijuana, Oaxaca, Teotihuacán, the Yucatán peninsula and Acapulco. Some of the essays concentrate on particular themes that emerge as central to the production and practice of Mexican tourism and tourist destinations, such as archaeological sites and the promotion of Mexican national identity, tourism as a leisure activity, fun and relaxation, and cultural and educational experiences.
The essays differ in their focus: some are concerned with political and economic histories of tourism; others may be categorised as cultural histories that focus on tourists, the tourist experience, or the Mexicans who are the objects of the tourists' gaze. One of the strengths of such an expansive survey is its ability to reveal the changing dynamics of Mexico's tourist industry over time and across certain discrete locations. However, as with many broadly focused anthologies, the essays are uneven. While the editors provide a useful introduction and conclusion that frame the particular history of Mexico's tourist industry within the context of tourist studies in general, not all of the essays productively engage with the important and extensive literature on critical tourist studies.
Unfortunately, one of the weakest essays, Andrea Boardman's ‘The U.S.–Mexican War and the Beginnings of American Tourism in Mexico’, is the first essay the reader encounters. Boardman argues that US soldiers who fought on Mexican soil during the war from 1846 to 1848 can be seen as proto-tourists, as they learned how to see as a tourist does and communicated what they saw to families and a wider public. The essay is undertheorised and lacks concrete historical references to substantiate the author's claims. The author, for example, alludes to ‘the imperial gaze, the male gaze, and the tourist gaze’, concepts that are central to tourism studies, but never elaborates on the distinctions between these three gazes. There is a rich literature on the imperial gaze, including the work of Edward Said, Mary Louise Pratt and E. Ann Kaplan, to name a few; on the tourist gaze, first introduced by Urry (to whom Boardman refers as ‘one scholar’); and volumes of work on the male gaze in film and visual culture studies. Boardman's analysis engages with none of this work.
The strongest essays are informed by careful historical research and analysis that reveal the ways in which modern tourism in Mexico developed in different regions over the past hundred years. Andrew Grant Wood's ‘On the Selling of Rey Momo: Early Tourism and the Marketing of Carnival in Veracruz’ traces the history of Veracruz from its founding in the sixteenth century by Hernán Cortés through its transformation from a lawless port town into a ‘folkloric and modern’ domestic tourist destination during the decade following post-revolutionary conflicts. Christina Bueno's ‘Teotihuacán: Showcase for the Centennial’ addresses one of the central draws of Mexican tourism, its archaeological sites. Focusing on the production of Teotihuacán as a tourist destination that would serve to promote Porfirio Diáz's project to construct and reify an indigenous Mexican past, the essay shows how the regime was able successfully to tap into and take advantage of both the rise of scholarly interest in archaeology in the late nineteenth century and a new passion among US and European tourists to visit historical and archaeological sites.
Berger's ‘Goodwill Ambassadors on Holiday: Tourism, Diplomacy, and Mexico–U. S. Relations’ looks at the ‘role that tourism has played as a vehicle of cultural relations and diplomacy’ in Mexico and in other national contexts (p. 109). The essay offers a well-theorised account of the relationship between tourism, official policy and transnational cultural relations. It interrogates the meaning of diplomacy and the ways in which various social actors, not just those representing the nation-state, play a part in negotiating and promoting cross-border cooperation in business, politics and cultural exchange. Other essays interrogate the role of nation-building, often at the expense of local inhabitants; the efforts of certain regions and individual towns to distinguish themselves by highlighting various kinds of tourist experiences; and the fine line the tourist industry had to walk in its cultivation of cultural stereotypes that often proved to be the biggest draw for foreign tourists. Overall, Holiday in Mexico offers students of contemporary Mexican history and culture an important account of the development and transformation of a national and regional tourist industry in Mexico.
